Why Kids Keep Asking “When Do I Start School?” And What It Actually Means
Last Tuesday, I was leaning against the daycare van door, waiting for my 4-year-old Mia when she burst out holding a crumpled handprint sun craft and asked, “Mom, when do I start big school? When?” It was the fourth time she’d asked that question in seven days, triggered by her best friend Lila’s new unicorn backpack for kindergarten, which Lila had showed off at the playground the weekend before. That same hour, I got an email from a parent of one of my incoming kindergarten students, asking the exact question I’ve gotten every August for the past seven years: My kid won’t stop asking when school starts. I’ve told him the date a dozen times. Is this normal?
I thought back to my older son Jude, when he was getting ready to start kindergarten. He asked the question every single night at dinner for three months straight. We bought a giant wall calendar, marked the date with a glitter pen, counted down the sleeps every morning, bought his dinosaur lunchbox six weeks early. I thought he was just over the moon excited to go to big school. Then, the night before his first day, he was sitting in the bath, soaping his rubber duck, and out of nowhere he started crying. “What if you forget to come get me before it gets dark?” he asked. I realized then that he hadn’t been asking for the date this whole time. He’d been asking if everything was going to be okay.
Last summer, I had an incoming kindergartener named Javi whose mom told me he asked “when do we start” every morning before breakfast, right after he brushed his teeth. She bought him a digital countdown clock that ticked off the seconds, and he still asked. When we did our pre-school home visit, Javi hung back by the couch while his mom and I talked, and finally he pulled on my sleeve and whispered, “When do I really start? Do I have to stay the whole whole day before my mom comes?” He didn’t need a better answer to the date. He needed confirmation that the rules he’d heard were actually true, that his mom wasn’t going to leave him there longer than he’d been told.
As a first grade teacher and a mom of two, I’ve learned that repeated “when do I start school” questions are almost never about the date. Kids don’t have the same grasp of long stretches of time that adults do. Three weeks might as well be three years to a 4 or 5 year old who’s never had their whole daily routine upended. The question is just their way of saying that this big, unknown change feels big and unknown, and they need a little anchor to hold onto.
The first thing I tell parents to try is to stop just repeating the date and add a small, specific, upcoming step instead. If your kid asks and you say “two more weeks,” that still feels like forever. If you say “two more weeks, and this Saturday we’re going to pick out your new lunchbox, remember?” that breaks the big wait into smaller, manageable pieces. It gives them something to count down to right now, instead of just a far-off event.
Another thing: If they’re asking over and over, answer the unspoken question out loud. Nine times out of ten, they’re worried about something small and specific that they haven’t known how to name. Instead of snapping “I already told you it’s two weeks,” try “You’re really wondering what school will be like, huh? Are you worried about who you’ll sit next to at snack?” or “You know I’ll be right here to pick you up as soon as the day ends, right?” When Mia asked me that question on the curb last Tuesday, I almost brushed her off with “another year, bug, stop asking.” Instead I sat down on the concrete next to her, chalk dust sticking to my jeans, and said “You keep asking about big school. Are you wondering if it’ll be okay?” She nodded immediately and said “Will I still get apple slices for snack like I do at daycare?” I told her she could pack apple slices every single day if she wanted, that it was totally up to her. She didn’t ask again for four days. That 30 second conversation did more than all the times I’d told her the date ever could.
I also tell parents to give them a small, repeated task related to school that they can do on their own. It gives them a little bit of control when everything else feels out of their hands. It can be something as simple as letting them put their new backpack by the front door every Sunday night, or drawing a picture for their new teacher and taping it to the fridge, or helping you count out the crayons that will go in their pencil box. It doesn’t have to be fancy, it just has to be something they can do to feel connected to the change instead of just waiting for it to happen.
It’s not a perfect fix, of course. Some kids will still ask every day, even after you’ve named their worry and given them small tasks. That’s okay too. It just means they need a little extra reassurance. I’ve had parents tell me they get frustrated because they’re answering the same question over and over, but stopping for 30 seconds to check the calendar again, or name the worry again, doesn’t take much time, and it goes a long way.
This week, Mia asked me again while we were folding laundry. She was dragging around my old elementary school backpack that I kept in the closet, and she stopped mid-sock fold to say, “When do I start big school again?” I told her it’s next summer, after her fifth birthday, and that we can go look at water bottles this weekend if she wants. She nodded, flipped the sock inside out (like she always does) and tossed it in the basket, then went back to dragging her backpack around the living room. She doesn’t need to remember the date right now. She just needed to know we’re still thinking about it, and that we’ll handle it when the time comes. Some days the question is just a request for a little extra certainty, and that’s all we have to give.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Keep Asking “When Do I Start School