Why Kids Quit New Activities: Maybe It Was Only The First Part That Felt Hard
The rain streaked the minivan windows last month when Lila, my 8-year-old, ripped her shin guard off and hurled it into the back row with a thud. “I’m never going back to soccer,” she said, crossing her arms and staring out at the parking lot puddles. I gripped the steering wheel and counted to three. We’d bought the cleats two weeks earlier, she’d decorated her water bottle with unicorn stickers, and I’d already paid the full season registration fee. My first thought was the one I’ve had a dozen times before: She just can’t stick with anything.
She’d begged for three months to play, after watching her older cousin score three goals at a rec tournament. I wasn’t surprised; she’d been kicking a ball around the yard since she was five. The first practice, she hung back by the coach the whole time, didn’t talk to any of the other girls. The second practice, she cried in the car before we left, said no one would pass her the ball. I told her it just takes time to make friends. I thought that was the whole issue.
I didn’t bring it up right away that night. I used to lecture immediately about commitment and not giving up, but that never works. I was folding socks at the kitchen table while she colored a cat for her teacher, so I just wiped crumbs off the table and said, “I noticed you spent a lot of time by the fence at practice yesterday. What was going through your head out there?”
She didn’t look up for a minute, then said, “No one told me how to do a throw-in. Coach explained it on the first day, I didn’t get it, and everyone else already knows. When the ball goes out of bounds, I just stand there because I don’t want to do it wrong and everyone laughs.”
Oh. That hit me. I’d thought her quitting was the whole story. I’d already mapped the entire arc: she wanted to try, it wasn’t as fun as she thought, she quits. But it wasn’t the whole story. It was only the first part. The awkward, unspoken, I’m too embarrassed to ask part.
I didn’t email the coach that night complaining she didn’t teach throw-ins right. I didn’t sign Lila up for private lessons. I just said, “That makes sense. That sounds really uncomfortable. Want to go out in the yard after school tomorrow and practice throw-ins for 10 minutes before we get the frozen yogurt you like?” She nodded, and went back to coloring.
Next day, we went out. I didn’t even know the exact rules for a rec league throw-in, honestly. I just showed her what I remembered: feet behind the line, bring it over your head, throw it. Most of her throws landed at my feet, or went sideways into the rose bush. On the fifth try, she threw it all the way to the other end of the yard, past the picnic table. She jumped up and down yelling. That was it. 10 minutes, that’s all.
Next practice, the ball went out of bounds right near her, and she picked it up. She did the throw-in, right to a girl on her team, who kicked it and almost scored. After practice, she ran to the car talking about it the whole way.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately, because it’s not just soccer. Last year, my neighbor’s third grader told his mom he hated writing and refused to turn in homework. They almost had him tested before they stopped to ask what was actually wrong. Turns out he’d messed up spelling “dinosaur” on his first story of the year, the kid next to him made fun of him, and he decided he was bad at all writing. That was only the first part. When my sister’s kindergartener refused to go to nap time, it wasn’t that he wasn’t tired—it was that the first week he wet his pants during nap, and he was scared it would happen again. Only the first part.
We get so used to the narrative that kids quit because they lack persistence, or they’re bored, or they just want to stay home and play games. That makes it easy to either lecture them about commitment or just cancel the activity and move on. But most of the time, the “I hate this, I quit” line is just the end of the first uncomfortable chunk of learning something new. Kids aren’t good at breaking down what’s wrong. They feel the whole thing is bad, because one small part is really bad.
The small shifts I’ve made that work pretty well are straightforward. When my kid says they want to quit, I don’t lecture and I don’t agree immediately. I just say, “Can you tell me the worst part of this right now?” That question almost always gets a more specific answer than “I just don’t like it.” Then, we tackle that one specific part, not the whole activity. We don’t need hours of practice, we don’t need to hire an expert. 10 minutes a day for a few days is almost always enough to get over the initial hump. After that, I let them decide. If they still want to quit, that’s fine. We quit art classes two months into the semester last year after Lila told me the store-bought glue the teacher used made her head hurt. That turned out to be the whole thing, not just the first part, and that’s okay.
Last week, Lila tripped over her own cleats during a scrimmage and got grass stains all over her new unicorn jersey. She came to the car laughing so hard she could barely breathe, and told me she’d gotten back up and passed the ball anyway. Some Saturday mornings she still drags her feet getting out of bed, and she still says soccer is stupid when her team loses. But now when she says that, I just ask “Which part?” More often than not, it’s just a small first part we haven’t sorted out yet. I don’t know if she’ll play soccer next year. I do know I’ll stop assuming the first “I quit” is the whole story, from now on.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Quit New Activities: Maybe It Was Only The First Part That Felt Hard