Why Do Older Siblings Hide Things? What I Learned When My Older Daughter Hid Her Sister’s Soccer Jersey
Saturday pancake crumbs were still sticking to the kitchen counter when Lila, my 10-year-old, started yelling from her bedroom. Her brand new soccer jersey—custom number 12, her name stitched in neon blue across the back, the one she’d begged for three months to get—was gone. It was 15 minutes before we needed to pull out of the driveway for her first playoff game, and my stress level spiked immediately.
I glanced over at Mia, 13, curled up on the living room couch, TikTok volume low enough that I could barely hear it, half a blueberry pancake in her hand. She didn’t look up, just shrugged when I asked if she’d moved it. “Haven’t seen it,” she said, and that casual, too-calm tone was what clued me in that something was off.
I tore through the laundry basket, checked the mudroom where Lila dumps her gear, even looked behind the couch where stray socks vanish forever. Lila was crying by this point, splotchy red face, saying she couldn’t play without her new jersey, that the team would lose, that it was all ruined. And I kept thinking back to the previous Saturday: Mia’s spring choir recital, the one she’d practiced for four afternoons a week since January. Lila had a last-minute qualifying scrimmage that same afternoon, and we couldn’t split ourselves in two. We’d gone to the scrimmage, left Mia with my sister to take photos, and she’d barely said two words to us all night after. She didn’t yell, didn’t throw a fit. She just went up to her room and shut the door, and I’d told myself she’d get over it.
I went up to Mia’s room to check, just in case the jersey had gotten moved when they were jumping on the bed a couple days before. I pulled out her stack of textbooks from the shelf by her door to reach a hoodie that had fallen behind, and there it was: Lila’s jersey, folded neatly, tucked between her biology textbook and her math workbook.
I stood there for a minute, holding it. My first instinct was to march right back downstairs, call Mia out in front of Lila, give her a time-out, take her phone for a week. That’s what I would have done a couple years ago, when the only sibling fighting we had was over who got the last popsicle. But something stopped me. Lila needed to get to her game, first of all. I grabbed the jersey, headed back down, didn’t say a word about where I’d found it. Lila dried her eyes, pulled it on, we made it to the field with two minutes to spare before kickoff. She even scored the winning goal, if you can believe it.
After the game, Lila went off to a team pizza party, so it was just me and Mia at home, folding laundry at the kitchen table. I didn’t start with an accusation. I just put the folded jersey on top of the pile, and said, “I found this behind your textbooks. I’ve been thinking about your recital last week. I know it hurt that we couldn’t be there. I should have checked in with you more after, instead of just assuming you were okay.”
That’s when Mia’s face crumpled, and she started crying into the beach towel she was folding. She said no one ever cares about her stuff, that all our weekends are taken up with Lila’s soccer games, that no one even asked her how the recital went because we were all too busy talking about Lila’s scrimmage. She didn’t even really mean to hide the jersey forever, she said. She just wanted Lila to feel as bad as she did. For just a little while.
That’s the thing I see so many people get wrong about sibling misbehavior, especially when it’s quiet, sneaky stuff like hiding a jersey, hiding homework, or stealing a favorite item. It’s not just that they’re being mean, or that they’re a bad kid, or that they need to be punished immediately. Most of the time, when older kids do this, it’s because they don’t know how to say what they’re feeling out loud. Pre-teens especially hate sounding like they’re jealous or demanding attention. It feels embarrassing to them to admit they feel left out, so they act out instead.
I didn’t give Mia a pass for what she did, by the way. After we talked through her feelings, I told her she needed to apologize to Lila when she got home, and I took away one weekend of TikTok to make sure she understood that hiding someone’s things is never okay. But the punishment wasn’t the point. The point was fixing what was broken under the behavior. We came up with a concrete thing after that: every first weekend of the month is Mia’s no-compromise weekend, whatever she wants to do, we don’t book any soccer games or other commitments around it. Every second weekend is Lila’s. It doesn’t work for every conflict—we still have to shift things around sometimes when there’s a tournament—but it gives each of them a guarantee that their stuff matters enough to prioritize.
We also put a cheap whiteboard on the inside of the fridge door, and I told both of them if they’re mad at each other or mad at us, they can just write it down, no names needed if they don’t want. Last week, when we had to cancel Mia’s movie night because Lila had a fever, she just wrote “Movie night cancellation sucks” on the board instead of hiding something of Lila’s. It’s not perfect, but it’s better than sneaking around.
We still have fights. Two weeks ago, Lila hid Mia’s favorite wireless headphones after Mia ate the last chocolate cupcake Lila had saved after practice. It’s not like one conversation fixed all our sibling tension forever. But now I know to pause, before I jump to punishment, and ask what’s really going on. The hidden jersey wasn’t just a bad prank. It was a 13-year-old’s quiet way of asking to be seen. That’s a lesson I’m still carrying with me, even when I’m late to a game, panicking, and just want everyone to get in the car.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do Older Siblings Hide Things