Why Does My Kid Constantly Ask For Advice Before Trying Anything (And What Actually Helps)
The flour dust on my counter was still fresh from dumping the bag, my morning coffee was sweating a ring onto the wax paper, and Muffin our beagle was gnawing on a stray chocolate chip off the floor when my 8-year-old Lila turned to me, measuring cup held half over the mixing bowl, and said the line I’ve come to know by heart: “Can I have advice please?”
I’d spent the previous six months reacting to this question a hundred different ways. Sometimes I’d jump in with step-by-step directions, because that’s what you do when someone asks for advice, right? Other times I’d get annoyed, the way I did that sunny Saturday at the playground when she stood at the top of the new twisty slide for seven whole minutes yelling down for advice on how to push off, and I finally yelled back “Just go! What do you need advice for?” She climbed back down the ladder, sat on my lap and cried for 20 minutes, and wouldn’t go near any slide the rest of the day. I left the playground feeling like a terrible mom, but I also couldn’t shake the confusion: why does she need my input for every tiny thing she does?
I got my answer a few weeks later at fall parent-teacher conferences, sitting on a too-small plastic chair in Lila’s first grade classroom, surrounded by construction paper turkeys taped to cinder block walls. Ms. Henderson, Lila’s teacher, brought it up first. She said Lila does the exact same thing in class: before every drawing, before turning in any math worksheet, even before picking a partner for reading, she pulls Ms. Henderson over and asks for advice. I told her I’d assumed Lila was just scared of getting things wrong, and Ms. Henderson nodded. That’s part of it, she said, but it’s become a habit. Lila’s learned that if she asks for advice first, she never has to be the one responsible for a mistake. If it goes wrong, it’s the advisor’s fault, not hers.
That clicked for me immediately. I’d always seen her constant question as a sign she needed more support from me, not that she was offloading the risk of trying something new. Ms. Henderson shared the small shifts she uses in class, and I started testing them at home. They’re so simple I was surprised they worked as well as they have.
The first shift is changing your default response. When Lila asks “Can I have advice please?” I don’t give her directions anymore. I just say, “What’s the first thing you’d try?” Going back to that cookie morning: when she asked, that’s what I said. She blinked, like she wasn’t expecting that, then said “I think I can put enough flour in until it hits the line?” I said “Okay, go for it.” She filled it, it was a quarter cup over, she frowned, then scooped the extra out into the bag with her finger. No drama, no crying, just fixed it. If I’d given her the advice, she never would have figured out how to correct the overfill on her own.
The second shift is a clear, easy-to-remember rule: no asking for advice until you’ve tried at least two different ways to solve the problem on your own. It doesn’t require any prep or fancy planning, just a quick reminder when she asks early. Last week she was working on her writing homework, the prompt was “My Favorite Weekend.” She stared at the blank page for three minutes then turned to me and asked for advice. I just tilted my head and said “Two tries, remember?” She huffed, turned back, and first wrote “I went to the park.” She crossed it out, then wrote “I went to the park with Muffin and we saw a squirrel that stole my hot dog bun.” That was the whole story, it was funny, it was hers, way better than the generic one I would have helped her come up with.
The third shift is what you do when she really does need help after two tries. Instead of giving her the answer or fixing it for her, you just give her two small options to choose from. That keeps the decision with her, so she’s still the one taking responsibility. When she was building the Lego treehouse last weekend, the platform wouldn’t stay attached to the trunk. She tried clipping it two different ways, it still fell off, so she came to ask. I didn’t walk over and clip it for her. I just said “You could try adding an extra small brick along the seam to hold it, or you could flip the platform around and clip it from the other side. Which do you want to try first?” She picked flipping it, it worked, and she ran over to show me, grinning like she’d built the whole thing from scratch. Which she had, basically.
It’s only been a couple months, and it’s not like she never asks for advice out of the blue anymore. If I’m in a hurry, like when we’re running late for school and she’s standing by the door asking for advice on which jacket to pick, I still sometimes just point to one and tell her to grab it. Some nights when I’m tired and she asks for advice on what to draw for homework, I still slip up and tell her to draw a cat. She still stands at the top of the high ropes at after-school care and yells down for advice sometimes, and I still have to bite my tongue from yelling instructions back.
But what’s changed is I don’t see that question as a cry for help or a sign that she’s insecure anymore. It’s just a habit, and we’re working on unlearning it slow. Last week we ate those extra-sweet cookies from when she overmeasured the sugar, and she laughed and said “Next time I’ll know not to scoop it when the bag’s lumpy.” That’s the whole point, isn’t it? She’s learning to figure it out, one wrong scoop at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does My Kid Constantly Ask For Advice Before Trying Anything (And What Actually Helps)