Why Don’t High School Courses Taken in Middle School Count Toward GPA?
I was halfway through my daughter Lila’s 8th grade parent-teacher conference when I leaned over her guidance counselor’s desk and squinted at her printed report card. Next to Algebra 1 and Honors Biology—both classes we’d signed her up for specifically to earn high school credit early—there were no letter grades, no GPA points listed, just a big P for Pass. I’d prepped a dozen questions that afternoon, from how she was doing on her lab reports to whether she should add a second high school level class next semester, but this threw me off. “Why don’t these count toward her GPA?” I asked. Ms. Henderson, who’d been doing this job for 28 years and always kept a pack of peppermints on her desk, leaned back and laughed a little, like she gets this question every week.
We’d signed Lila up for these classes after hearing from every other parent we knew that getting core credits out early freed up space for APs junior and senior year, and boosted your GPA early for college apps. I’d spent a few late nights scrolling college admissions threads, so I bought into the idea. Lila is a solid student who works hard, and she’d already finished all 8th grade math requirements, so it made sense on paper. I’d even told her a few times that getting good grades here would set her up for all four years of high school, so I was confused when the district wouldn’t put those grades on her transcript.
Ms. Henderson walked me through the first reason, slow enough for me to get past my initial frustration: 13-year-olds don’t have the same executive function skills as 15-year-olds. A grade a kid gets in 7th or 8th grade doesn’t reflect the same level of maturity or study habits they’ll have in high school, but if you count it in their cumulative GPA, it sticks with them for four years. She gave me an example from two years prior: a 7th grader here took Geometry for high school credit. He’s a smart kid, but he was still adjusting to new ADHD medication and struggled to remember to turn in homework. He ended up with a C in the class. That one C dropped his cumulative GPA from a 3.78 to a 3.62, which was exactly the gap that kept him from getting the state’s top merit scholarship. If the class had been pass/fail, no GPA attached, he would’ve kept his clean average, gotten the scholarship, and still walked away with the credit.
The second reason is consistency. Middle schools grade very differently than high schools. Some inflate grades far more than high schools do, others are stricter because they’re trying to prepare kids for high school. If a kid moves districts halfway through middle school, one district counts the GPA and the other doesn’t, it creates a mess no guidance office can easily untangle. On top of that, most districts require kids to pass the state end-of-course exam to actually earn the high school credit. If you count the grade on their GPA before they even take that exam, and they end up failing it, you’re left with a bad grade on a transcript that doesn’t even count for credit. That’s a raw deal for everyone.
I asked the question I’d been turning over since I saw the report card: if it doesn’t count for GPA, why would kids bother working hard? Ms. Henderson said that’s the myth most parents buy into. What she actually sees is that pass/fail takes the pressure off so kids can focus on learning the material, not just chasing a letter. Last year, three kids dropped the high school Biology class in the first month when they found out it would count toward their GPA, all because they got a C on their first quiz. If it’s pass/fail, they stick with it, ask for extra help, and most end up passing the end-of-course exam anyway.
After the conference, we walked to the ice cream shop down the street from the school. Lila got mint chocolate chip with sprinkles, and she jumped in right away to say she was glad the classes didn’t count for GPA. She’d gotten a C on her first Biology midterm, she said, and panicked for a whole week before she remembered it wouldn’t be on her permanent high school transcript. She just studied harder for the next test, brought her average up enough to pass, and was actually enjoying the class now.
Since that conference, I’ve talked to a handful of other parents who were just as confused as I was about the no-GPA rule, annoyed that they thought they were getting a head start on college prep. What I’ve shared with them, based on what I learned, are three concrete things that work for our family. First, don’t wait for a GPA on a transcript to tell you how your kid is doing. I check Lila’s online grade book once every two weeks to see how she’s doing on quizzes and homework, I ask her what’s tripping her up once a week over dinner, and I email her teacher if I see consistent missed points to check in. I don’t need a letter grade on her high school transcript to know if she’s mastering the material. Second, if your district does count middle school high school classes toward GPA, ask your guidance office what the policy is for dropping low grades. Most districts let you remove a grade if you retake the class in high school, and some even let you remove it just because it was taken in middle school. Third, don’t push your kid to take these classes just to boost their GPA. Most colleges recalculate GPA starting from 9th grade anyway, so those middle school grades don’t even factor into admissions decisions most of the time. If your kid is ready for harder material, great, go for it. But don’t put them through extra stress for a GPA that won’t end up mattering.
We’re a month out from Lila’s end-of-course exams now. I don’t know if she’ll pass both, or if she’ll need to retake one in 9th grade. Either way, it’s fine. I still catch myself scrolling those college admissions threads sometimes, that little voice in my head wondering if we’re doing enough to get her where she wants to go. But lately, I’ve been thinking that this no-GPA rule is one of the few things in the whole crazy college prep race that actually makes sense. It meets kids where they are, instead of making them pay for being developmentally on track three years early. That’s good enough for me right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Don’t High School Courses Taken in Middle School Count Toward GPA