Why Is My 11-Year-Old Girl Suddenly Withdrawn? What Caregivers Can Try First
Last weekend, I was grabbing extra hamburger buns from the back of my aunt’s minivan at our annual family cookout when I spotted my 11-year-old cousin Lila huddled between the tire and the bumper, scrolling TikTok on my aunt’s beat-up old work phone. She didn’t hear me coming until I dropped the bag of buns, and she jumped like I’d caught her doing something she shouldn’t. This used to be the kid who’d drag me out to the lawn before the grill was even lit, shoving a bag of friendship bracelet string in my hand and begging me to teach her a new pattern. She’d spend an hour making a bracelet for every cousin, even the teenage boys who pretended to hate it. This year, she didn’t mention bracelets once. She mumbled that she was fine, just needed a minute, and went back to her phone.
I’ve been picking Lila up from her new middle school every Tuesday for the past three months, since my aunt picked up a second shift at the hospital and couldn’t make the early dismissal. I’ve watched this shift happen slowly, so I know it’s not just a one-off bad day. She used to ramble the whole ride home about her art class, what her best friend had said, the weird things her science teacher did. Now she spends most of the ride with her hood up, staring out the window. A month ago, I watched her crumple up a full-page drawing of a fox she’d worked on for a week and toss it in the trash on the way out of school. When I fished it out and asked her what was wrong, she crossed her arms and said “It’s ugly. It’s not perfect. Everyone else’s drawings look way better than mine.”
My aunt’s first instinct, like most of ours, was to fix it fast. She’d say “It’s a great drawing, don’t be silly” or “A B minus is totally fine, stop being so hard on yourself.” But that never worked. Lila would just shut down more, leave the room, and not talk for an hour. I started reading a lot of material about early adolescence for a class I’m taking for my paraeducator license, and I realized we were making a common mistake: we were dismissing her feelings instead of meeting her where she was.
I stopped asking her big, loaded questions the second she gets in the car. Instead of “How was school?” or “How are things with your friends?” which just makes her clam up, I ask one tiny, low-stakes question every week. Last week it was “What’s the weirdest thing someone brought for lunch this week?” The week before that it was “If you could make one rule at your school, what would it be?” The questions don’t demand a big emotional answer, so she doesn’t feel put on the spot. Two weeks ago, answering the lunch question, she mentioned that the girl who sits next to her at lunch also brings those weird sour candy belts that Lila loves, and they’d traded half their packs. That’s the first friend update I’d gotten in a month, and it just came out casually, no pressure.
We started that “no good art” jar a month and a half ago. It’s just an old Barilla lasagna jar we had in my aunt’s pantry, and we put sparkly unicorn stickers on the lid. The rule is simple: any time she wants to throw away a drawing or a project because it’s not good enough, she has to put it in the jar instead. No pressure to ever look at it again, no one gets to see it unless she wants them to. At the end of every month, we go through it together if she feels like it. Last weekend, she pulled out a crumpled drawing of her old beagle, Max, who died two years ago. She’d thrown it away because one ear was twice as big as the other. When she pulled it out, she stared at it for a minute and said “Wait, I actually like this.” It’s taped to the inside of her closet door now.
I’ve noticed that when she says something is bad, she doesn’t actually want me to tell her it’s good. She wants me to notice the work she put in, even if the end result isn’t perfect. Instead of saying “this drawing is great,” I’ll say “I love that you used dark blue for the sky instead of the regular light blue, that’s such a cool choice” or “That must have taken forever to get all those little fur details right.” It sounds small, but it’s way different than generic praise. It acknowledges the effort she put in, not just whether the end product is good enough for someone else’s standards.
When she told me her best friend since second grade started hanging out with the dance team girls and now she sits alone most days, my aunt wanted to email the school counselor and the principal right away. Lila begged her not to, said that would just make everyone call her a baby and make it worse. We didn’t push it. We didn’t tell her she needed to put herself out there and make new friends, or that the old friend was a jerk. We just let her talk about it when she wanted to, and we let her skip the school dance last week to stay home and eat mint chocolate chip ice cream and watch the old Barbie Princess and the Pauper movie she’s loved since she was 5.
I’m still worried. Some weeks she still spends the whole car ride quiet, still crumples up all her work and won’t show anyone anything. I still leave some Tuesday afternoons wondering if I’m doing enough, if we should push for more help, if this is just the start of something harder. But right now, small things are working. She talks more than she did three months ago. She has that drawing of Max on her closet door. She traded candy with a girl at lunch. That’s enough for right now. We don’t have to fix it all this week. We just have to keep showing up, one small question and one crumpled drawing at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My 11-Year-Old Girl Suddenly Withdrawn