Why Do MAM Pacifiers Get Stinky (And What Actually Works To Fix The Odor)
Last Tuesday, I was digging through my overstuffed diaper bag for a fruit pouch for my 11-month-old Lila, when my hand hit her favorite MAM pacifier at the bottom, crammed next to a half-eaten goldfish cracker and a dry, crinkly wet wipe I’d forgotten to throw away. I pulled it out to rinse it before her nap, and that smell hit me: not just the usual faint spit-up tang, that weird, stale sour funk that lingers even after a quick rinse under the faucet. I’d washed the whole batch of pacifiers just 24 hours earlier, so I stared at it, annoyed, wondering why this kept happening. MAM pacifiers were the only one Lila would take after we tried three other brands, but this odor problem felt like a constant, gross little battle I couldn’t win.
When Lila first started using them, I just followed what I’d always done with pacifiers: toss the whole thing in the dishwasher’s mesh bag, pull it out when the cycle’s done, pop it back in the diaper caddy. I didn’t think anything of it until that first weird smell hit, about two months in. I tried everything I could think of first: extra soap when hand-washing, running them through a second dishwasher cycle, even boiling one on the stove to sanitize it. Boiling actually made it worse – the plastic around the rim got a little warped, and the sour smell was still there, just mixed with a weird hot plastic after-scent. I posted about it in my local mom group, and half the responses were just “yeah, MAM pacifiers always get smelly, throw them away every two weeks.” That felt wasteful, and a little pricey – a three-pack is $15, I didn’t want to drop that every month just to avoid a bad smell.
I was up at 2 a.m. one night, Lila was teething and fussy, I was waiting for the baby Tylenol to kick in, and I flipped over the empty pacifier packaging that was still sitting on my counter. There, in tiny print I’d never bothered to read before, it said to disassemble the two pieces before every clean. MAM pacifiers are designed with a removable nipple that fits into the shield, to make deep cleaning easier – but that little gap between the two pieces is exactly where saliva, milk, and moisture get trapped if you don’t take it apart. Bacteria grows in that dark, wet gap, and that’s the source of that stubborn smell. It seems so obvious now, but I’d had no idea the nipple even came apart that easily the first month I used them.
I started testing small changes, to see what would actually get rid of the smell for more than a day. The first change was the easiest: every time I clean pacifiers, I pop the nipple out of the shield. I run both pieces under water first to get any obvious spit or milk off, and I use the tiny skinny brush I keep for cleaning sippy cup spouts to scrub the groove where the nipple sits, and the two small vent holes on the shield. Those vents are another trap – even a little bit of gunk can get stuck there and start to smell if you don’t knock it loose. Once a week, I soak all the pacifiers in a mix of warm water and a teaspoon of baking soda. I keep a small mason jar by the kitchen sink just for this, and I drop all the disassembled pieces in before I go to bed, then rinse them well in the morning. I tried white vinegar first, like some people recommended, but it left a sharp sour after-smell that Lila hated – she’d spit the pacifier out immediately after, so baking soda works way better for us, it doesn’t leave any after-scent at all.
I brought the whole question up to Lila’s pediatrician at her 12-month checkup, because I was worried the smell meant there was hidden mold that could make her sick. She told me that most of the time, that stale sour smell is just benign bacteria buildup from trapped moisture, not the dangerous black or green mold that you need to worry about. If you see actual dark spots growing in the gap, you toss it right away, but the regular odor is just a cleaning issue, not a health emergency, as long as you stay on top of it. She also mentioned that after about a month of regular use, the plastic can develop tiny micro-cracks from repeated washing and sucking, which can trap bacteria permanently, so it’s good to replace them regularly even if you clean them well. I started marking the bottom of each new pacifier with a tiny bit of sharpie, writing the date I opened it, so I don’t forget when it’s time to swap it out. That takes 10 seconds, and it keeps me from trying to scrub a pacifier that’s just too worn to save.
I still mess up, of course. Last weekend, we went to my nephew’s birthday party, Lila dropped her pacifier in the grass, I stuffed it back in my diaper bag in a hurry to leave, and I forgot to take it apart when we got home. Two days later I pulled it out, and sure enough, that faint sour smell was back. I didn’t throw it away this time, though. I just popped it apart, scrubbed the groove and vents with my little brush, dropped it in the baking soda soak overnight, and it was good as new by morning.
We’re planning to start weaning off the pacifier in a few months, once Lila turns 18 months, so this won’t be a problem forever. For now, though, it’s just one of those small, annoying daily things that has a simple fix, once you know what’s actually causing the smell. I still find the occasional forgotten smelly pacifier at the bottom of my bag, but it doesn’t stress me out the way it used to. All it takes is 10 minutes of work once a week to keep them fresh, and that’s way easier than buying new ones every other week, or dealing with that weird sour smell every time your kid needs their pacifier to nap.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do MAM Pacifiers Get Stinky (And What Actually Works To Fix The Odor)