Why Kids Lose the Ability to Ask Questions They Don’t Know To Ask, And What To Do About It
Last Wednesday, after morning recess, I carried a bag of potting mix and a baggie of dried lima beans into my 4th grade classroom. We were starting our germination experiment, and I’d decided to skip the pre-written worksheet this time around. I wanted kids to come up with their own questions about what makes seeds grow. Most kids crowded the front table, grabbing clear cups and paper towels, chattering about whether they would grow their beans in the dark or by the window. Mia just sat at her desk, twisting the end of her braid, staring at an empty cup in front of her.
I knelt down next to her, brushing a stray piece of potting mix off my jeans. “Something stuck?” I asked. She shrugged. “I don’t know what to ask. The worksheet usually tells me.” I paused, because I’d seen this a dozen times this year. Kids who can pull a full essay on photosynthesis off a screen in 30 seconds, but can’t name one thing they’re curious about that they haven’t already been told to study.
After class, I thought about Javi, from last semester. He’d done a project on local birds, and the week he was supposed to work on it, his family’s internet went out. He couldn’t look up a list of common backyard birds like everyone else, so he walked to the public library after school and checked out the only bird book they had that wasn’t checked out: a beat-up 1992 field guide with a coffee stain on the cover. When he turned in his project, he had three extra pages no one asked for, about passenger pigeons. He found a sidebar that said thousands of them used to nest in the woods 20 miles from our town, before they went extinct. He’d never heard of passenger pigeons before. He never would have thought to search for them. But there he was, flipping through pages he didn’t go looking for, and he stumbled on a question he didn’t know he could ask.
When I was a kid, that happened all the time. My grandma grew tomatoes in her backyard, and one summer most of them split open before they ripened. I spent a rainy Saturday going through her shelf of old gardening books looking for a reason. I didn’t find the answer I was looking for right away, but I stumbled on a whole chapter about why some tomatoes taste better than others, and how to save seeds from year to year. I never went into that weekend knowing to ask about seed saving. I just found it, because I was wandering through information instead of jumping straight to an answer.
Now, it’s too easy to skip the wandering. If you want to know why tomatoes split, you Google it, you get the answer in 10 seconds, and you move on. No detours, no accidental discoveries. For kids, that’s compounded by the way we structure most of their learning: every worksheet has pre-written questions, every unit has a set list of things to know, every homework answer is a quick search or AI prompt away. They never get practice sitting in that space of not knowing what you don’t know, and hunting around until you find a question worth asking. That’s the ability we’re losing, bit by bit. It’s not that kids are less curious. It’s that we’ve stripped away the unstructured, messy space where curiosity about unknown things grows.
The good news is, it doesn’t take big overhauls to bring that space back. I’ve started with small changes in my classroom, and I suggest the same to parents I talk to.
First, when a kid asks you a question, don’t just tell them the answer or tell them to Google it. Say “Let’s go look that up together, and see what else we find.” If they ask how bees make honey, grab a library book instead of pulling up a search result. Flip through it slowly, and stop on any random page that catches your eye. Last month, a kid asked me why cats purr, and we ended up reading a 2-page spread in an old animal book about how cheetahs purr too, unlike big lions and tigers. No one would have searched for that, but we all left knowing something new we didn’t know we wanted to learn.
Second, leave space that doesn’t have a pre-set goal. Keep a pile of old magazines, used books from thrift stores, or outdated field guides on your coffee table. No one has to do a report on them. They’re just there to flip through when you’re waiting for dinner to cook, or when you’re bored on a rainy day. In my classroom, I have a box of 1970s National Geographics that a retired teacher gave me. The kids who finish their work early always flip through them, and I get more weird, interesting questions from that box than from any textbook I’ve ever used.
Third, when a kid says they don’t have any questions, ask them to name one weird thing they noticed today. It doesn’t have to be big. After I asked Mia that, she thought for a minute and said “Why does a dry bean get soft when you put it in water, but not turn into mush?” That was her question. She ended up testing whether beans germinate better in sugar water or plain water, got mold on half her samples, and still doesn’t have a perfect answer. That’s okay.
I still catch myself falling into the habit too. If I have a question about fixing my leaky faucet, I Google the exact step I need and skip all the extra stuff about how faucets work, or what different types of seals do. It’s faster, but I don’t learn anything I didn’t already know to ask for. We’re all busy, and we all need quick answers sometimes. But it’s worth leaving 10 minutes a week for wandering, for the questions we don’t know we need to ask yet. It’s still a work in progress in my classroom, and at home. Some weeks we do better than others. But the small moments of discovery make it worth it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Lose the Ability to Ask Questions They Don’t Know To Ask, And What To Do About It