Why Kids Play Separate From Each Other On Playdates (And What To Do About It)
Last Saturday, I stirred lemonade on the kitchen counter and listened to the too-quiet living room, where my 7-year-old Lila was hosting her soccer friend Mia for their third playdate. I’d dumped out goldfish crackers, wiped down the craft table, and hidden the tiny Barbie shoes that always get lost under the couch, so I was pretty sure the silence didn’t mean someone was drawing on the wall. I wiped my wet hand on my jeans and peeked around the door frame anyway. Lila was bent over her slime kit, kneading neon green goop and humming that Encanto song she can’t stop singing. Ten feet away on the rug, Mia was stacking a Lego castle, completely absorbed. They hadn’t spoken a full sentence to each other in 15 minutes. I felt that familiar little twitch of panic—this is a failure, right? They’re supposed to play together. I’d half stepped into the room, ready to prompt Lila to show Mia her new unicorn stickers, when I stopped. That old habit of fixing it before it’s broken had gotten me into awkward spots before.
A couple years ago, when Lila was just starting kindergarten, I’d have jumped right in. When a classmate came over and the two of them settled into separate activities, I’d badgered them to play tag, to work on a puzzle together, to “have fun like good friends.” By the end of that playdate, both kids were cranky, the mom left 20 minutes early, and I’d convinced myself I was terrible at hosting. It wasn’t until I talked to Lila’s first grade teacher at a fall conference that I started to rethink everything. She mentioned offhand that most parents think parallel play is just for toddlers, but kids keep using it way into elementary school. It’s not that they don’t like each other, she said. It’s that it’s low pressure. When you’re still getting to be friends, you don’t have to perform “fun” the whole time.
That Saturday with Mia, I pulled back from the door, went back to stirring my lemonade, and got back to folding the laundry I’d left on the counter. I left them alone. Twenty minutes later, I heard a snort that made me look up. Mia had wandered over, poked Lila’s slime, and said it smelled like rotten strawberries. They both dissolved into laughter, messed around with the goop for 15 minutes, then Lila got bored, wandered back to the couch to read her Dog Man graphic novel, and Mia returned to finishing her castle. No drama, no one was upset.
When Mia’s mom came to pick her up an hour later, she glanced in the living room and laughed, “They’re not even playing together, huh?” A year ago I would have apologized, started rambling about how they had fun earlier, blamed myself for not pulling out the right group game. This time I just smiled and said, “They’ve been flipping back and forth all afternoon. It works for them.” Then Mia popped up from the rug, said “I had so much fun, your sticker bin is better than the one at the bookstore,” and Lila chimed in that she got to try Mia’s new rainbow Lego brick. Both kids were happy, no one felt forced.
I started keeping track after that, how often this plays out. At birthday parties, at park meetups, even when I volunteer in Lila’s classroom. A lot of the time, kids are happier doing separate activities in the same space than they are being forced into a group game that only one of them wants to play. We as parents have this unspoken rule that a successful playdate means constant joint interaction. We see the photos of kids huddled around the same board game laughing, so we think anything less is a problem. But the truth is, for most elementary-aged kids, separate play in the same space is a tool. It’s how they warm up to a new friend, it’s how they recharge if they get overwhelmed by social interaction, it’s how they get to be together without the pressure of having to entertain each other every second.
The changes I’ve made to how I handle playdates are small, no fancy rearranging or big conversations required. First, I only step in if someone comes to me upset. If my kid says the other won’t play with them, or the guest looks bored and anxious, I’ll help them brainstorm an activity they both might like. But if both are quietly occupied, I leave them be. I never ask “why aren’t you guys playing together?” that just makes kids self-conscious. If I check in, I just ask if anyone needs a snack or a drink, no extra commentary. Second, I set up our play space to let this happen naturally. Our main play area is open in the back of the living room, so I’ve kept the craft table, Lego rug, and reading nook all within sight of each other. Kids can do their own thing without being far apart, and they can shift to playing together whenever they want. I don’t clear everything out to set up a group activity unless they ask for it. Third, I don’t apologize for it to other parents. Most of the time, once I mention my kid does this all the time, they agree their kid does the exact same thing at home.
I still catch that little twitch of panic sometimes. Two weeks ago, my cousin brought her 8-year-old daughter over for the afternoon, and they sat on opposite ends of the couch for the first hour: one coloring, one watching YouTube clips on a tablet, barely talking. I stood in the kitchen for five minutes, debating whether I should suggest they bake cookies or pull out the board games. I ended up just sitting down and finishing my coffee, leaving them be. By the end of the afternoon, they were mixing cookie dough together, covered in sprinkles, laughing so hard they could barely stand. It didn’t happen because I forced it. It happened because they were ready. I don’t think every playdate has to end with kids playing the same game the whole time. Sometimes, just being in the same room, doing your own thing, is enough. That’s the part I’m still getting used to, but so far, it’s worked out way better than my old habit of fixing things that weren’t broken.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Play Separate From Each Other On Playdates (And What To Do About It)