Why I Struggle To Understand The Current State Of Education (What I Learned From My Kid’s Teacher)
Last month, I stood outside my daughter Lila’s fourth-grade classroom waiting for our parent-teacher conference, lukewarm oat milk latte in one hand, a crumpled list of questions in the other. Lila was at the school book fair picking out a graphic novel about rescue dogs, so it was just me and her teacher Ms. Henderson when we sat down at a kid-sized desk stacked with construction paper and half-graded reading responses. I got through the small talk about how Lila loves recess and hates broccoli in the school lunch line, then I said what I’ve been wanting to say to an educator for two years: I need help understanding what’s actually going on with education right now.
When I was in fourth grade, I sat in rows, memorized my times tables, and got a red check mark on every spelling mistake I made. Lila comes home talking about “inquiry-based projects” and brings home half-finished worksheets that she says “we talk through as a group.” I scroll the local parent Facebook group and half the parents say kids can’t read or write anymore and the whole system is broken, the other half says old-school teaching held kids back for decades and we need to embrace the new way. I can’t tell who’s right, and I can’t tell if my kid is on track.
Ms. Henderson laughed, not in a mean way, and said she gets that question at every single conference this semester. She pulled out Lila’s math notebook and flipped to a page covered in scribbled numbers, a drawing of a picnic blanket, and a list of snack prices. I’d seen this before, assumed it was a fun Friday activity before a holiday. “This is her math unit for the month,” Ms. Henderson said. “She had to calculate how much food we need for 28 kids, stay under a $150 budget, adjust for food allergies. She did great. She had to multiply, add, problem solve when one group changed their order last minute.” I said, “But when did she practice her multiplication tables?” Ms. Henderson said they practice five minutes a day, but the point is to use what they learn, not just regurgitate it on a test.
That night I went home, sat at the kitchen table while Lila ate Goldfish crackers and worked on a writing assignment. She had to draft a paragraph about her favorite holiday, and I counted three misspelled words right off the bat. I reached for a pencil to mark them, like my mom did for me, and Lila swatted my hand away. “Ms. Henderson says we fix spelling on the final draft,” she said. “Right now we’re just getting ideas down.” I pulled my hand back and thought about what Ms. Henderson said earlier. The confusion I feel isn’t about whether new methods are good or bad. It’s that we’re in the middle of a shift, and no one bothered to explain it to parents.
Ms. Henderson told me what most teachers won’t say out loud at conference: right now, every school is juggling three big things at once, and that’s why everything feels messy. First, they’re still catching kids up from the pandemic years, when a lot of kids missed small, consistent practice like spelling drills and math facts. Second, they’re rolling out new curriculum standards that prioritize problem-solving and critical thinking over rote memorization. Third, most schools are still short a handful of teachers and aides, so no one has time to send home a weekly newsletter explaining what all the new jargon means. The confusion parents feel isn’t a failure of parenting, it’s just a side effect of a system that’s in transition.
After that conference, I changed a few small habits that have cut down on my stress and helped me stay connected to what Lila’s actually learning, no big overhauls required. First, I stopped panicking every time I see a half-finished worksheet. Instead, I started doing 10 minutes of the rote practice I care about every Sunday after dinner: 10 spelling words, five minutes of flash cards for whatever math fact she’s working on that week. It’s not extra homework, it’s not a big deal, it just fills in the gaps if school doesn’t get to repeated practice that week. Second, instead of asking “what did you do at school today?” (which always gets “nothing”), I ask “what’s the hardest problem you worked on this week?” That gives me a far better idea of what she’s learning than any letter grade on a test.
Last week, Lila came home upset about a group science project. Her two partners didn’t do any of the work on their solar system poster, so Lila stayed up an hour after bedtime drawing all the planets and writing all the facts. I almost grabbed my phone to email Ms. Henderson to complain that it was unfair, that Lila was doing all the work. But I remembered what Ms. Henderson said: messy group work isn’t just busy work. It’s practice for when Lila has a bad teammate at a job someday, and she has to figure out how to ask for help. I didn’t email the teacher. I just asked Lila, “What do you think you’ll do next time this happens?” She thought for a minute and said, “I’ll tell the teacher at the start that they aren’t doing their work, not wait until the night before it’s due.” That’s a skill I didn’t learn until I was 25, working my first office job.
I still don’t have it all figured out. I still worry when I see our district’s state test scores dropped 11 points last year. I still get annoyed when a project requires me to run to the store for poster board at 8pm the night before it’s due. I don’t think the current state of education is perfect, and I don’t think it’s all bad. The confusion I felt a few months ago wasn’t because I was out of touch, or because the system was irreparably broken. It’s because change is messy, and right now, education is changing right in front of our eyes, and we’re all just figuring it out as we go.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Struggle To Understand The Current State Of Education (What I Learned From My Kid’s Teacher)