Why Is My 11 Year Old Girl Withdrawing? What I’ve Learned As A Teacher And Cousin
Last month, I stood outside my cousin Lila’s bedroom door at a family cookout, holding a squishy square of half-melted chocolate. She was supposed to be helping me roast marshmallows for s’mores, but no one had seen her in 45 minutes. The door was cracked an inch, so I peeked through. She was curled up on her faded Minecraft comforter, phone held a foot from her face, screen dimmed so low I could barely see it. When I knocked, she jumped and clicked the screen black so fast I almost missed the animation tutorial she’d been watching.
I stepped in, sat on the end of her bed, and handed over the chocolate. She mumbled thanks, didn’t look up. I glanced at the floor by her desk, where her 6th grade math binder gaped open, a D-marked test on top with the teacher’s “Come see me for extra help” scribbled out in blue pencil so hard it tore the paper. Her big sketchbook, the one she carried everywhere two years ago when she won the county fair art award, was tucked under her bed, a thin layer of dust on the cover.
After that, I pulled my aunt aside by the grill, where the hamburgers were burning a little around the edges. She sighed and wiped grease on her jeans, said she didn’t know what to do with Lila anymore. A year ago, she was getting straight A’s, begged to sleep over at friends’ houses, drew every night after homework. Now she won’t come out of her room for dinner, snaps if anyone asks how school was, and spends every free minute on TikTok. They took her phone away for a whole week once, and she just sat in her room not talking, didn’t do any homework anyway, so they gave it back. “She’s just lazy, right?” my aunt said. “Or has a bad attitude. What did we do wrong?”
I’m a 5th grade teacher, so I see this almost every fall, when 11 year olds head off to middle school. I didn’t say that right away, but I started stopping by after work once a week, just to hang out, no agenda. I learned a long time ago that asking “What’s wrong, are you okay?” makes 11 year olds shut down faster than anything. Instead, I’d bring a cherry soda from the gas station, sit on her floor, and ask specific, low-stakes questions. Once I saw her sketchbook peeking out from under the bed, I said “I heard you draw Minecraft fanart. One of my students brought a creeper drawing in for show and tell last week, it was so good. Can I see any of yours?”
That was the first time she opened up a little. She pulled the sketchbook out slow, like she expected me to make fun of it. She told me the girls she’d been friends with since elementary school started hanging out with the popular group at middle school, and they told her her drawing was “babyish” when she brought it to art class. No one sits with her at lunch anymore. She doesn’t want to tell her mom because she thinks her mom will just tell her to “make new friends” and it’s not that easy. The TikTok thing? She wasn’t just scrolling mindlessly. She was watching 10-minute tutorials on how to draw flipbook animation, because she wants to make her own little Minecraft videos, but she was scared to post them because she didn’t want anyone from school to find them and make fun of her.
That’s the thing no one talks about enough. When parents see a pre-teen hiding in their room on their phone, we default to thinking the phone is the problem. But half the time, the phone is the only place they feel safe. It’s not that unstructured screen time is ideal, it’s that punishing screen time without asking what they’re doing there just pushes them further away.
We didn’t do some big dramatic intervention. We did three small things, all of which any parent or caregiver can do this week. First, instead of a blanket “no phone after dinner” rule, Lila and her mom worked out a new schedule: after she finishes 30 minutes of homework (no more, no less, to start), she gets 45 minutes of unhurried phone time to work on her drawing and watch tutorials. That time is off-limits for lectures about screen time. If she finishes her homework early, she gets an extra 15 minutes. No more sneaking the phone under the covers at night, because she knows she’ll get the time if she holds up her end of the deal.
Second, instead of forcing her to join the school art club where the girls who made fun of her go, we found a low-pressure animation class for 10-12 year olds at the local rec center. It’s once a week on Saturdays, only 7 kids, and the rule is you don’t have to share your work if you don’t want to. She went two weeks ago, didn’t talk to anyone the whole time, but when she came home she showed my aunt a 10-second clip she made of a cat fighting an Enderman. My aunt didn’t gush or overpraise, she just said “that’s really cool, how did you get the cat to move like that?” That’s way better than big over-the-top praise for kids who are already nervous about putting their work out there.
Third, when we’re all together as a family, we don’t force her to sit at the table for the whole meal if she doesn’t want to. We just tell her there’s always a plate for her in the fridge if she gets hungry, and no one will bug her if she wants to go back to her room after 15 minutes. That takes the pressure off everyone.
It’s not fixed. Her math grade is still a C minus, she still doesn’t have any close friends at school, she still skips most big family holidays. I still worry about her. Middle school is a rotten, awkward place for a lot of kids, and some rough patches don’t have a quick fix. Last week she texted me a link to her first TikTok, it’s got 14 views and 12 likes, three of which are from me, her mom, and her little brother. It’s nothing big, but it’s something. We’re not just yelling at her for the symptoms anymore. We’re meeting her where she is, and that’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My 11 Year Old Girl Withdrawing