Why Does My 2 Year Old Switch Parental Favorites After a Trip? What We Learned
The blueberry oatmeal was still warm when Lila flinched away from my napkin, shaking her head so hard her pigtails flew. “DADA WIPE,” she yelled, stretching her sticky chin out toward my husband across the table. I stood there holding the crumpled paper towel, half a cold coffee in my other hand, and thought: Wait, this is new. Before our 10-day trip out of state for my cousin’s wedding, I was the undisputed favorite. Lila would only let me buckle her car seat, only I could pick out her pajamas, and if I left the room for two minutes to get more laundry detergent, she’d stand at the door screaming my name.
My husband had to stay home for a work deadline, so it was just me and Lila the whole trip. She was great—loved the hotel pool, got spoiled with lollipops by my aunts, and slept surprisingly well in the pack ‘n play. We got home, hugged dad, played with the new toy he’d left out for her, and everything seemed fine the first day. By day two, though, it was all dad all the time. If I tried to put her sneakers on, full-on meltdown. If I handed her a sippy cup of milk, she pushed it across the counter until dad picked it up and handed it back. I was confused, a little stung, and my husband was equal parts amused and thrown off—he’d spent six months as the backup, so this sudden shift felt as weird to him as it did to me.
I texted my friend who leads the toddler class at our local day care, because I’d never heard of a favorite switch popping up out of nowhere after a trip. She explained it simply, no fancy terms: Two year olds process change really differently than adults. Even a fun, low-stress trip upends their whole routine, and when you add a week apart from one parent, their little brains go into overdrive to make sure that parent doesn’t disappear again. The only way they know how to do that is to cling as hard as they can, to test and re-test that bond. It’s not that you’ve done something wrong, or that they love you less. It’s just them sorting out the shift that happened when you got home.
That clicked. I’d been thinking it was some kind of punishment for leaving dad at home, or that Lila suddenly preferred him because he lets her have more crackers. It never occurred to me that the switch was her way of handling the stress of being apart from him, even if the trip was fun. We tried a few small things that ended up working really well, no big changes to our whole day required.
First, we stopped making a big deal out of the preference. At first, I’d joke half-hurt, “Oh, mommy’s not good enough now?” when Lila pushed me away. That just made her more upset, more determined to stick close to dad. So we switched to just a calm, matter-of-fact response: “Okay, Lila wants Dada to do that. I’ll go get your snack ready, okay?” No drama, no laying our feelings on a two year old who can’t possibly process that she’s hurt someone.
Second, we didn’t let me step away entirely, even when Lila yelled for dad. If dad was buckling the car seat, I still stood by the door and talked about the goldfish crackers we were bringing to the park, or tickled her toes before he snapped the buckle. If dad was reading the bedtime book, I sat on the end of the bed and pointed out the silly dog on the page, or handed Lila her favorite stuffed rabbit when she dropped it. I didn’t push her to come to me, I just stayed present. That way, she didn’t start to think I was going away too, which would have just made her cling harder to dad.
Third, I kept one small, pre-trip routine that was just ours. Before the trip, we always cut bananas together right after her nap. I didn’t give that up just because she wanted dad. I’d walk in after her nap, hold up the banana and the little plastic cutter, and say “Banana time!” If she cried for dad, I’d say “Dad will be here in a minute to see your rainbow slices, let’s get them cut first.” Nine times out of ten, she’d stay. It was a small, familiar thing that didn’t change, even after all the new stuff from the trip.
It’s been a month now, and things aren’t back exactly to how they were before. Some days she still asks for dad for everything, even when I’m right there. Last week she screamed when I tried to pick her up from time out, and the neighbor knocked on the door to check if everything was okay. But we also have days where she asks me to read bedtime, or holds my hand first when we walk to the mailbox. Last Sunday, she held both of our hands the whole way to the park, which was the first time that’s happened since we got home.
I used to think favorite parent switching was about who does more fun stuff or gives more treats. Now I know it’s just how these little kids work through change. They don’t have the words to say they feel a little unsettled after being out of their routine, or that they’re scared the parent who was gone might leave again. So they show it by clinging as hard as they can. It doesn’t last forever, but it’s not something you can rush either. Next time we take a trip where one of us has to stay home, I’m pretty sure we’ll go through this all over again. But now I know what to do, and that it’s not personal. It’s just how they learn that both of their people are always going to be there, no matter what.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does My 2 Year Old Switch Parental Favorites After a Trip