Why Does My Child Have Obsessive Conversations? Practical Tips For Parents and Teachers
The spaghetti water was boiling over, the timer for the garlic bread was blaring, and my 6-year-old son Leo was wedged between my legs asking the same question he’d asked 11 times that day. “But what if the tornado comes when we’re at the grocery store? What do we do then?” I’d just about had it. I wiped suds off my forearm and said a little sharper than I meant, “Leo, we have talked about this so many times. Can we please talk about something else?” He blinked up at me, his rain boots still on from the walk home from school, and asked again, “But what if we’re in the checkout line?”
I brought it up at his parent-teacher conference two days later, and Ms. Henderson nodded before I even finished talking. He does the same thing at school, she said. Ever since the town sent out that tornado test warning last month, he stops her three times a day to confirm the next school drill is actually October 11, not September 11. He’s not being disruptive on purpose, she said, it just feels like he can’t let it go. I left the conference stressed, scrolling late at night on my phone, reading about anxiety and OCD, wondering if I needed to get him evaluated right away. I called my friend Lila, who’s a school psychologist, and asked her to meet me for coffee.
We met at our usual spot, the one with the sticky tables and too-strong lattes, and I laid out the whole thing. She leaned back and said most of the time, this kind of looping conversation isn’t something to panic about. Little kids’ brains can only hold so much uncertainty at once. When something feels big or scary or new, repeating the question or the topic is just their way of tamping down that uncertainty. It’s not that they don’t remember the answer, it’s that they need help holding onto the answer, because it doesn’t feel solid yet. For some kids, it’s not even anxiety—their brain just gets hooked on a special interest, and it’s the only thing that feels interesting enough to talk about, all the time.
She gave me a few specific things to try, none of which involved big changes or costly appointments, which was a huge relief. The first one was the answer board trick. Instead of repeating the same answer 15 times a day, or telling him to stop asking, we write the answer down once, clear and simple, and post it where he can reach it any time. I picked up a $10 small whiteboard from the dollar store and hung it by the fridge. That night when Leo asked his question again, I didn’t answer. I said “That’s such an important question, let’s write down our plan so you can check it any time you want.” We wrote it out together, bullet points: 1. If we’re at the grocery store, we go to the back hallway by the milk coolers. 2. Mom will hold your hand the whole time. 3. Mabel (his stuffed dog) comes with us. I stepped back and said “Any time you wonder, you can come look here, okay?”
The first two days, he still asked out of habit. I just nodded toward the board, and he’d trudge over, read it to himself, and wander off. The third day, he only asked once. I was shocked how well it worked, because I’d been so focused on getting him to stop that I didn’t realize what he actually wanted was just to know the answer would be there whenever he needed it.
The other thing I changed was what I said before I redirect. I used to default to “We already talked about this,” which made Leo shut down or just ask again louder. Now I lead with naming the feeling, then redirect. If he asks at bedtime, I say “It feels really scary to think about tornadoes when you’re trying to sleep, doesn’t it?” He almost always nods, because no one has ever said that out loud for him before. Then I say “Our plan is on the board, remember? Do you want to go check it before you get in bed?” Half the time, he just needed the feeling acknowledged, and he doesn’t even bother going to look.
Lila said the same logic applies when the looping is about a favorite topic, not something scary. The first grade teacher down the hall from her has a kid who only wants to talk about T-Rexes, all day every day, interrupting math and reading to share new facts. Instead of telling him to be quiet, she set aside five minutes at the end of morning circle every day as “Dinosaur Time.” He gets to share one new fact, and that’s it. He stopped interrupting the rest of the day because he knows his turn is coming, guaranteed. At home, I tried this when Leo got stuck looping on his favorite Roblox game a few months before the tornado thing. We started doing 10 minutes of Roblox talk after dinner, before we read books, and it cut the random questions during the day by like 80%.
Lila did say there are times to check in with your pediatrician. If the conversations are taking over most of the day, if your kid can’t do things they used to love because they’re stuck on the topic, or if they’re not sleeping or eating because of it, that’s when you reach out for more help. But for most kids, it’s just a phase that works itself out with a little structure.
Last night, we were getting ready for bed, and Leo looked up from putting his pajamas on and asked, “What if the tornado comes when we’re at Grandma’s house?” I didn’t sigh or snap. I grabbed the marker, we went to the fridge, and added a new bullet to the list: “Grandma has a basement in the laundry room. We go there right away.” He read it, smiled, and went to brush his teeth. He still asks once every few days, and I don’t expect it to go away completely until he finds the next big thing to wrap his head around. But it’s not a battle anymore. I used to think I had to fix it, that there was something wrong that needed solving right away. Now I know it’s just his brain working through things, one question at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does My Child Have Obsessive Conversations