Why Disappointment Over Young Kids’ “Stupid” Mistakes At School Is Normal (And What To Do Instead)
Last Tuesday, I walked into my 2nd grade intervention classroom 5 minutes before the first bell, and stopped dead. The new fraction anchor chart I’d stayed until 6pm the night before making—the one with cut-out pie pieces and sticky notes of student work—had a thick 3-inch permanent blue streak straight across the 1/4 mark, where a kid had smudged the pencil line the week before. Seven-year-old Mia was standing right in front of it, a capped marker clutched in her hand, her shoulders up around her ears. Before I could stop myself, the thought popped into my head: Why would you do such a stupid thing? And right behind that, sharp and hot, disappointment. I’d just started to get through to Mia, who’d spent the first month hiding her math papers in her desk and refusing to speak when I asked a question. Was all that progress for nothing?
The other kids filed in a minute later, and immediately started calling out. “Mia did it on purpose!” “She always messes up our stuff.” I waved them to their seats, my disappointment still buzzing in my ears, and gestured for Mia to follow me to the reading nook by the door. I leaned against the bean bag and took a breath—an old habit I picked up after a dozen too many times I’d reacted when I was frustrated—and instead of asking why she’d ruined the chart, I asked, “What were you trying to do here?”
She stared at her scuffed sneakers for a full minute before mumbling that the smudge on the 1/4 mark was bugging her. We’d made the chart for everyone, she said, so she wanted to fix it. She grabbed the blue marker off the shelf because the dry erase one I keep up there was gone, and she didn’t think permanent marker would stay that dark.
Oh. Right. She wasn’t being destructive. She was trying to help. My disappointment melted a little, and I felt guilty for calling her choice stupid in my head.
This isn’t the first time this has happened, and it won’t be the last. I’m a teacher and a mom to a 1st grader, and I can’t tell you how many times I’ve gotten that note from school, or walked into a room to find a mess, and felt that same disappointment, writing off a young kid’s choice as stupid before I know the whole story. Last month, my son came home with a note saying he’d cut up his class’s new birthday bulletin board to make paper airplanes. I was fuming in the car line, already planning how I’d buy a new one and make him apologize, until he said the teacher put old scrap paper by the cutters for anyone who wanted it, and half the birthday board had fallen off the wall onto the scrap pile. He thought it was free to use.
That’s the thing about lower elementary kids. Their brains are still working out how to pause and think through consequences before they act. They see a problem, or a chance to help, or just something that looks fun, and they go for it. That doesn’t make their choices smart, but it doesn’t make them stupid, either.
After the anchor chart incident, I jotted down three small things I now do when I feel that disappointment creep in, that anyone can try whether you’re a teacher in the classroom or a parent waiting to pick your kid up after a bad note.
First, pause 10 seconds before you speak or react. That’s not vague “give them space”—that’s giving you time to separate the mistake from the story you’re telling yourself about the kid. I used to jump right in with a lecture, and that just makes kids shut down, because they already know they messed up. Ten seconds is nothing, it just keeps you from saying something you’ll regret. I even keep a water bottle by my desk to sip during that pause, which gives me something to do with my restless hands.
Second, ask “what were you trying to do?” instead of “why did you do that?” “Why” makes kids defensive, because most of the time they can’t explain why they did it anyway, they just did it. Asking what they were trying to do gets to the root of it right away. Nine times out of ten, it’s not that they wanted to break something or be bad. It’s that they wanted to help, or they were curious, or they made a simple mistake that got out of hand.
Third, name your disappointment out loud if you need to. You don’t have to pretend you’re not upset. I told Mia straight up: “I worked really hard on that chart, so I was really disappointed when I saw the blue streak at first. That makes sense, right? But I’m glad you told me you were trying to help.” That’s honest, it models how to talk about big feelings, and it doesn’t make the kid feel like they’re bad for messing up. I even added a big, bright sticky note over the blue streak that says “Mia fixed the smudge!” and it’s still there.
I still mess this up. Two weeks ago, a boy knocked over a full bin of counting cubes and scattered them all over the carpet right before dismissal, and I felt that same twist of disappointment before I remembered he was trying to move the bin closer to his friend who couldn’t reach it. It’s normal to feel that letdown when something you cared about gets messed up, especially when you’ve put work into a kid or a space or a project. You don’t have to be perfect and never feel disappointed. You just have to hold that feeling for a minute before you decide the kid did something stupid on purpose. It’s small, but it makes a big difference for everyone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Disappointment Over Young Kids’ “Stupid” Mistakes At School Is Normal (And What To Do Instead)