Why Do PD Presenters Keep Talking When Lunch Just Got Delivered? A Teacher’s Perspective
Last month, I sat in our district’s windowless conference center for a full-day back-to-school PD, my sneakers propped on the leg of a folding chair that wobbled if you leaned too far left. It was 12:02, and my stomach had been growling so consistently for 20 minutes the special ed teacher next to me had already slipped me a mint to “kill the noise.” We’d all been told lunch would start at 12:15, so when two catering staff rolled foil-covered carts through the door at 12:03, the entire room hummed to attention. Phones went dark, pens were set down, every neck craned to see the chocolate chip cookie stacks peeking out from the side cart. The presenter? He didn’t even pause. Kept right on talking about aligning our reading rubrics to the new state standards, clicking through slides like the entire room hadn’t just shifted from half-bored to ravenous. I squeezed my water bottle so hard the plastic crinkled. I had a 1:30 dentist appointment for my 10 year old’s cavity filling, and I needed 20 minutes to eat and drive across town to get there. If he ran 10 minutes over, I’d be late.
After the session finally ended 12 minutes late, I vented to my friend Sarah in the parking lot while we waited for our kids to finish their after-school art class. Sarah used to teach 4th grade with me, and now she does part-time PD for our region, so I expected her to side with me. Instead, she leaned against her minivan eating her stolen cookie and laughed, not at my frustration, but at the situation. She said she’s been that presenter, ignoring the smell of warm lunch rolling through the door, and there are really boring, normal reasons it happens—most of the time it’s not that the presenter doesn’t notice or doesn’t care.
She told me about her first big PD last spring. The district scheduled the content block from 8 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., with lunch starting sharp at 12:30. She was in the middle of walking everyone through a required de-escalation script that the district had specifically asked her to cover, when catering showed up 18 minutes early. She paused, pointed at the carts, and told everyone they could go ahead and grab their food early and take 10 minutes. What happened next? Half the group got their lunches and headed out to their cars to take work calls or sit in the sun. A group of elementary teachers went down the hall to check on their own kids who were in the building’s after-school care. By 12:30, when she was ready to restart, she was missing 12 people, and she had to cut the entire 40-minute hands-on practice that was the whole point of the session. Afterward, admin pulled her aside and said they’d gotten feedback that the session felt incomplete. Now? If lunch shows up early, she keeps talking until the scheduled end time, no exceptions.
That’s the thing most of us sitting in the audience don’t think about. 9 times out of 10, PD presenters aren’t fancy outside consultants who don’t know our lives. They’re current or former teachers, same as us, working off a strict schedule someone else made. The district paid for specific content to be covered, and if they cut material to make room for early lunch, they won’t get asked back. They also know from experience that once you let a crowd of hungry teachers disperse for lunch, it’s almost impossible to get everyone back focused and on time. It’s not that they want to be rude. It’s that they’re choosing between being a little annoying and not doing the job they were hired to do.
After talking it through, we landed on a few small, low-effort changes that fix most of the tension, no big overhauls needed. For presenters, the simplest fix is just to name the elephant in the room and give a clear timeline. You don’t have to pause the whole session. Just say one sentence: “I see lunch got here 10 minutes early. We’ve got one more quick section to wrap up, it’ll take 7 minutes, then we’ll all break.” That’s it. Just that one line takes all the fidgeting and distraction away, because everyone knows when it’s ending. If you’re okay with people grabbing their food and eating while you wrap up, say that too: “If you want to get your lunch now and eat while I finish up, that’s totally fine with me.” I’ve seen this work, and it takes 10 seconds.
For admins who schedule PD, the fix is even easier: build a 10-minute buffer between the scheduled end of the content block and the lunch start time. Tell caterers to deliver 10 minutes early, so if the session wraps on time, everyone can get their food right away, and if it runs a little over, there’s no conflict. Just let presenters know what the plan is ahead of time, so they don’t have to guess what to do when the carts roll in.
For the rest of us stuck in the audience? If you have a hard commitment like a kid’s appointment or a bus duty that you can’t miss, just slip out quietly. Don’t make a big scene, don’t slam the door. Most presenters would rather you leave than have you huffing and packing your bag for 10 minutes distracting everyone around you. I’ve started doing this, and no one has ever minded.
Last week I went to a small PD on new literacy apps, and the presenter did exactly that trick. She saw the lunch carts roll in, smiled, and said, “Looks like that beat us here. I’ve got two quick tips to show you, that’s it, four minutes max, then we’re done.” The whole room relaxed. No craning necks, no quiet slipping out, no one staring at their watch counting down the seconds. It was fine. I still get annoyed when it happens the old way, when a presenter pretends a room full of hungry people can focus on grading rubrics when cookies are 20 feet away. But now I know it’s almost never that they don’t care. It’s usually that they got burned once, or they’re working with a bad schedule someone else made. It’s just one of those messy little things that comes with in-person professional development. I don’t think we’ll ever get it perfect every time, but those 30 seconds of naming the obvious go a really long way.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do PD Presenters Keep Talking When Lunch Just Got Delivered