Why Kids Remind You “I Did This” (And How To Respond Without Frustration)
Last Tuesday, I stood in my entryway crumbs from my 4-year-old’s pop-tart stuck to my sweatpants, patting down every pocket for my car keys and mentally running through the list of things we couldn’t leave home without. Water bottles? Check. Permission slip for the field trip? Check. “Mia,” I called over my shoulder to my 7-year-old, “did you feed Nibbles yet? We can’t come back all day if you forgot.”
She stopped yanking her backpack zipper shut, crossed her arms over her chest, and said, sharp but not yelling, “Keep in mind I did this. I did it right after breakfast.”
I was so frazzled I almost brushed her off with a distracted “Okay okay, let’s go” like I had the three other times she’d said that exact line in the past week. Once when I asked if she’d packed her library books, once when I checked if she’d finished her math homework before screen time. I’d always written it off as sassy backtalk, just another sign that second grade attitude was kicking in. But that morning, standing there with my hands still empty of keys, I stopped. What if it wasn’t attitude?
I found my keys in the fridge, right next to the half-gallon of milk where I’d set them while grabbing a snack, and drove to school. Waiting in the drop-off line, I thought about the parent-teacher conference I’d had two days before with Mia’s teacher, Ms. Lopez. She’d mentioned that more than half her class this year is constantly checking in that they’ve done their work, that they’ve followed the rules, that they didn’t forget what they were supposed to do. She said it’s not that they’re being defensive. It’s that they’re finally old enough to take on small responsibilities, but they haven’t figured out how to ask to be trusted yet.
A lot of the time, she said, we ask kids if they did something out of habit, not because we actually think they forgot. If a kid has fed the class hamster for a month straight, we still ask every day. If they’ve packed their own backpack for two weeks, we still double-check. That constant checking adds up. For a kid who’s trying to prove they can handle it, one extra question feels like we don’t believe they can do it at all. So they come back with “Keep in mind I did this” because that’s the only way they know how to say that.
After drop-off, I sat in the parking lot and made a quick list of the things Mia was supposed to do every day that I still asked her about twice. Feed Nibbles. Pack her library books on Sundays. Put her homework in her folder after she finishes. Bring her dirty soccer clothes in from the car after practice. I counted seven things. Seven things she’d been doing on her own for at least a month, that I still nagged her about out of habit. I wasn’t helping her— I was telling her I didn’t think she could do it.
I started testing small changes the next day. The first thing I changed was my response when she did tell me she’d already finished something. Before, I’d just mumble okay and move on to the next thing on my list. Now, I pause for two seconds and say something specific about her remembering, not just the task. Instead of “Okay, hurry up,” I say “Thanks for getting that done early, that takes one thing off my plate.” It takes no extra time, it’s just a couple more words, but the difference is noticeable. Before, she’d huff and walk away still annoyed. Now she just nods and moves on to what she was doing.
The second change I made was cutting one reminder per chore every two weeks. I used to remind her to feed Nibbles when she woke up, then again when we were leaving. Now I just remind her once when she wakes up, and if I almost ask the second time, I bite my tongue. If she brings it up unprompted with her “Keep in mind I did this” line, I just acknowledge it like we talked about. It’s been three weeks, and she hasn’t forgotten once.
It’s not like this fixed everything. I still slip up. Two nights ago, I asked her if she’d packed her gym clothes for PE the next day, even though she’d been packing her own clothes for PE every week for two months. She looked up from her coloring and said, “Keep in mind I did this” with a big eye roll, and I snapped back that there was no reason to be rude about it. We both went to bed a little mad, and the next morning I apologized. I told her I shouldn’t have asked again when she’s been doing it all on her own, that it was my habit, not her fault. She just shrugged and said, “It’s okay. It just feels weird when you ask me every time, like you think I’ll mess up.”
That’s the part no one tells you, I think. When kids start taking on small responsibilities, our job isn’t just to make sure they get the thing done. It’s to step back and let them show us they can do it, even if that means they forget once in a while. It’s way easier to just ask again and avoid the hassle of a forgotten hamster feeding or a missing gym shirt, but that small hassle is how they learn to keep track of things on their own. And when they remind you they already did the thing, that’s not backtalk. That’s them telling you they’re learning, too.
Lately, Mia has started coming to me first, before I even have to ask. She’ll walk in after school and say “I put my homework in my folder already” or “I brought all my library books back to the front hall.” I just say “That’s great, you handled that” and that’s it. There are still mornings where we’re both frazzled, where I ask a stupid question and she gives me a sassy answer. But it happens less than it used to be. I still catch myself reaching for that extra question some days, but now I just stop and remember: she’s got this. I just have to let her show me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Remind You “I Did This” (And How To Respond Without Frustration)