Why Do Kids Keep Saying School Is Stupid? A Parent’s Honest Reflection
The backpack hits the kitchen floor with a thud I’d recognize anywhere. It’s 3:15 on a Tuesday, I’m folding the week’s soccer laundry, and there’s a half-eaten granola bar sticking to the cutting board I’ve been ignoring since breakfast. My 13-year-old leans against the fridge, crosses his arms, and says, “Why the fuck is school so stupid?”
It’s not a tantrum over a bad test grade, this time. It’s his science class, where he’s been begging to work on a group project about local wildfire mitigation. He spent all last summer volunteering with our county’s conservation group, pulling invasive ivy and learning how native plantings cut fire risk. This week, they had an entire 45-minute period set aside for project work, and their teacher made them spend the whole time filling out a 20-question multiple-choice worksheet about the definition of “ecosystem” and “biodiversity.” “I already know this,” he says. “We already took the quiz. I got an A. Why do I have to write it down again?”
I’ve had this conversation at least once a week for two years. Sometimes it’s English class, where he got a B- on a To Kill a Mockingbird assignment because he refused to stick to the required five-paragraph format and wanted to record a podcast instead, talking about how Atticus’s “heroism” looks different when you’re a mixed kid growing up in Georgia. Sometimes it’s the mandatory assembly about digital safety that’s the exact same one they sat through last year, and the year before that.
I used to respond one of two ways. Either I’d jump in to defend the system, tell him it’s just practice, that you have to learn the basics before you can do the fun stuff, that grades matter for college. That would just make him yell louder and storm to his room. Or I’d grab my phone to draft an angry email to his teacher, ready to fix the problem right that second. That didn’t work either, because one bad assignment isn’t the problem. Most teachers are just following rules they didn’t make, stuck with overcrowded classrooms and district mandates that leave no room for flexibility.
Over the last six months, I’ve stopped doing both. Instead, I’ve landed on three small, low-effort things that make the frustration easier for both of us, and that keep him from hating learning entirely just because he hates school.
First, I just agree with him first. I don’t soften it or minimize it. I don’t tell him it’s not that bad. I just say, “That does sound like a giant waste of your time. Why do you think they made you do that?” Half the time, he just wants to be angry about it, not fixed. Last week, when he ranted about the pointless worksheet, he ended up talking for 10 minutes about how all the rules seem designed to make sure no one ever gets to do anything interesting. I just nodded and folded socks. That’s all he needed. He didn’t want me to call the principal. He just wanted his frustration to be valid, because it is valid. Wasting an hour of your day on something that doesn’t matter sucks.
Second, we have 20 minutes every Sunday we call “ungraded learning time.” That’s just time for him to work on whatever project school wouldn’t let him do. When he couldn’t do the podcast for English, we recorded it that Sunday anyway. He posted it to his tiny TikTok account for his friends, and a kid from another district commented that he’d never thought about Atticus that way before. When science stole his project time, he’s still working on his presentation for our local community garden, where he wants to propose swapping out water-heavy non-native bushes for native fire-resistant plants. It doesn’t count for any school credit, and no teacher is going to grade it. That’s the point. It reminds him that learning isn’t something you do just to get a grade from someone else. It’s something you do because you care about it.
Third, when there’s a pile of stupid assignments due, we game the system together. I used to insist he do every assignment carefully, take his time, do it perfectly. Now, if it’s obvious the assignment is just filler to meet a district requirement, we do it as fast as possible. Last month, he had three review sheets due the same day, all covering stuff he’d already tested on. We sat down at the kitchen table, split them up, he dictated the answers, I typed, we got all three done in 25 minutes. That left him two hours to go hiking with his friend after school, which is way better for his brain and his mental health than spending an hour on pointless busywork. It’s not cheating. It’s teaching him to prioritize what matters, instead of wasting energy on things that don’t.
I know I can’t fix the whole school system. Some days are still going to end with a slammed backpack and a rant about how stupid it all is. Some teachers are overworked and stuck following rules they can’t change, and large parts of the system are still built for compliance, not curiosity. That’s not going to change because I’m frustrated as a parent.
But so far, this small approach is working. Last night, he pulled me over to his desk to show me the hand-drawn map he’d made of our local watershed, marking all the spots where invasive species are starting to creep in. He’s planning to bring it to the next conservation meeting next month, no grade required. It’s not a perfect fix, and there are still days I want to rant right along with him. But it’s enough, for now. We’re getting by, and he still cares about learning. That’s more than I can ask for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do Kids Keep Saying School Is Stupid