Why Do Older Siblings Hide Each Other’s Things? What I Learned When My Older Daughter Hid My Younger Daughter’s Soccer Jersey
The crumbs from Lila’s Cheerios were still sticking to the kitchen table when her panic started. It was 7:15 on a rainy Saturday, her first game as a starting forward for her U13 team, and her brand new soccer jersey was nowhere to be found. She’d hung it on the back of her desk chair the night before, she said, the one with the number 9 stitched on the back and the pink cuff she’d dyed herself in the bathroom sink after practice. We’d been talking about this game for two weeks, and I’d already triple-checked that her shin guards and cleats were packed by the door.
She dumped out her duffel bag, dragged all the clean laundry off her bed, flipped every cushion on the living room couch, and by 7:25 she was standing in the middle of the hall sniffling, saying she couldn’t believe she lost it, that her coach would bench her before she even got a chance to play. I glanced up at Mia, my 14-year-old, who was leaning against the fridge scrolling TikTok and picking at a blueberry Pop-Tart. She hadn’t said a word the whole 10 minutes of searching, and her jaw was tighter than it gets when she’s trying not to show she’s annoyed. I’d seen that look enough times to know.
I didn’t call her out in front of Lila. I just said I’d check the hall closet, and gestured for Mia to follow me. I closed the closet door behind us, crossed my arms, and said “Did you hide it?” It took 10 seconds before she crossed her arms back and started crying, the angry, embarrassed kind of cry where she can barely get the words out. She said it wasn’t supposed to be this big a deal. Two days earlier, she’d had her first high school art show, and she’d asked Lila to come after school. Lila had a pre-game scrimmage and said no, and I’d rushed Lila out right after school, stopping only to glance at Mia’s acrylic painting of our old dog before I grabbed Lila’s cleats and left. I’d even forgotten to take her for the post-show hot cocoa I’d promised.
She’d gone into Lila’s room that night to borrow a phone charger, saw the jersey hanging there, and stuffed it in the back of the closet behind the bin of Christmas ornaments before she even thought about what she was doing. She said she just wanted Lila to be mad for a minute, to notice she was upset, and then it got too big and she couldn’t say anything because she knew she was being stupid.
I’ve dealt with my share of sibling nonsense over the years: stolen headphones, hidden homework, mean notes passed back and forth. For a long time, I defaulted to the same reaction: it’s just sibling rivalry, they’re being brats, someone needs to apologize and go to their room. But this time, I could see the hurt sitting right under the mess, and I realized how often I miss that with older kids. We expect them to be more mature, to use their words, to not throw fits over feeling left out. When they do something petty like hide a jersey, we jump straight to punishing bad behavior instead of asking what the bad behavior is actually saying.
We pulled the jersey out, shook off the pine needles that had fallen off the Christmas wreaths stored on top of the bin, and got Lila to the game 10 minutes early. She still scored a goal, and we took her out for ice cream after. That night after dinner, when everyone was full and calm, we sat down to talk, and I didn’t do the things I usually used to do. I didn’t force Mia to apologize to Lila right in the moment, and I didn’t tell Lila she had to forgive her immediately just because she said sorry. I didn’t dismiss anyone’s feelings to keep the peace. First, I told Mia I got it: I would have been hurt too, if I’d counted on someone to be at my big thing and they bailed, and I dropped the ball by not making more time for her art show after. Then I told Lila what Mia had done was wrong, and her anger was totally fair: that jersey mattered, and it was okay to be upset that someone hid it on game day.
Instead of giving Mia a generic punishment like taking her phone for a week, I asked her what she could do to fix what she broke. She thought for a minute, then said she’d make Lila her favorite garlic pasta for dinner every Sunday for a month, and she’d go to all of Lila’s remaining away games this season to carry her bag and take photos for her TikTok. Lila agreed to that, and even offered to come to Mia’s next art show in the spring, no excuses.
That’s the thing I’ve been thinking about since that Saturday. If your older kid hides a younger kid’s stuff, don’t start with yelling. First, pull them aside privately – don’t call them out in front of the whole family, because their embarrassment and pride are already half the problem. Second, address the urgent thing first – if it’s game day or picture day, get the thing back and deal with the conversation later when everyone isn’t panicking. Third, validate the hurt before you talk about the bad behavior. If you start with “I get why you were upset” instead of “how could you be so mean,” they’ll stop shutting down and tell you what’s actually going on.
It’s been three weeks now. They still bicker over the TV remote, and Mia still steals Lila’s leftover tacos from the fridge when she’s hungry after school, and Lila still borrows Mia’s hoodies without asking and stains them. Last week I got so wrapped up in planning for Lila’s regional tournament that I forgot to ask Mia how her chemistry midterm went until two days later. We’re not perfect, and this isn’t some story about how we fixed all our sibling problems forever. But that jersey mess taught me that the stupid, petty things older siblings do aren’t just stupid and petty. Most of the time, they’re just the only way a kid who’s supposed to be mature knows how to say, “My stuff matters too. Can you see me right now?” That’s something I’m trying to remember to look for, even on the chaotic mornings when all I see is a missing jersey and a ticking clock.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do Older Siblings Hide Each Other’s Things