Why does my kid have big meltdowns over small things? Am I doing something wrong, or is this normal?
It’s 7:12 a.m. I’m holding a half-eaten slice of soggy toast, and my 5-year-old is curled on the entryway floor, sobbing because I pulled his blue socks from the dryer instead of leaving them folded on top of the hamper, like I did “last Tuesday when it was rainy.” I kneel down, hold up the matching pair still warm from the machine, and say, “We can change them right now, no big deal.” He screams so loud my coffee sloshes in my mug: “NO, YOU ALREADY PUT THEM ON MY FEET. IT’S RUINED.” I stand back, lean against the door, and think the same thing I think after every one of these outbursts: Am I doing something wrong here?
After I drop him off at preschool, I scroll through the parent group I’m in on Facebook, and there it is: a new post from a mom three towns over, asking the exact same question. Her 6-year-old had a 25-minute meltdown because the grocery store was out of his favorite green apples. “Am I too lenient? Too strict? Did I mess up his coping skills somehow?” she writes. I’ve commented that exact question, in one form or another, three times in the last two months.
Last weekend, we had the park incident: He got to the slide right after another kid, and because he wasn’t first, he sat down on the wood mulch and refused to move for 18 minutes. I kept smiling apologetically at other parents waiting, my face hot, while I went through the whole routine of bargaining, reasoning, and then quietly threatening to leave without him. Nothing worked. By the time he calmed down, I was frazzled, and all I could think was that everyone there was watching me, thinking I had no idea how to parent my own kid.
A couple days later, I met my friend Lila for coffee. She’s taught kindergarten for 12 years, so I vented the whole sock-slide-grocery store sequence to her, and asked her straight out: What am I doing wrong? She stirred her latte and laughed, not in a mean way, just a tired, been-there way. She said she gets asked this question at least once a week by parents of her students. It’s not you, she said. It’s just where their brains are right now. Kids between 4 and 7 carry whole, perfect little plans for their day around in their heads. Every tiny detail matters. When that plan breaks, even over socks, their brains don’t have the wiring yet to shift gears and adjust quietly. The part that handles disappointment and flexibility isn’t even close to done growing. It’s not that you trained them wrong. It’s that they can’t do the thing you’re expecting them to do yet.
That clicked for me. I’d read all the general parenting takes about big feelings, but I’d always turned it back on me: If I’m doing this right, they should be able to handle this by now. Lila gave me two tiny, specific things to try, no big lifestyle changes required. First, don’t start with reasoning or fixing when they’re already upset. Just say the exact thing they wanted out loud, to let them know you get why they’re mad. Instead of “it’s just socks,” it’s “You wanted the folded blue socks from the hamper, not the warm ones from the dryer. That’s really disappointing when it’s not what you expected.” Second, after that, give them one tiny, clear choice, not a dozen options, not a demand to calm down right now. Either change them now, or change them after toast.
I tested it two days later, when I accidentally poured his orange juice before he got to the table. He’d been talking all morning about pouring it himself. He clenched his fists, his face turned red, and I could see the meltdown starting to build. I tried the line: “You wanted to pour the juice yourself. That’s not what you planned, and that sucks.” Then I said, “Do you want to pour a second cup for yourself now, or pour the next one at snack time?” He stood there for a second, blinked, and said “snack time.” Then he climbed into his seat and ate his breakfast. No 20-minute sobfest. It worked.
I started asking other parents about it after that, and every single one had a story. My neighbor with a 6-year-old has a nightly fight over putting pajamas on, and she always thought she’d failed at setting routines. My coworker with an 8-year-old says he still loses it if the wrong jelly is on his sandwich, and she’s spent years thinking she spoiled him. We all see the curated reels online of kids calmly adjusting to change, of parents handling every moment with gentle patience, so we assume every other family has it figured out, and we’re the only ones messing up.
One other thing I’ve started doing that helps, that no one really talks about: If we’re already late, or I’m already tapped out, I don’t even try to fix it right away. I just pick them up (if they’ll let me) and say, “I see you’re really mad. We have to go now, you can cry in the car.” I don’t apologize for rushing them, I don’t feel guilty for not waiting out the whole meltdown in public. That’s a small adjustment that takes way less energy than forcing a resolution before you’re ready.
It’s not all fixed, of course. Last week, he cried for 15 minutes because I cut his sandwich into squares instead of the rectangles he wanted. I tried the line, I offered the choice, and he still cried. We were late to soccer practice, so I just picked him up, carried him to the car, and told him he could cry as loud as he wanted on the drive. By the time we pulled into the parking lot, he’d stopped, wiped his face, and ran out to the field. I still have that split second after every meltdown where I wonder if I messed up. But now I know that question, that self-doubt, is just part of being a parent of a little kid. It’s not me doing something wrong. It’s just this stage, the one we all go through, even if no one talks about it much.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why does my kid have big meltdowns over small things