Why Is My Kid Doodling During Homework? Is It A Waste Of Time?
7:14 PM, I check the clock because I’m counting down to bedtime and the dishes that won’t wash themselves. Leo’s 4th grade homework is spread across our kitchen table, dotted with crumbs from the after-school granola bar he never finishes. I lean over to check his long division, and half the page is covered in doodles—scaly dragons with too many teeth, tiny stick-figure knights, even one dragon curled around the edge of a word problem that asks about train schedules.
Last week I would’ve grabbed his worksheet and sighed, told him all that drawing was a waste of time, that if he focused on the math instead of dragons he’d be done and outside playing already. “Leo,” I said that night two weeks ago, “if you spent half the time you draw these on your work, you’d be done 20 minutes ago.” He blinked up at me, pencil still hovering over a dragon’s eye, and said, “But I can’t do the math if I don’t draw.”
I left it that night, but the question niggled at me. Is this thing a waste of time? I’d volunteered in his classroom enough to see teachers pull doodled pages out of notebooks and toss them in the trash, to hear other parents complain that their kid’s constant fidgeting or drawing or whatever off-topic thing they’re doing is just a bad habit that’s holding them back. I’d thought that too, for a long time. Any time that wasn’t spent directly on the assigned task felt wasted.
I brought it up with Leo’s teacher, Ms. Henderson, a couple weeks later at our after-conference coffee. We were sitting in her old minivan in the school parking lot, because the gym was still full of other parents talking, and the coffee was lukewarm gas station blend. I told her about the dragons, about how I can’t tell if I should be cracking down or letting it go, if it’s just a waste of time or something else.
She laughed and said she used to crack down hard on doodling, too. “I used to think any kid drawing during my lesson wasn’t paying attention,” she said. “Then I had a student a few years back who told me straight up he couldn’t remember what I said if his hand wasn’t moving. Got me curious, so I did a little test with my class the next year. One week I made everyone sit on their hands during read-aloud, no doodling. The next week I let them draw whatever they wanted while I read. Most of the kids could tell me more about the story the second week. Half of them didn’t even remember they were drawing.”
She told me it’s not just doodling, either. She has kids who build tiny Lego towers while they take spelling tests, kids who bounce on exercise balls while they read, kids who hum off-key the whole time they work. A lot of parents ask her if that’s a waste of time, if it’s distracting the other kids or their own kid. More often than not, she said, it’s the opposite. Those little “wasted” movements or drawings are how a lot of kids keep their brain from wandering off to something else entirely.
I went home that week and decided to stop saying anything about the dragons for seven days. I kept a little post-it note on the corner of the table to count how many times I would’ve interrupted him to nag about doodling. The week before the experiment, I’d interrupted him 11 times. Eleven stops and starts, 11 times he had to yank his focus away from his math to remember I was waiting for him to get back to work. After I stopped nagging? Zero interruptions. His average homework time dropped by 12 minutes a night.
That’s when I started really noticing all the other things we write off as a waste of time all the time. My neighbor’s kid spends hours sorting his Pokémon cards by type and hit point value, and everyone jokes that it’s a huge waste of time that could be spent reading. But that sorting is just practice for categorizing, for pattern recognition, for organizing information—skills he uses for his book reports and science projects now. My niece spends an hour a day drawing little comics instead of practicing the piano that her parents pay $80 a month for. She’s now writing her own graphic novel for the school library, something she never would’ve done if they’d made her stop drawing to practice scales every night.
It’s not that all off-task stuff is good, obviously. If Leo is spending an hour drawing and hasn’t finished a single math problem, I step in. I don’t ban the doodles, I just say, “Let’s finish the next five problems first, then you can draw a whole page of dragons after dinner.” That works way better than grabbing his pencil and telling him to stop. I also keep a blank half-sheet of paper taped to the side of his homework folder, so he can doodle all he wants there instead of covering his worksheet, which makes grading easier for Ms. Henderson and keeps me from panicking when I see dragon scales on his spelling test.
I still catch myself sometimes, though. Last night I looked over and he’d drawn a whole dragon eating a long division problem on the back of his worksheet, and I almost opened my mouth to say something. I counted the problems he’d gotten right that night: 8 out of 10, same as when I’m nagging him nonstop. He was already packing his backpack to go watch a cartoon before bed, done 10 minutes earlier than he had been two months ago.
I still don’t have all the answers. Some days I worry that we’re letting too much “unproductive” time slip by, that we should be doing more flashcards or more practice or more of whatever the parenting newsletters say we should be doing. I still get that little twinge of guilt when I see half a page of dragons instead of all blank margins around math problems. But right now, the dragons work for Leo. They’re not a waste of time. They’re just how he gets his work done. That’s enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My Kid Doodling During Homework