Why Florida High Schools Now Give Full PE Credit For Marching Band
I pulled up to the band practice field at 7:30 last Wednesday, humidity clinging to the car windows even after an hour of AC running. My 16-year-old daughter Lila, who’s played clarinet in our Florida high school’s marching band for two years, dragged herself to the passenger door, dropped her 15-pound instrument case at my feet, and flopped into the seat. Her black uniform collar was dark with sweat, she had a gel ice pack taped to her left shin, and her 32-ounce water bottle was completely empty. “I would give my entire allowance for a foot massage and a large chocolate milkshake,” she said, kicking off her marching shoes to reveal blisters lined up along her heels.
I laughed and pulled out of the parking lot, but I was thinking about this time last year. Back then, Lila finished practice every day just as tired, but she still had to log 30 minutes of additional activity for her required online PE credit. Back then, marching band only counted for half a PE credit, so she had to tack on an extra online class that ate into the time she had for homework and her part-time pet-sitting job. She stayed up until 10:30 most nights just walking our dog around the neighborhood three times a week to hit her hourly requirement, and she almost dropped the class mid-semester because it conflicted with her chemistry study sessions.
This year, that’s all changed. Florida now allows high school marching band students to earn full PE credit for their time in the program, after a new law passed that went into effect this fall. The bill’s sponsor summed it up pretty simply: marching band is just as physically demanding as some traditional sports. Having watched a full season of practices and games, I can’t argue with that.
I talked to our band director, Mr. Torres, at the back-to-school parent night last month, and he said he’s been pushing for this change for more than a decade. Most people who don’t follow marching band picture it as a group of kids standing on the sidelines playing carols at parades, he said. But between two-a-day pre-season practices that start at 8 a.m. and end at 4 p.m., 2-mile warm-up runs before every practice, carrying instruments that can weigh up to 30 pounds for hours at a time, and learning to step in exact formations while memorizing 12 minutes of music for competition season, it’s a full-body workout. He pulled out a practice log to show me: most students log 15 hours of activity a week during marching season, that’s more than most varsity soccer players I know. Two kids on his team last year missed a week of practice with sprained ankles, and the color guard captain tore her ACL at band camp—injuries that look exactly like what you’d see on the football field.
What a lot of people don’t talk about is how the old rule hurt kids who don’t fit the traditional high school sports mold. Most kids in marching band aren’t playing football or basketball, so they don’t get PE credit for another sport. The old half-credit rule meant they had to fit an extra PE class into their schedule somewhere, and that often meant cutting out an elective or an AP class they wanted to take for college credit. Lila almost couldn’t fit AP Psychology into her junior year schedule last year because of that extra PE requirement. It wasn’t that she wasn’t already getting enough exercise—she just wasn’t getting credit for the work she was already doing.
I’ve had a lot of friends from other states message me since the law passed, asking how we got this done, and what they can do to push for the same change in their district. It’s not as hard as it sounds, from what I’ve seen. First, collect the data that the Florida advocacy group used: national PE associations already recognize that marching band meets all the core PE standards for cardio endurance, muscle strength, and coordination. Most band directors already keep hour logs for practice and competitions, so you just need to put that together in a simple packet for the school board.
Second, don’t go at it alone. My friend Sarah, who lives an hour north in Georgia, got three other band parents together last year after her son had to drop AP Environmental Science to fit an extra PE class. They presented their packet to the school board at a regular meeting, and the district just approved a pilot program for this year. Going as a group makes it clear this isn’t just one parent complaining about their kid’s schedule—it’s a change that helps dozens of students at the school.
Third, frame it as a schedule equity issue, not just a “band is cool” issue. A lot of administrators don’t care that kids are tired after practice, but they do care when you tell them that the old rule is keeping kids from taking advanced classes that help them get into college and earn college credit in high school. That’s the point that got our local school board on board years before the state law passed, actually—they saw how many kids were blocked from classes they needed, just because they chose band over football.
Of course, there’s still pushback. I saw a thread on our local parent Facebook group last week where people argued that this just lowers standards, that band is an art class and shouldn’t count toward PE. I get the concern that kids shouldn’t get credit for work they’re not doing—but these kids are already doing the work. They’re just getting credit for the physical activity they’re already putting in, instead of being forced to do extra work that doesn’t add anything to their health or their transcript.
Last Friday, I went to our first home game, and watched Lila and the band do their halftime show. The sun was just going down, it was still 82 degrees out, and every kid on the field was glistening with sweat by the end of the 12-minute show. Afterward, Lila ran over to me, grabbed a Gatorade out of my cooler, and told me her guidance counselor had just moved her into AP Stats for the spring, now that she doesn’t need that extra online PE class. It’s a small change, but it makes a big difference for her.
Right now, this is only the rule in Florida, and there are still thousands of districts across the country where marching band doesn’t count for full PE credit. It’s going to take time for other states and districts to catch up. But for the kids here, it’s already working—they get credit for the work they do, and they get a little more space in their schedules for the classes that matter to them. That’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Florida High Schools Now Give Full PE Credit For Marching Band