Why Kids Say Unfiltered Things: What My 7-Year-Old’s Funny Blunt Comment Taught Me
It’s 7:15 on a Tuesday, I’m sitting on the edge of my 7-year-old Mia’s bed pulling on socks after helping her dig out a missing gym shoe from under her toy bin. My sister is on speakerphone, and she just mailed me the cropped floral sweater for my birthday that I’d pointed out a few weeks prior. I hold it up to my chest, squint at the mirror propped on Mia’s dresser, and ask my sister, “Do you think this makes me look old? I feel like cropped tops are for college kids now, not 36-year-olds who pay a mortgage.”
Mia’s cross-legged on the floor sorting her slime collection by stretchiness, doesn’t even look up from her work. She just blurts, “Yeah. You look way older than all the moms at my soccer practice. Like, grandma old.”
I snort-laughed so hard I fell back onto Mia’s comforter covered in unicorn stickers. My sister started cackling so loud the speaker crackled. Mia finally looked up, slime oozing between her fingers, confused. “What? It’s true. Your hair has that gray streak like Grandma’s, and the sweater has flowers like Grandma’s sweaters. That’s just how it is.”
It took me a full five minutes to stop laughing enough to get us out the door for school, but that comment stuck with me all week. For the past year or so, I’ve seen dozens of posts in my local mom group about how to handle blunt, unfiltered kid comments. Parents get upset because their kid said someone was fat, or their new haircut was ugly, or their aunt’s perfume smelled like garbage, and everyone chimes in with advice: you need to correct them immediately, teach them manners young, don’t let them get away with being rude. I’ve been that parent before, too. Six months ago, Mia told our 82-year-old neighbor that her walker looked like a shopping cart, and I apologized so profusely I probably made the whole thing more awkward than it needed to be, then fussed at Mia in the car all the way home.
But after the sweater comment, I started thinking more about what’s actually going on when kids say these things. Mia wasn’t trying to hurt my feelings. She wasn’t being disrespectful. She was just telling me the fact, as she saw it. Kids between 6 and 9 are still figuring out that not every question people ask is asking for the actual truth. Adults walk around with all these unwritten rules: we ask “do I look old” because we want reassurance, not honesty; we ask “do you like the gift” because we want the other person to feel good, not to hear that you hate orange sweaters. Kids haven’t learned those rules yet. That’s a developmental step, not a character flaw.
After I stopped laughing that morning, I didn’t scold her. I just said, “Okay, that’s fair. Why do you think that, anyway?” Which is the first thing I now tell other parents to do when their kid says something blunt: ask first, scold later. Asking what they mean gives you context, nine times out of ten there’s no malice, just literal kid logic that makes total sense to them. If I’d snapped and said “that’s rude, we don’t talk to people that way” right away, Mia would have just ended up upset and confused, and I would have missed the whole funny, straightforward logic of her thought process. If we’re in public and the comment is awkward for someone else, I just smile and say “She tells it like it is!” to defuse the tension, then talk about it later when we’re alone, so Mia doesn’t get embarrassed in front of a crowd.
The second thing I’ve started doing that works is talking about social rules plainly, instead of just calling her rude. If the comment hurts my feelings, or I know it would hurt someone else’s, I say that directly, instead of expecting her to read my mind. For example, after the wedding a few months back where Mia told my great-aunt her purple hair looked like a melted grape popsicle, I didn’t yell at her in front of the whole family. I just pulled her aside to get a glass of lemonade and said, “Aunt Linda picked out that purple hair because she really likes it, and she asked what you thought because she wanted to feel good about it. Next time someone asks you what you think of their new look, you can find one small thing to say that’s nice, even if you don’t love the whole thing. Like, you could say it’s really bright and cool, even if you don’t think it looks good.” That’s specific, it’s concrete, she knows exactly what I’m asking her to do, instead of just being told “be polite” which means nothing to a 7-year-old.
I also don’t force her to lie outright, which is a line I’ve landed on after a lot of trial and error. I don’t make her say she loves a Christmas gift from a distant cousin that she actually thinks is boring. I just tell her she has to say thank you, and that’s enough. She’ll learn to soften the truth over time as she gets better at reading other people’s feelings, but pushing her to be fake when she’s young just doesn’t make sense to me.
Mia still says unfiltered things all the time. Last week she told our neighbor his new lawn gnome was creepy and looked like it would steal socks. It still catches me off guard, and I still get a little twinge of embarrassment when we’re in public. But I’d rather have a kid who tells the truth honestly than one who’s already learned to hide what she thinks to make adults comfortable. We’re still figuring out where the line is between being kind and being real, and some days we get it wrong. So far, though, asking first and correcting gently later has worked a lot better than scolding ever did.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Say Unfiltered Things: What My 7-Year-Old’s Funny Blunt Comment Taught Me