Why Is School So Stupid? A Parent’s Perspective On What’s Wrong And What You Can Do
I’m pulling out of the elementary school pickup line when my fifth grader, Jax, slams his backpack against the passenger side door and says, voice tight, “School is so fucking stupid.” He never swears, so I pause before merging onto the main road, glance over, and see his cheeks are pink. “What happened?”
He launches in: He finished his math test 15 minutes early, the whole thing double-checked for mistakes, and pulled out his pencil to keep drawing the space cat comic he’s been working on for weeks. He fit the whole first issue in the blank margins of the test. When he got it back yesterday, his teacher had taken 10 points off, written “Extra work on test papers is not permitted. Finish all work in designated spaces only,” and dropped his A to a B-. By the time he’s done listing every other recent stupid thing that’s pushed him over the edge—reading logs that don’t count his graphic novels because they’re “not full text,” PE making him sit out the scrimmage because he stopped walking laps for two minutes to catch his breath when his asthma flared, art class making everyone draw the same generic apple instead of letting us draw what we actually want—it’s hard not to feel his frustration. I used to teach fourth grade, remember? I’ve enforced these same stupid rules myself.
It’s not that Jax’s teacher is a bad person. She’s not. She sends nice notes about how kind he is to the new kid in class, she remembers he’s allergic to kiwi at class parties. The problem isn’t bad teachers. It’s that the system is built first for ease of management, not for kids. When you have 28 kids in a class, admin breathing down your neck about testing compliance, and a hundred boxes to check every single day, you make blanket rules. Blanket rules don’t require extra thinking or extra work. A “no extra writing on tests” rule is easier than stopping to ask which kid is drawing because they finished early and which kid is writing down cheat notes. A “graphic novels don’t count for reading logs” rule is easier than fighting the district’s page-count requirement that doesn’t update to match 30 years of reading research. It’s not malicious. It’s just that no one in the system has the time or bandwidth to adjust for every kid’s needs, so everyone gets shoved into the same box, even when the box doesn’t fit.
My first instinct, when Jax finished his rant, was to default to what most of us do: “Well, rules are rules, you have to respect the teacher.” But I caught myself. What would that have done? It would have told Jax his frustration doesn’t matter, that I side with the system over him, and he’d never tell me when things get bad again. Instead, I pulled into the drive-thru for his favorite frozen lemonade, handed it to him through the cup holder, and said, “Yeah, that is stupid. That sounds really garbage.” That’s it. No problem solving, no defending anyone, just agreeing that what happened sucked. That’s the first thing I tell other parents when they ask what to do when their kid says school is stupid: Just agree with them first. You don’t have to start arguing or fixing things immediately. Just name the feeling: That sounds unfair. That would make me mad too. It takes 10 seconds, and it changes everything.
After Jax calmed down, we talked about what he wanted to do about the test. He thought about it for a few minutes sipping his lemonade, and said he just wanted the teacher to know it hurt his feelings, he didn’t want anyone to get in trouble. So we wrote a two-sentence email together: “I worked really hard on my math test and finished early. I was upset I lost points for drawing in the margin.” That’s all. No yelling, no demands. The teacher wrote back the next day that she hadn’t thought about it that way, and gave him back his 10 points. It didn’t fix every stupid rule in the school, but it taught Jax that speaking up for small things can work, when they matter to him.
Over the past few months, we’ve built a few small, low-effort habits that work for us, when the stupid parts of school pile up. First, we have a small whiteboard on the back of Jax’s closet door we call the Stupid School List. Whenever something dumb happens, he writes it down. It’s a 30-second outlet that keeps the frustration from festering into something bigger. Second, we do a 5-minute “battery mapping” check every Sunday night. We just go over: What’s the stupid stuff this week that’s just annoying and not worth fighting, and what’s the stuff that actually bugs you enough to do something about? For example, the rule that your name has to be in the top right corner even if you wrote it on the back is stupid, but it takes two seconds to comply, so that’s a no-fight. Taking points off a project because you drew outside the lines is a fight, so we talk through what to say or do. Third, no matter how much homework he has, he gets 45 minutes of completely unstructured, no-rules time right after school. No logs, no expectations, no adult telling him what to do. He can draw, dig in the garden, play with his action figures, whatever. That’s his time to reset from all the compliance he has to do all day.
Last week, Jax came home with a detention slip for talking too loud during silent reading. He tossed it on the counter, shrugged, and said, “Told you, school is still stupid.” I nodded, pulled out the pre-made cookie dough we had in the fridge, and we baked cookies while he drew a comic of the detention supervisor as a grumpy talking toaster that hates fun. It’s taped to our fridge now.
We haven’t fixed anything big. The reading log still doesn’t count graphic novels, PE still makes everyone walk laps no matter their asthma, and there’s always a new stupid rule popping up every month. Some days I get more mad about it than Jax does. But what we’ve figured out is that it’s okay to say it’s stupid. You don’t have to pretend the system works for your kid to be a good parent, or for your kid to succeed. It’s okay to validate their frustration, help them pick what matters, and give them a safe place to be annoyed when the whole thing just doesn’t make sense. That’s enough, most days.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is School So Stupid