Why kids refuse school photos: what I learned from an impromptu 10-minute photo shoot at home
The camera app on my phone is still open to the shots I took 10 minutes ago, the crumpled blue button-down my son refused to wear is draped over the back of the dining chair, and the dinosaur sticker he peeled off my camera lens is stuck to the fridge. Ten minutes ago, my 8-year-old walked over to the plain white wall by our front door, said “I’m ready now,” and we knocked out the photo shoot we needed for his school ID in 10 minutes flat. I posted the first shot to my stories this morning with the line, “Here’s my photo shoot I just did 10 minutes ago. Let me know your thoughts!” and by now I have a dozen comments from other parents asking how I pulled it off. Two years in a row, my son refused to sit for the school’s fall portrait day, so I get the question.
Two years ago, first grade, he hid behind the gym bleachers and cried so hard the only photo the school got was a blurry shot of his shoulder peeking out next to a basketball hoop. Last year, second grade, he refused to leave his teacher’s side, so his spot on the class composite is just a blank white box. I don’t care much about fancy printed portraits, but the school needs a headshot for the yearbook and his hallway ID badge, so this year I decided to skip the school shoot entirely and try it at home.
I cleared off the wall by the front door yesterday, propped my phone up on a stack of books against the counter, and laid the blue button-down I’d bought out on the dining table. I even washed it three times to get the stiff, chemical new-fabric smell and scratch out, because I know that stiffness makes his skin crawl. I didn’t set a hard time to do it. I just told him after breakfast that the space was ready, and he could come do it whenever he felt like it. He went back to building his Lego T-Rex, I went back to folding laundry, and 10 minutes ago he wandered over, wiped his hands on his jeans, and said he was ready.
He looked at the button-down, looked back at me, and said “Can I wear my green dinosaur hoodie instead? It doesn’t itch.” The school’s email said “collared shirts preferred” but I shrugged and said sure. Then he said he didn’t want to stand still and smile “like a robot” the way the school photographer makes kids do. I remembered him telling me after last year’s failed shoot that the big flash hurts his eyes, the stranger with the big camera makes his chest feel tight, and holding a smile for what feels like forever makes his face ache. So I said, we don’t have to do any of that. What do you want to do for your photo?
He said he wanted to do a real photo shoot, like the toy reviewers he watches on YouTube, where he gets to show his favorite thing. So he ran and grabbed the half-built Lego T-Rex he’d been working on all morning, held it up against his chest, and I hit countdown. Three clicks, one silly face for me, one straight-on for the school, and it was done. No crying, no hiding, no me bribing him with a popsicle after an hour of coaxing. It was all over in 10 minutes, just like I said.
It’s not some fancy trick I pulled off, honestly. It’s just a small shift I’ve made the past couple years with my sensory-sensitive kid that I wish I’d figured out sooner: we spend so much time making kids fit the existing rules that we forget most of the rules for these small, mundane things are flexible, and bending them barely matters to anyone but the kid.
I know a lot of parents see their kid refuse a photo, or any other common school task, and immediately think they did something wrong, or that their kid needs to “just learn” to do it the normal way. I’ve been there. I spent an hour fighting him to pose for a soccer photo last spring, and we both ended up upset, and the photo still came out bad. This time was different because I didn’t ask him to adapt to the photo — I adapted the photo to him.
If your kid also refuses school portraits, the first thing you can do is just email the school and ask if you can submit your own. Most people don’t know this, but almost every elementary school will say yes, especially if you explain your kid struggles with the crowd and the unfamiliar photographer. Our office secretary told me last week that at least 10 families do this every year now. You don’t need a fancy camera, either — a phone photo in natural light by a plain wall works just fine.
Next, leave the set-up out and don’t nag. I had the wall ready all morning, and I let my kid come to it when he was done with his play, instead of yanking him away from what he was enjoying to get it over with. Let him pick his clothes, even if it’s not what the school suggested. A kid in a comfortable hoodie will pose far better than a kid scratching at a stiff new collared shirt the whole time. Skip the flash if they hate it — open a window, use natural light, it’s more than enough. And skip the forced smile too. If they want to hold a favorite toy, let them. 9 times out of 10, the school just needs a clear shot of their face, they don’t care if a dinosaur peeks over their shoulder.
I’m not saying this fixes everything, or that every photo shoot from now on will go this smoothly. Next time we need a formal photo for something, he might still hide, and I’ll have to try something new. I still don’t know what all the people who commented on my post think of the photo, honestly. But when we were done, my son leaned over my shoulder to look at the shot, nodded, and said “That looks like me.” That’s more than any forced school portrait ever got us, and it was done in 10 minutes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why kids refuse school photos: what I learned from an impromptu 10-minute photo shoot at home