Why I Turned On Comment Approval for Our Class Blog (and the New Flair That Followed)
It was a Thursday morning, and I had just poured my coffee when I saw the comment. It was on the class blog, under a post about a story we’d read. One student had written: “This is stupid. Why do we have to do this?” Another had replied almost immediately, “Because you’re stupid.” That second comment sat there for a full forty minutes before I spotted it. No one had flagged it. No one had reported it. The whole class had seen it, and the conversation just stopped.
I teach fifth grade, and for the past year I’ve let students post comments on our classroom blog without any moderation. The idea was to give them a space to practice writing for an audience. But after that incident, I knew I needed to change something. The problem wasn’t that kids can be mean sometimes – we all know that. The problem was that the public nature of the blog made it worse. When a comment goes live instantly, it feels like a shout. When it has to wait, it becomes a message.
So I turned on post and comment approval. In our school’s blogging platform, that meant every comment had to go through me before it appeared. I also decided to approve posts from a few students who had a habit of typing without thinking. The process was simple: I’d get an email notification, open the comment, read it, and either click “approve” or “trash” (we’d have a talk about why for the latter). It took me about ten extra minutes a day. But the shift in the room was immediate.
The first few days, students would refresh the page and see their comment wasn’t there yet. They’d raise their hands: “Did you approve mine?” I’d say, “I haven’t checked yet – why don’t you reread what you wrote?” That became a kind of ritual. They’d open their comment, stare at it, and sometimes ask to edit it before I even saw it. One boy, who always wrote short bursts like “This book is cool,” came up to me and said, “I want to change mine. Can I add a question?” That was a first.
The delay, it turned out, wasn’t just a safeguard. It gave kids time to reflect. We talk a lot about “thinking before you speak,” but online that’s harder because speaking feels like typing. The approval process made them pause, and pausing is half the battle.
But I also wanted to be more positive than just “no bad comments.” So I introduced a new flair system. Flair in our blogging platform is like a small label you can attach to a post or comment – a tag that says something about the content. I made four flairs: “New Idea,” “Good Question,” “Respectful Disagree,” and “Just Because.” (The last one for comments that are kind but don’t need a big label.)
Here’s how it works: when I approve a comment, I can also add a flair. So a student who writes, “I think the main character made a mistake, but here’s why…” might get a “Respectful Disagree” flair. A kid who asks, “What would have happened if she stayed?” gets “Good Question.” The label appears right next to their name on the blog. For a fifth grader, that’s like a little badge.
The effect was slow but noticeable. Kids started to look for flairs on their comments. One girl asked, “How do I get the ‘New Idea’ flair?” I said, “Write something that no one else has said yet.” That became a challenge. A few days later, she commented, “In the story, the brother is actually angrier than the sister, even though he says he’s not. Maybe because he lost the watch.” I approved it and slapped a “New Idea” flair on. She grinned for the rest of the day.
The practical side of this is fairly low-tech. You can do the same on any platform that allows comment moderation and custom labels. If you use a classroom blog or a private parent forum, look for settings like “approve comments” or “moderate posts.” Some platforms let you set rules – for example, automatically approve comments from trusted users, which saves time. I still manually approve everyone, partly because I like reading them, but also because I want to catch subtle digs that might pass an automatic filter.
For the flair, you don’t even need special software. You can just write a short prefix in front of the comment, like “[Good Question] Why did the author end it that way?” But I found that having a separate visual tag made it more exciting for kids. It felt more like a reward.
Now, after two months, the blog looks different. The comment section is quieter – fewer, but longer comments. There’s a “Respectful Disagree” thread under a post about homework, and it’s actually civil. A student wrote, “I see your point, but I still think we should have fewer math problems because we already practice at home.” Another responded, “That’s fair, but I need the practice.” That exchange got two flairs: one for the disagree, one for the fair acknowledgment.
Not everything is solved. Some students still type in a hurry and ask to edit. A few comments are still so empty – like “I agree” – that I just let them sit unapproved. I haven’t figured out a flair for “restate the author’s point and add nothing,” and I’m not sure I want one. The approval process takes time, and there are days when I fall behind and comments are waiting. But the kids are learning that writing for others means thinking first.
What surprised me is how the flair has helped not just the confident writers but the quiet ones. A shy student who generally stays out of discussions wrote a comment about the school garden: “I think we should plant mint because it smells good and it’s easy.” I gave her a “Just Because” flair. She didn’t say anything, but I saw her look at the screen a few times that afternoon. The next week, she commented on another post without being asked.
We’re still figuring it out. The approval filter catches the rude stuff, but it also catches the careless stuff. That’s fine. The flair gives kids a target, but it also sets a tone. I don’t know if this will work in high school or if it’s just right for fifth graders. I do know that the blog feels safer, and that matters.
Now I’m thinking about letting students suggest their own flairs at the end of the year. See what they come up with. Probably something about snacks.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Turned On Comment Approval for Our Class Blog (and the New Flair That Followed)