Why Is My 11-Year-Old Shutting Down? What I Learned Worrying About My Cousin
Last weekend, I was at my aunt’s annual July barbecue, grabbing a second cup of lemonade from the cooler when I spotted Lila on the back step, knees pulled up to her chest, face lit by her phone screen. The rest of the kids her age were yelling over a game of cornhole by the fence, a few with popsicle drips running down their wrists. Lila’s 11, and up until a year ago, she’d have been the first one dragging me into the game to be on her team, begging me to sneak her an extra chocolate chip cookie after. This time, when I sat down next to her and asked what she was watching, she just mumbled “nothing” and tilted her screen away from me.
I’m an upper elementary teacher, so I see quiet, withdrawn 11-year-olds every school year. But when it’s your 11-year-old cousin, the one you used to do glitter nail art with while binging old Disney Channel movies, it’s different. My aunt keeps brushing it off as “just pre-teen moodiness” – says she’s always tired, won’t turn in her math homework, quit art club three months ago for no reason, and won’t tell anyone what’s wrong. I knew it wasn’t just moodiness, I just couldn’t get her to open up enough to figure out what was actually wrong.
Two weeks ago, my aunt had a last-minute work emergency and asked me to pick Lila up from her new middle school. I got there 10 minutes early, and she was leaning against the fence by herself, not standing with the other girls from her homeroom. I suggested we stop for mint chocolate chip before dropping her back, and she shrugged okay. We sat in the parking lot of the ice cream shop, and I didn’t ask her what was wrong right away. I just complained about how my school’s new drop-off rule is ridiculous and makes me 10 minutes late every day. After a minute, she poked her ice cream with her spoon and said the art teacher hung her watercolor of a fox up in the hallway for back-to-school night. Two girls from her class walked by, and one said “wow that looks like a kindergartener drew that” and the other laughed.
She said after that, she told the teacher she didn’t want it up anymore, and quit art club the next day. She didn’t tell her mom because “mom would just say they’re just mean and my art is good anyway, which doesn’t help.” She’s right, that’s what most of us do. When an 11-year-old comes to us hurt, we jump to fix it, to tell them it’s not a big deal, to reassure them that they’re great. But what 11-year-olds need at that age isn’t fixing. They need someone to agree that it is a big deal, because to them, it is. At 11, your whole world shifts: peer approval stops being nice to have and starts being the most important thing in your life. Your brain is already wired to care more about what people your age think than what any adult thinks, and that’s not a flaw, that’s just normal development.
Instead of telling her her art was amazing, I just said “That sounds so awful. I’d want to quit too, if that happened to me. I’d want to hide my drawing and never draw anything again in front of anyone.” She looked up at me and started crying, quiet little sobs into her ice cream cone. That’s the first time she’d talked about it to anyone. After that, I asked her if she wanted to draw with me at my apartment once a week. I said no one else has to see it, we don’t have to hang anything up, we can just draw while we watch whatever garbage reality show she wants, and if she doesn’t feel like drawing one week we can just get popcorn instead. She said yes.
I also talked to her homeroom teacher, who I know through a district workshop, and asked if she could make a couple of small adjustments. Instead of calling on Lila to answer questions out loud in front of the whole class when she doesn’t raise her hand, she lets her write answers on the whiteboard in small groups first. She doesn’t force Lila to do whole-class presentations right now, lets her record hers and play the audio instead. Those are tiny, low-effort changes that make a huge difference when you’re already feeling like everyone is watching you and judging you.
Another small habit I started that any parent or caregiver can copy: I never ask her “how’s school?” She always says “fine.” Instead I ask one specific, low-stakes question: “What’s the most annoying thing that happened today?” or “Who did the dumbest thing in your class this week?” Specific questions don’t feel like an interrogation, and they’re way easier to answer than a big open question about how you’re doing. Last week she told me about a boy who put a goldfish cracker up his nose and had to go to the nurse, and that turned into a 20 minute conversation, no pushing required.
It’s not fixed. She still sits on the step at family barbecues. She still hasn’t gone back to art club. My aunt still gets frustrated sometimes, says she wishes Lila would just “be her old self again.” But last week when we met at my place to draw, she pulled out a 12-page comic she’d drawn about a stray cat that moves into a bookstore and hides from all the people because she’s scared they won’t like her drawings. She let me read the whole thing. At the end, the cat decides to show one person who works at the bookstore, and that person thinks it’s good. That’s more progress than anyone has gotten in six months. We still don’t know how it’s going to go. But right now, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My 11-Year-Old Shutting Down