Why Florida High School Marching Band Now Counts For Full PE Credit: What Parents Should Know
I waited in the pickup line at my daughter’s Tampa high school last Tuesday, the 92-degree heat fogging my windshield even with the AC cranked, when Lila stumbled out of the band room. Her marching uniform jacket was slung over one shoulder, her white crew socks stained brown from the practice field, and she was favoring her left ankle, the one she twisted during drill two days earlier. She hefted her 25-pound sousaphone case into the trunk, flopped into the passenger seat, and wiped sweat from her forehead with the back of her hand. “Coach made us run three 800s before we even started working on the new show,” she said. “I wish people would stop acting like this isn’t real exercise.”
That comment hit different now that Florida’s new rule allowing marching band to count for full high school PE credit went into effect this fall. For as long as I can remember, marching band has been slotted as a fine arts elective, with at most a half credit toward PE if you were lucky. I used to buy into the old stereotype too, back before Lila joined the band as a freshman. When I was in high school, band was the thing you did if you didn’t make the cut for sports, if you preferred reading to running. I kept asking her why she didn’t just take regular PE like everyone else, until she dragged me to a preseason practice in August.
I stood on the sidelines for an hour and a half, and by the end I was sore just from watching. The kids were on their feet the entire time, repeating the same 8-count drill over and over until every step landed on the same yard line. The brass players held their instruments at shoulder height for 20 minutes straight without setting them down. By the end of practice, half the kids had sweat stains down the entire back of their shirts, and several were sitting on the curb chugging extra Gatorade. That night, Lila couldn’t lift her arms high enough to pull her hair into a ponytail. I stopped asking questions after that.
I talked to Lila’s band director, Mr. Henderson, at parent-teacher conferences last month, and he said he’d been pushing for this change for more than a decade. He told me about a senior he had five years ago, a straight-A student who’d been in band all four years, who couldn’t graduate on time because he was missing a half PE credit. The kid had to skip a summer internship at a local engineering firm to take a 6-week online PE class that delayed his graduation by a semester. “These kids put in more physical hours a week than most of our junior varsity sports teams,” he told me. “We have the cardio, the strength training, the flexibility work – we already meet every single state PE standard. We just weren’t allowed to count it.”
A lot of parents I’ve talked to, though, are skeptical. My neighbor Karen, whose son plays JV football, asked me last week if this isn’t just lowering the bar for graduation. “My son works his tail off for football credit,” she said. “Why should band get the same?” That’s a fair question, so I told her what the rule actually says: it’s not a free pass. Every marching band program that offers PE credit has to follow the same state fitness requirements as regular PE. Lila has to pass a mile run, do a 2-minute plank, and meet basic strength benchmarks every semester, just like she would in a regular PE class. The only difference is she gets to do that work while practicing something she actually loves, instead of being forced to play dodgeball with a bunch of kids who don’t care.
If you’re a parent of a middle or high schooler thinking about band, there are a few things I’ve learned that are worth passing along. First, if you live outside Florida, check your own district’s policy – a lot of states are considering similar changes after Florida’s new rule, and even if full credit isn’t allowed, many districts let marching band count for at least a partial credit. It doesn’t hurt to send one quick email to your guidance counselor to ask. Second, if your kid hates traditional PE because of the pressure of team sports, don’t write off marching band as a “less physical” alternative – but do go watch a preseason practice before they commit. A lot of kids are surprised by how demanding it is, and it’s better to know that up front than to quit after the first week when you realize you’re sore every day. Third, if your kid is already in marching band, sit down with their guidance counselor this semester to see if you can adjust their schedule. Lila used her extra PE slot to add an AP Music Theory class she needs for her college applications that she wouldn’t have had room for otherwise. That’s not cutting corners – that’s letting kids use their time for something that matters to them.
Last month I chaperoned a band competition a few hours away, and on the bus ride home I watched half the kids ice their knees and ankles while the other half napped. One of the colorguard girls told me she adds two hours of dance practice a week on top of band just to keep up with the choreography. The kid next to her, a snare drummer, said he’s gained 10 pounds of muscle in his shoulders and core since he joined last year. It’s hard to argue that isn’t real physical work, no matter what the old stereotypes say.
Right now, there’s still pushback from some school board members who say this will weaken graduation requirements, and it’s too early to tell if other states will follow Florida’s lead. There’s always the chance some programs will cut corners and hand out credit without holding kids to the fitness standards. But for the kids I’ve seen, it just feels like a long-overdue change. Lila’s sore most nights after practice, she has to schedule homework around 3-hour after-school rehearsals, and she still shows up every day excited to be there. It’s as physical as some sports, as the saying goes – and now, finally, it counts.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Florida High School Marching Band Now Counts For Full PE Credit: What Parents Should Know