Why I Approve Every Post and Comment in Our Class Blog (and What the New Flair Is For)
On Tuesday morning, Marcus came in early, still wearing his backpack, and stood at my desk. “Why does it say awaiting approval? I posted that yesterday.” He pointed at the Chromebook screen, where his comment on our class blog sat in a gray box. We’d been studying weather patterns, and the kids were supposed to leave a comment on a news article about local flooding. Marcus had written something about how the storm drains near his apartment had overflowed.
“I read every comment before it goes live,” I said.
“So you don’t trust us?”
“I trust you. But I also want to read what you write before the whole class sees it. Same reason I read your essays before you turn them in. It’s not a secret test.”
He frowned, but he didn’t argue. He went to his seat, and I approved his comment a few minutes later. It was fine. Actually, it was better than fine—he’d described the water rising over his sneakers and how his dad moved the car at 2 a.m. I approved it, and he got a little green “Published” notice on his screen. He said, “Oh, okay.”
The approval system wasn’t new. I’d been using it since the beginning of the year, partly because our district requires teachers to monitor classroom discussion boards, and partly because I’d learned the hard way that kids will type things in a chat box they’d never say out loud. Last year, a student posted “this is stupid” as a comment on a classmate’s paragraph about the Revolutionary War. It wasn’t mean exactly, but it wasn’t helpful either, and I had to untangle it before the other student saw it. So now everything goes through the queue.
But the flair thing was new. I added it the same week Marcus asked about the approval delay. I’d noticed that when I did approve comments, a lot of them said the same thing: “I agree with what Tyler said.” I’d count twenty variations of that in one discussion, and none of them showed any thinking. So I made a simple list of tags the kids could pick when they posted or commented: Question, Connection, Evidence, New Thought. On our class blog, these tags show up as little colored labels next to the author’s name.
I introduced it as “the flair system,” and the kids immediately started arguing about which color was best. But once they got past the colors, it actually changed how they wrote.
For example, instead of allowing “I agree with Tyler,” I told them they had to pick a flair first. If they choose Evidence, they have to find something in the article or previous post that supports their point. If they choose Connection, they have to link it to something from their own life. If they choose Question, they have to ask something that can’t be answered with yes or no.
Marcus, after his overnight wait, came back later that week and posted a comment about the same flooding article. He chose Connection, and he wrote about the first time he saw his street turn into a river. He said his mother told him not to play in the water because “you don’t know what’s under it.” Then he connected it to the article’s point about pollution being carried into homes. It wasn’t a perfect essay, but it was a real comment. It had a thought behind it.
The flair system also gave me a reason to send things back to the approval queue more gently. When a student picks Evidence but writes “I saw a puddle one time,” I can leave a private note saying, “This is a Connection, not Evidence. Want to try again?” It’s a lot easier than writing “this doesn’t make sense” in the margins.
One morning, a girl named Priya submitted a post with the Question flair. It read, “Why do our comments have to get approved? Are we in Kindergarten?” I approved it, but I answered it too. “No,” I wrote in the comments, “you’re fifth graders. And I’m practicing my patience.” A few kids liked that. Priya came up to me after class and said, “I was kind of serious, though.” So we talked about why moderation exists. She said she understood, but she still thought it was too slow.
She has a point. The approval delay can be irritating. If you’re on a school blog and you post something on Sunday night, it might sit there until Monday morning. For a fifth grader, that feels like a lifetime. I’ve tried to speed it up by checking the queue twice a day, and I tell the kids: “If I see it, I approve it within a couple of hours. If it’s at bedtime, it waits until morning. That’s the rule.” Most of them have gotten used to it. Some of them have learned to write their comment, read it out loud, and then hit submit. That little delay can be useful.
For parents, if you notice “awaiting approval” on your child’s school account, it’s not something to worry about. It simply means their teacher is reading it before it gets shared. You can use it as a chance to ask, “What did you write? Can you tell me?” You don’t have to talk about filters or moderation policies. Just let them explain their thinking. If they pick a flair like Evidence or Connection, ask them why they chose that one. Sometimes they’ll say, “Because I had to,” which is fine. But sometimes they’ll actually explain the connection, and that’s a conversation.
The flair system isn’t a magic solution. Some kids still pick a random tag just to post quickly. There are still comments that say “I agree with everyone” with the New Thought flair attached. I approve those too, but I usually leave a note: “Thanks for your thoughts. What’s the new idea?” A few kids have started editing their comments before I even get to them.
Marcus still rushes sometimes. Last week, he submitted a post with Question flair, but it was just the word “why” by itself. I left it in the queue overnight. In the morning, he came in, saw the private note, and said, “Fine.” He went back to his desk, typed a real question about why the city didn’t build bigger drains, and hit submit. I approved it before the bell rang.
The queue is still there. Some comments get approved, some get a private note, and a few get deleted entirely. I don’t think the kids will ever love the waiting. But they’re starting to realize that the wait isn’t about distrust. It’s about giving them a moment to decide what they actually want to say before the whole class sees it. The flair helps. The approval helps. But most of the learning still happens in the seconds between writing and submitting—when they realize they can change something, and no one has read it yet. That’s maybe the real lesson.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Approve Every Post and Comment in Our Class Blog (and What the New Flair Is For)