Why I’m Choosing to Stop Using AI for My Kid’s Homework (And What I’m Doing Instead)
The kitchen table was sticky with spilled chocolate milk, a half-eaten bag of Doritos crumbled next to my 11-year-old’s Chromebook. It was 7:45 on a Tuesday, his piano lesson had run 20 minutes late, my work call had dragged past dinner, and he’d just remembered his ancient Egypt outline was due first thing the next morning. I pulled up the chat box I’d started relying on for all these last-minute emergencies, typed out the prompt, and had a polished three-paragraph outline in 12 seconds flat. When I turned to show him, he leaned back in his chair and shrugged. “Cool, can I just copy this?” That’s when I said it out loud, more to myself than to him: I want to stop using AI.
It started small, last winter when he stayed home from school with a cold and I was juggling back-to-back meetings. When he yelled down the stairs asking for the difference between rotation and revolution for his science homework, I didn’t pause to walk through it with him or pull out his textbook. I just typed the question into AI, sent the answer up, and went back to my presentation. After that, it became a habit. Stuck brainstorming a science fair question? AI would spit out five good ones in 10 seconds. Can’t remember how to do 6th grade algebra? AI would walk through the problem faster than I could scroll through his teacher’s example email. I was a working mom with two kids, a part-time side gig, and a dog that keeps digging up the rose bushes. AI felt like a free personal assistant, why wouldn’t I use it?
I didn’t notice the shift until a couple months ago. He stopped squinting at his notes when he got stuck on a problem. He stopped rambling through half-baked ideas when we sat down to work on an outline. If he hit a bump, he just looked at me and asked for the AI answer. That Tuesday with the Egypt project, I looked at the perfect outline on my screen, and I realized he didn’t care that ancient Egyptians used yeast to bake bread 5,000 years ago. He didn’t care that kids his age in Egypt back then played with wooden dolls similar to the one he got for his little sister last Christmas. AI had already given him the answer, so there was no reason for him to go looking for the part that would stick with him.
I closed the tab that night, and we started small. First, I dug out an old dill pickle jar from the recycling, we covered it in dinosaur stickers, and turned it into our Hard Question Jar. Any question we don’t know the answer to right away, any topic he’s stuck on that I don’t have time to work through that minute, gets written on a slip of paper and tossed in. Every Sunday after dinner, we spend 20 minutes going through the jar together at the public library down the street. We pull books off the shelves, search kid-friendly history sites, and work through the answers together. Last week we had a slip that said “why do cats purr” and we both found out we were wrong—they don’t just purr when they’re happy, they do it to calm themselves down when they’re hurt too. It didn’t save us any time, but we both left with something we didn’t know before, instead of a quick answer we forgot by the next morning.
For last-minute homework panics, we have a new 10-minute rule. I set a timer on my phone, and he has to write down every idea he has, no matter how silly or off-topic, before he asks for help. If he’s still stuck, I don’t give him the answer. I just ask three questions: What’s the coolest thing you learned about this so far? Who is this for, and what do you want them to remember? What’s one thing you think that no one else might write? That’s it. No perfect outlines, no polished paragraphs from someone (or something) else. I also talked to his teacher a couple weeks ago, and she told me she’d rather have a messy outline with three wrong ideas than a perfect one that isn’t his. So I stopped caring if every assignment gets an A. A B on a project he did himself is worth more than an A on one he copied.
It’s not working perfectly, of course. Some nights I’m still exhausted, we’re still running late, and I have to fight the urge to just pull up AI and get it over with. Last month, he waited until the night before to start his persuasive essay arguing for more recess, and I almost caved. Instead we did the 10-minute brain dump, and he came up with the idea that recess helps him stop fidgeting through math class, something he actually deals with every day. His essay had three spelling mistakes and a rambling introduction, but he got a B+ and the teacher wrote “great personal insight” at the bottom.
He still tries to sneak AI sometimes—last week I caught him asking it to make his flashcards for a science quiz instead of writing them out himself. We dumped the AI flashcards, wrote them out together, and went to bed 15 minutes late. It was messy, it cut into my evening TV time, but I saw him memorize half the terms while he was writing them, something he never would have done if AI had done it for him.
I don’t think AI is evil, or that it has no place anywhere. I still use it to plan weekly grocery lists and sort out my work calendar. But for my son’s learning, the whole point is the messy, frustrating, slow work of thinking through hard things himself. I’m not done figuring this out, and some days I still wonder if I’m making the right choice. But right now, I notice he talks about what he’s learning at dinner more than he used to. He gets excited when he finds a fact that surprises him, instead of just checking a box that homework is done. That’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I’m Choosing to Stop Using AI for My Kid’s Homework (And What I’m Doing Instead)