Why I Feel Like I’m Failing as a Parent (And What I’m Trying Instead)
By seven-fifteen on a Tuesday, I was standing in the kitchen with a half-eaten piece of toast in one hand and a math worksheet in the other. My daughter, Ada, was at the table, arms crossed. The sheet had twelve subtraction problems; she had finished two. “I can’t do it,” she said. “You can,” I said. “Just try.” She picked up her pencil, wrote 9 for 14−5, then threw the pencil across the table. “See? I can’t.”
I snapped. “Fine. No cartoons tonight.”
The silence that followed was worse than any argument. She picked up the pencil and filled in the boxes. Her hand was shaking. I stood at the sink pretending to wash dishes. There was no big crying fit, no door slammed. But something in me felt like I had just signed the papers for being a bad parent.
Here’s what stings: I’ve worked in classrooms for years. I know that “I can’t” sometimes means “I’m scared” or “I’m already lost” or “I’ve been working so hard all day and I have no more room left.” I know a child’s stress response isn’t misbehavior. I know punishment doesn’t teach. But none of that knowledge stopped me from being the adult standing in the kitchen, threatening to take away cartoons over a worksheet about regrouping.
Later that night, I told my husband, “I think I’m failing somewhere.” He said, “She’s fine. We’re fine.” And he wasn’t wrong. But I didn’t mean her. I meant the part of me that keeps sliding into automatic parenting. The part that hears my own mother’s words come out of my mouth: “If you’d just apply yourself.” The part that mistakes fear for disrespect.
So I started doing what I should have done first: I stopped giving advice and started watching.
Over the next few days, I noticed a pattern. Ada didn’t melt down all the time. She melted down in the space between school and dinner, especially when I handed her homework the minute she got through the door. She was carrying six hours of holding it together around other kids, following directions, sitting still, remembering to raise her hand, trying not to lose her lunch code. Then she came home and I handed her a worksheet and said “show me what you learned.” That wasn’t a problem. That was a demand.
I changed one thing: The paper now waits. When she gets home, she gets a snack, a few minutes of quiet time, or sometimes a bike ride around the block. I call it “clearing the school out of her brain.” The work gets done later, after she’s had a chance to breathe. It seems small, but it changed the temperature of most of our evenings.
I also borrowed a trick from a colleague. When Ada says “I can’t” about any task, I ask her to put a dot next to the part of the problem that makes sense. It could be a number, a word, a picture. Then we start there. For subtraction, she might dot the 4 and the 5. We talk about what those numbers mean. She still has to do the rest, but she no longer has to face the whole wall at once. The dot gives her brain a place to hold on to. I’ve used it for spelling words, too: dot the one you almost know.
This sounds like a small thing, but it changes my words, too. Instead of “Just try harder,” I can say “Find one part that you know.” That gives her a doable action. It also gets me out of the cheerleader role, which honestly wasn’t helping.
I also started noticing the moment before the snap in myself. My body gives signals. My jaw tightens, I talk faster, I start counting to myself. I used to ignore that as if it would go away. Now I use it as a prompt to simplify the room. Sometimes I say, “Let’s take a two-minute break and come back.” We both pretend to hate it, but we both need it.
This hasn’t made us a calm, steady family. Last week, we had a spectacular meltdown over an unfinished alphabet activity. She was supposed to write missing letters on a piece of paper. The letters were not in order, which somehow broke her brain. She shoved the paper across the table and started crying. I felt the old anger rise. I caught myself saying, “It’s just letters. Why are you crying over letters?” Then she looked at me with the kind of face a child makes when they realize the adult doesn’t get it, and I knew the letters weren’t the point. The point was that she had been working hard all day, and the activity looked different from what she thought it would be, and her little brain felt like the whole thing was unfair. I got down on the floor, not because I’m a saint, but because I couldn’t think of what else to do. She cried for about four minutes. Then she said, “The letters are in my mouth but they can’t come out.” I don’t have a phrase for that feeling. But I whispered, “That sounds scary.” She sniffed and said, “Yes.” We did the alphabet activity the next morning, in the car, verbally, with no paper. She got them all right. Her brain was ready then, even if it wasn’t that night.
I’m not telling this to make it neat. I’m telling it because the “I think I’m failing somewhere” feeling doesn’t disappear just because you’re an experienced educator. It comes back whenever the child in front of you doesn’t match the lesson plan you had in your head. The only real improvement I’ve made is lowering my expectations for perfect timing.
These days, I’m less interested in getting the work done than in noticing when the work can happen at all. A snack before a task. A dot on the page. A walk around the block. A minute of sitting in the hallway until the anger passes. These are not parenting tips in the glossy magazine sense. They are just ways of not making a bad moment worse.
Do I still think I’m failing? Sometimes. But I think the phrase should be “failing somewhere,” not “failing everywhere.” The somewhere changes from day to day. Today it’s the fact that she watched two hours of television while I worked after dinner. Tomorrow it might be the spelling test I forgot to sign. But the way I read “I can’t” is different now. It isn’t a challenge. It’s a signal. And when I hear it, I try to ask, “What can you do?” rather than “Why can’t you?” The answer is usually simpler than I expect.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Feel Like I’m Failing as a Parent (And What I’m Trying Instead)