Why I Feel Sad When My 5-Year-Old Struggles (And What I’m Actually Doing About It)
It’s 11:45 a.m., I’m leaning against the weathered cedar fence outside Lila’s preschool, holding a half-cold oat milk latte I grabbed on the way, and I spot her before she spots me. She’s hanging back by the classroom door, twisting the frayed hem of her green dinosaur hoodie, while the other 5-year-olds shove their snow boots on and crowd toward the exit, chattering about snack time and the new slide. Her teacher detours from the line to meet me at the fence, like she has most afternoons this semester. “Another quiet day,” she says, soft like she’s breaking bad news. “Wouldn’t join the movement game this morning, and wouldn’t share her drawing at circle time.”
Lila comes over a minute later, doesn’t look up, just slips her hand into mine, her palm sweaty through her thin knit glove. I ask if she wants a chocolate chip cookie from the bakery down the street on the way home, she just shrugs. In the car, she curls up with her floppy gray rabbit in the backseat and doesn’t say a word the whole 10-minute drive.
When we get home, I set her peanut butter crackers on the kitchen counter, and I lean against the fridge and just feel that heavy, quiet sadness settle in my chest. It’s not the ugly, sobbing sadness I felt after her first three bad weeks, it’s just a constant tight thing, there under everything I do. Everyone tells me she’s young, she’s the youngest in her class by almost three months, she’s just shy, she’ll catch up. I know all that. But I still hear it every day when she comes home and says, “I’m bad at preschool.” I still see it when she crumples up a half-colored page and throws it in the trash because it’s “not right.”
I used to react the way everyone says you should. I’d kneel down and say, “No, baby, you’re not bad! You’re so smart and talented!” I’d pull out a practice sheet and say, “C’mon, let’s try just one more letter, it’s fun!” That never worked. She’d either shut down completely or cry and run to her room, slamming the door behind her. A few weeks ago, after a particularly bad meltdown over cutting out a paper pumpkin for fall, I called the child development consultant my sister recommended, and she told me the first thing I had to do was stop fixing the feeling before we named it.
That changed everything. Instead of jumping in to cheer her up or convince her she’s fine before she’s even finished saying how hard something is, I just meet her where she is. When she says cutting curved lines is too hard, I don’t say “you can do it.” I say “Cutting those little lines makes your hand tired, doesn’t it? That feels really frustrating.” Nine times out of ten, she’ll nod and start talking about it, instead of shutting down. Last week she told me her hand shakes when everyone is watching her draw, and I never would have gotten that out if I’d just told her she was great the second she said it was hard.
We made a bunch of other small changes, too, none of them fancy or expensive. I stopped asking “how was school?” the second I see her, because that puts her on the spot to have a good answer, when all she wants to do is leave. Now I just greet her with whatever small, silly thing I brought that day—sometimes a sparkly sticker, sometimes a sour candy—and ask if she wants to walk around the block to look at the neighborhood cats before we go home. I talked to her teacher about letting Lila watch group activities from the side until she wants to join, instead of calling her out in front of the whole class. Most days now she joins halfway through, instead of hiding in the book corner the whole time.
At home, I got rid of the alphabet tracing workbooks that were collecting dust on the shelf and making both of us stressed. Now we practice pre-writing and fine motor skills in the middle of other things: she writes the first letter of her name on our grocery list, we draw faces in the condensation on the car windows on warm days, we tear up old magazine pages for collages to build hand strength before we glue them down. It’s not a formal lesson, it’s just two or three minutes here and there in the middle of our day, no pressure to get it right.
I still get sad, though. Last Saturday I was at the playground, and another mom was talking about how her 5-year-old can already read 50 sight words, and that old twist came back to my chest. I used to scroll through parent Instagram after days like that, looking for other kids the same age to compare, but I stopped that a month ago. It just makes the sadness bigger, when all you see are other people’s highlight reels. I worry about next year, when kindergarten starts and the expectations get bigger. I worry she’ll go through whole days feeling like she’s not doing it right. I don’t have a neat ending where she’s suddenly ahead of the class and everything is perfect.
But last night, she brought me a crumpled piece of construction paper with a lopsided pink heart and five stick figures of our family, and she said “I cut it all by myself, only the top edge was a little bumpy.” I stuck it on the fridge, right next to my grocery list and my partner’s work reminder. It’s not perfect, but it’s hers. Right now, that’s enough. We’re taking it one hard day at a time, and the sadness doesn’t go away completely, but it gets softer, because I know we’re not pushing her to be someone she’s not yet.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Feel Sad When My 5-Year-Old Struggles (And What I’m Actually Doing About It)