Why Grandparents Take Food From Kids’ Plates (And What To Do About It)
Last Sunday, I stood at my mom’s kitchen counter dumping iced tea into plastic cups, when I saw her hand reach across the dining table and pluck a half-bite out of my 5-year-old Lila’s chocolate chip cookie. Lila had traded half her fries to her brother for that cookie an hour earlier, had saved it for last after picking clean every piece of roasted broccoli on her plate, and was just about to take her first big bite when my mom’s fingers closed around the edge. Lila’s smile dropped straight into her lap. My mom wiped crumbs off her chin and laughed. “Too much sugar for this little one,” she said, like she’d just done everybody a favor.
This isn’t a one-time thing. For as long as my kids have been eating solid food, my mom has taken bites of their meals, swiped half their slices of pizza, and plucked fries off their plates when she thinks they’ve had enough. Sometimes it’s about sugar, sometimes it’s about portion size, sometimes it’s just a “silly” tease that leaves my kids squinting and clutching their plates to their chests. I used to freeze up every time it happened. The first year, I’d bite my tongue so hard I’d get a canker sore. I thought if I said something, I’d hurt her feelings, or start a fight about how she was undermining my parenting. Once, after she swiped half my 7-year-old Leo’s BBQ ribs right when he sat down, I snapped a little over the sink while washing dishes. “Mom, that’s his food,” I said. “Can’t you let him decide how much he wants?” She got quiet, wiped her hands on her apron, and said, “I fed you, didn’t I? I just don’t want him to get sick eating too much.” That stung. I went home that night thinking about it, and realized I’d been framing this all wrong.
My mom grew up the second oldest of five kids, in a house where the fridge was more often half-empty than full. She once told me that when her mom made a batch of cookies, you got one, and if you didn’t hide it from your older brothers, you didn’t get any at all. Portion control wasn’t a wellness trend for her; it was survival. She didn’t learn to leave a kid’s food alone because when she was a kid, there wasn’t enough food to leave alone. That doesn’t make it okay that my kids leave family dinners feeling like no one respects their stuff, but it does make it make sense. It’s not that she doesn’t care about their boundaries; it’s that her brain is still working off a rulebook written when she was 7 years old, going to bed hungry.
I also started thinking about what this means for the kids, beyond a half-stolen cookie. I’ve been working for a couple years now on helping them learn to listen to their own bodies—when they’re hungry, when they’re full. Every time someone takes food off their plate without asking, that’s one less chance they get to practice that. If they never get to finish the meal they started, they never learn to judge how much they actually wanted. I didn’t want my kids growing up thinking it was okay for people to just take their food whenever they wanted, either—boundaries start small, right? So I tried a few small things that didn’t involve big yelling fights, and most of them have worked pretty well.
First, I stopped correcting her in front of the whole table. When I used to call her out right there, she’d get defensive, because it felt like I was telling her she was a bad grandma in front of everyone. Now, if she takes something and the kids are upset, I just say something casual like “Let’s go get you another cookie, bug” and then pull my mom aside later when we’re folding laundry or getting dessert ready. I don’t say “you need to stop doing that.” I say, “Mom, the pediatrician told me the kids need to practice figuring out when they’re full on their own, so it helps me a lot if they get to finish whatever they take. I know you’re looking out for them, that makes total sense, it just messes up the practice they need.” Framing it as a team thing, not her mistake, keeps her from getting hurt.
Second, I pre-empt it now before anyone sits down. When I bring food over, or when we’re all dishing up, I grab the kids’ plates first. I portion them out exactly how I want them, and say right out loud, “I got their plates today—these are just the size they like, so they can holler if they want more.” It’s a gentle reminder that doesn’t feel like a callout. If we’re having treats, I give everyone small treats to start, so there’s no “too big” treat to take a bite of. And if I see her hand drifting toward a kid’s plate, I distract her with her own food: “Oh Mom, I made that lemon bar you like, it’s on the counter by the toaster, go get it before my husband eats the whole pan.” That works 9 times out of 10—she gets her treat, the kids keep theirs, no drama.
I also started naming the interaction for the kids, when it is a playful tease. Sometimes my mom does it just to be silly, because she thinks it’s funny when they pretend to be mad. But the kids don’t always pick up on the joke, so I just say right out loud, “Grandma’s playing a silly stealing game! Do you want to ask her for a bite back to be silly too?” That clarifies things for the kids, and reminds my mom that the joke isn’t always landing the way she wants it to.
It’s not fixed. Last week, she swiped a whole tater tot off Lila’s plate before I could even react, and Lila pouted for 10 minutes. I still bite my tongue sometimes, and sometimes I say the wrong thing. But it’s gotten way better than it was a year ago. The kids don’t hide their plates under the table anymore when they eat at grandma’s house. And my mom still gets to be the grandma who sneaks bites of food and teases the kids, just now it’s usually when everyone’s agreed it’s a game, not when Lila’s been waiting an hour for her cookie. Some days that feels like enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Grandparents Take Food From Kids’ Plates (And What To Do About It)