Why Kids Ask ‘Am I Dumb For Making A Mistake?’ And What You Can Do
The crumbs of cheddar goldfish were stuck to the edge of my 4th grader’s math worksheet when he slammed his pencil down hard enough to make the eraser bounce off. “Am I dumb for making a mistake like this?” he said, voice tight, staring at the page of long division problems he’d half-erased already. I was mid-work email, one hand on my cold coffee mug, and my first instinct was to blurt out the line I’ve said a hundred times: “Of course you’re not dumb, that was just a little mistake.”
I stopped short, though, because I remembered the learning support Q&A I’d gone to at his school two weeks before. The teacher leading it had asked how many of us respond to that exact question by immediately reassuring our kids they’re not dumb, and almost every hand in the room went up. Then she said that quick reassurance doesn’t actually answer the question kids are really asking. They’re not asking for a compliment. They’re asking how to sort what a mistake means about who they are.
I pushed my laptop aside, leaned over the sticky kitchen table, and said, “Show me what the mistake is, exactly.” He huffed and tapped the top of the problem: he was supposed to divide 427 by 3, but he’d written 472. Every step after that was calculated correctly, but the whole problem was wrong because of one swapped digit. I grabbed a spare pencil and circled each step one by one, starting after the wrong number. “Okay, let’s go through this. First step after the number: you put 1 over the 4, that’s right. Then you multiplied 1 times 3, got 3, subtracted, that’s right. You brought down the next number, that’s correct. You remembered to put a zero in the quotient when the number is smaller than the divisor—do you remember that’s the step Ms. Lee said half the class forgets? That’s right here. All six of these steps are right. The only wrong thing is the two numbers got swapped when you copied the problem.”
He leaned in a little, squinted at the page like he was seeing it for the first time. “Huh. I didn’t look at that. I just saw the whole thing was wrong.” Then he added, “But Mia says if you make stupid mistakes like that, you’re dumb. And Coach says if you mess up the start, you mess up the whole play.”
I thought about how many times I’ve closed a Google Doc after a typo in a client email and thought “I’m such an idiot,” how I’ve written off an entire recipe because I measured the wrong ingredient, how we all do this even as adults. We tie small, silly mistakes to our whole ability, instead of seeing them as one wrong step in a dozen right ones. What stuck with me from that Q&A is that around 9 or 10 years old, kids start to shift from “I tried this and it didn’t work” to “I am the kind of person who is bad at this.” They start sorting their peers into smart and not smart based on the mistakes they notice, then turn that same lens on themselves. Brushing off the question with “you’re not dumb” just tells them you don’t want to talk about it, not that mistakes don’t define you.
What we started doing instead doesn’t take any extra time, really, just a small shift in habit. First, when he asks that question, we map the mistake first before any reassurance. We name exactly what went wrong, and what kind of mistake it is. This one was a hurry mistake—he wanted to finish math in 10 minutes so he could play Roblox with his friend, so he rushed copying. It wasn’t a “I don’t understand long division” mistake, it wasn’t a “I’m bad at math” mistake. Second, we count the right steps alongside the wrong one. Almost no mistake ruins every part of a task, but when kids are upset, they only see the wrong part. Third, we name the mistake instead of calling ourselves dumb. It’s “I made a hurry mistake” instead of “I’m so dumb.” It’s a tiny shift, but it separates the thing you did from the thing you are.
A few days after that math homework incident, I was baking chocolate chip cookies for his class party, and I doubled the recipe wrong, put two tablespoons of salt instead of two teaspoons. I pulled the tray out after 10 minutes, smelled it, and said “Oh, come on, what a mess.” Before I could say anything else, my son leaned over from where he was doing his reading log and said “Wait, what did you get right? You got the butter and the sugar and the chocolate chips all right. That’s most of it. What kind of mistake was it?” I laughed and said “A reading glasses mistake, I didn’t put my glasses on and misread the recipe.” He nodded and said “Okay, so just that one step wrong. We can scrape the dough off the tray and adjust it next time, right?”
It doesn’t work every time. Two weeks ago he got a spelling test back with five wrong, crumpled it up and said “I’m dumb at spelling, I always mess up.” I still caught myself starting to say “No you’re not” before I remembered to pause and ask him to show me which mistakes he made. Some days he’s too upset to map it out, some days I’m too busy rushing to get dinner on the table to stop and go through the steps. It’s not like we’ve fixed his whole tendency to be hard on himself forever.
But now, after most mistakes, he doesn’t shut down for 20 minutes refusing to keep going. He just finds the wrong step, fixes it, and moves on. Last week he finished his math homework five minutes early, and he tapped the page and said “I copied the number wrong at first, but I checked it before I turned it in. Only one mistake, that’s not bad.” I just nodded. It’s not a big win we can put on the fridge, but it’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Ask ‘Am I Dumb For Making A Mistake