Why Does My Child Have Obsessive Conversations? Practical Tips for Parents
I was reaching for a gallon of 2% milk in the grocery store last Tuesday when my 7-year-old son Leo tugged my sleeve for the seventh time in five minutes. “Mom, mom. Why does the garbage truck come on Tuesdays for our street but Wednesdays for the house down on Maple? Why can’t they switch? Did you see the new one with the broken side mirror? Why won’t the city fix a broken mirror? Is it dangerous? Do they have the money?”
The woman behind me in line shifted her basket a little further away and smiled awkwardly. I mouthed “sorry” and herded Leo toward the checkout, my face warm. This wasn’t new. For the past six weeks, garbage trucks have been the only thing that matters. At bedtime, after we close the picture book, it’s garbage trucks. At the dinner table, between bites of mac and cheese, it’s garbage trucks. On walks to school, he points out every speck of trash on the curb and connects it back to garbage truck routes.
I’ll admit I panicked. I stayed up late one night googling “obsessive conversations in kids” and came away with a long list of scary possibilities, convinced I was missing a big red flag. I brought it up to Leo’s first grade teacher, Ms. Lopez, at a quick after-school check-in, and she just nodded like she heard this every week. She said Leo does pull the class back to garbage trucks during morning circle sometimes, when they’re supposed to be talking about the weather or upcoming field trips. But she also told me most of the time, this isn’t something to rush to a doctor about.
Kids between 5 and 10 get fixated, she explained. When their brain latches onto something new and fascinating, they can’t just tuck the questions away. Their prefrontal cortex isn’t developed enough to pick up on subtle social cues that the other person is done talking, or to filter the urge to bring it up over and over. It’s not that they’re being rude or that something’s wrong. It’s just how they process big, exciting interests.
She gave me a couple of small, concrete things to try instead of just shutting the conversation down, which was what I’d been doing that only made Leo more upset and persistent. At first I was sure giving him more time to talk about garbage trucks would make the whole thing worse, but it turned out to do the opposite.
First, instead of saying “We already talked about this” or “Can we talk about something else,” I started trying a specific script: “That’s such a good question about garbage trucks. I have 2 minutes to talk about it right now while I unload the dishwasher, then we need to switch to talking about what you want for lunch, okay?” Naming the specific time and the next topic makes it clear that I’m not dismissing his question, I’m just rescheduling it. That already cut down on a lot of the begging and repeated tugging.
The second trick was the question notebook. We had a small blue spiral notebook with a T-Rex on the cover left over from his birthday, so we turned it into the official Garbage Truck Question Book. Any time Leo has a question when we can’t stop to talk—at the grocery store, when I’m on a work call, right after we turn the light out at bedtime—we write the question down in the notebook. We set aside 15 minutes exactly right after dinner every single day to go through all the new questions and talk about nothing but garbage trucks. Sometimes we look up answers online, sometimes we walk to the end of the street to watch the truck pass, sometimes we just brainstorm what we think the answer might be.
Within a week, the constant repetitive talking dropped by half. Because Leo knew his question wasn’t going to be lost or ignored. He didn’t have to keep pressing to get space for it, because the space was already reserved.
For social settings, I added one more small step. Before we go to a playdate or visit family, we do a quick pre-talk in the car: “Today we’re going to Emma’s house to play. Garbage trucks are super cool, but let’s save our garbage truck questions for our after-dinner time at home, okay? If you just can’t wait to tell me one, you can whisper it to me and I’ll write it down on my list.” Last week at that grocery store, he had a new question about whether garbage truck drivers get lunch breaks, he just tugged my sleeve, whispered it, I jotted it on the back of my grocery list, and he went back to staring at the candy display. No big scene.
I still check in with myself about whether this is something more serious. Ms. Lopez told me the line to watch for is when the fixation takes over everything. If your kid won’t play with friends, won’t do school work, can’t talk about anything at all even during time set aside for other activities, that’s when you talk to your pediatrician. For Leo, he still begs to play soccer after dinner, he rambles about his best friend’s new bike, he can sit through a whole movie without mentioning garbage trucks once. This is just his favorite thing right now.
Some days I still forget. When I’m tired after a long day of work, I’ll snap and say “Can we please talk about anything other than garbage trucks?” and Leo will look hurt, and I’ll have to apologize and pull out the notebook anyway. Next month, it might not be garbage trucks anymore. I went through this with dinosaurs when he was 5, and then space rockets when he was 6, so I know this phase will shift to something else eventually. It’s not perfect, and it’s still embarrassing sometimes in the grocery store line. But these days, instead of panicking that something’s wrong, I just reach for a pen and write the question down. It’s small, but it works, most days.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does My Child Have Obsessive Conversations