Why Kids Are Sneaky (And What It Really Means When They Won’t Talk To You)
The 13-year-old slouched into my office after lunch, scuffing her worn white sneakers on the rubber welcome mat by the door, and pulled a half-eaten granola bar out of one hoodie pocket and a crumpled algebra test out of the other. She set the test on my desk, face down, and stared at her scuffed laces. “I hate being sneaky,” she said, twisting a neon pink hair tie around her wrist over and over. “But I don’t feel comfortable talking to my mom.”
Lila, that’s her name, had failed the quiz two weeks prior. She’d hidden the notice the teacher sent home, deleted the follow-up email from her mom’s phone inbox when she borrowed it to check an assignment, and lied last Sunday when her mom asked how the first unit quizzes went. “Fine,” she’d said. I asked her why she didn’t just tell the truth. She picked at a corner of the test paper and told me what happened the last time she admitted she was struggling with a class. Her mom had canceled their weekly movie night to redo every single problem with her, then texted the other mom in their carpool about how “Lila just can’t seem to focus on math these days,” then signed her up for three after-school tutoring sessions a week without asking her if she even wanted extra help. For a month after that, dinner conversation kept circling back to Lila’s grades, right in front of her dad and 10-year-old brother. “I felt like everyone was looking at me like I was stupid,” she said. “I already knew I failed. I already felt bad. Why do I have to let everyone know and feel worse?”
A couple weeks before that meeting with Lila, I’d sat across from her mom for our parent-teacher conference. Her mom was harried, juggling a work phone that kept buzzing under the table, and she’d asked me what she was doing wrong. “She never tells me anything anymore,” she’d said. “I know she’s hiding stuff. I just wish she’d talk to me.” That’s the line I hear almost every week from parents of middle schoolers. Most of them assume sneaky behavior means their kid is pulling one over on them, that they’re being intentionally defiant or untrustworthy. What most don’t realize is that sneaking isn’t about wanting to be bad. It’s a calculation. Kids weigh the outcome of being honest against the outcome of hiding what’s wrong, and more often than not, they decide hiding hurts less.
After I talked to Lila, I called her mom in for a quick meeting to walk through what Lila had shared. I didn’t throw her mom under the bus— I told her most parents do exactly what she did, because they love their kid and want to fix their problems as fast as possible. But I gave her two small things to try the next time Lila came to her with something hard, instead of jumping into problem-solving mode. First, if she finds out Lila has been hiding something, she should open with “That must have been really hard to carry alone,” instead of “How could you lie to me?” Second, whenever Lila shares a problem, she should end her first response with “Do you want to figure out a fix together, or do you just want to vent about it right now?” That’s it, just two small phrases, no big overhauls to how you talk to your kid.
Her mom tried it a week later, after Lila worked up the courage to hand over the failed test. She told me later that when Lila put the paper on the kitchen counter, her first instinct was to ask why she waited two weeks to say something. But she bit her tongue and said the line I gave her: “That must have been really hard to carry alone.” Lila started crying right there, she said. She said she’d been so scared to tell her, she’d barely slept that whole week. Then her mom asked the second question: do you want to fix this together, or just vent? Lila said she didn’t want three tutoring sessions a week— she just wanted to go to the teacher’s after-school help once a week and study with her friend who gets algebra. Her mom agreed. They didn’t bring it up at dinner that night, didn’t talk about it in front of her brother.
It’s not a perfect fix. Lila still stops by my office once every couple weeks to work up the courage before she tells her mom something. Last week she was here, hiding that she got a C-minus on her history research paper. She still thinks her mom will push her to rewrite it over the weekend and lecture her about not starting earlier, so she’s still sitting on it. “It’s not even that bad of a grade,” she said, picking at a loose thread on my couch. “I just don’t feel like the lecture.” I didn’t push her to tell her mom right away.
The thing a lot of parents don’t get is that the goal isn’t to get your kid to tell you everything. It’s just to make the cost of being honest lower than the cost of being sneaky. Pre-teens and teens are already learning how to manage their own problems, and they need space to do that without every small mistake turning into a family conversation or a big intervention. When kids know they won’t get shamed, or lectured, or have their problem solved for them before they even ask for help, they start to open up a little more, one small thing at a time.
Lila doesn’t say she likes being sneaky anymore. She still hates it. But now she knows that if she ever does want to talk, the conversation won’t automatically be worse than hiding it. That’s not a neat, happy ending. It’s just a start. And that’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Are Sneaky (And What It Really Means When They Won’t Talk To You)