Why Boys Are Falling Behind in College Enrollment—and What Parents Can Do
Last spring, I sat in the guidance office at my son’s high school while the counselor pulled up a spreadsheet on her desktop. It was a simple grid showing where the senior class planned to go the following fall. Across the top, two columns: “Female” and “Male.” Out of 214 students heading to a two-year or four-year program, 137 were young women. Scrolling down, I noticed the boys’ names clustered in the rows marked “undecided” or “working.”
The counselor shrugged. “That’s just how it goes now,” she said. “Our boys are harder to get moving.”
She didn’t mean it cruelly. She’d been at the school long enough to see the pattern as normal. But sitting there, I thought about my son, who had just told me the night before that state university was “four more years of sitting in a desk.” He wasn’t angry. He just sounded tired. College, to him, was more of the same thing he’d been doing since kindergarten—only now with homework that cost money.
That moment stuck with me. Because the gender gap in college enrollment isn’t a statistic you can ignore by looking at one school’s spreadsheet. Nationwide, women now make up nearly 60% of college students. That means for every three young women enrolling, about two young men are enrolling. The gap has been widening for decades, and it’s not just happening at elite universities—it’s at community colleges, state schools, and trade programs too.
Most conversations about this gap treat it as a “men’s issue.” The implication is that it’s about helping boys feel better about themselves. But it’s actually an economic problem for all of us. The fastest-growing fields—health care, information technology, skilled trades that require certification, and many others—need workers with credentials beyond a high school diploma. When millions of young men miss that step, they end up stuck in a labor market that no longer pays a livable wage without postsecondary training. That affects not just their paychecks, but their health, housing, and family stability. It affects the local economy when businesses can’t hire qualified technicians. It affects communities when one whole segment of the population is left out of the opportunity.
A few weeks after that meeting, I volunteered at a mentorship program at a different high school. I sat across from a junior named Jay, who had thick glasses and a fidgety energy. When I asked what he planned after graduation, he said, “I’m not a school person.”
I asked him what that meant.
He described sitting in classes where he had to stay still for forty-five minutes and take notes on slideshows. He described feeling stupid when he talked aloud in class, and also feeling stupid when he didn’t. He told me he loved working on his uncle’s old truck, that he had rebuilt the carburetor twice, and that he could name every engine part in the car he wanted to buy. He wasn’t lazy. He was observant.
“So you’re not a school person,” I said. “But have you thought about what you’d do after high school?”
He said he’d probably work construction like his dad. Which is fine. But he also said he hadn’t looked into an apprenticeship, hadn’t researched a single trade certificate, and had never once been on a college or technical campus. He was rejecting a path he didn’t even know existed, because the only version of “school” he’d ever seen was the one that made him feel small.
That’s the part parents and teachers often miss. The college gender gap isn’t mostly about boys disliking education. It’s about boys not seeing themselves in the educational spaces we offer them. The traditional four-year college—lecture hall, reading assignments, essays—doesn’t feel like a natural fit for many boys who spend middle school and high school being told to sit down and listen. And when no one shows them the other options, they default to “college isn’t for me” and drift into the workforce with zero direction.
But here’s the thing: those boys still need postsecondary training. A high school diploma alone has never been enough, and it’s even less enough now.
So what actually helps? I’ve watched it happen in small, unglamorous ways.
For my own son, the turning point came when his older cousin took him to an open house at a state school’s aviation program. My son had never mentioned being interested in flying. But his cousin had heard about the program and said, “You always talk about how engines work. Let’s just go look.” No pressure. No “this will be good for you.” They walked through a hangar, touched a small plane’s instrument panel, and listened to a professor talk about maintenance certification. My son didn’t say much on the drive home. But the next week, he asked me, “Is it too late to apply?”
That’s the pattern I keep seeing. Not a sudden motivation to get a degree. Just a kid being exposed to something concrete that connects to what he already likes.
A friend of mine tried something similar with her teenage son, who had decided college was “a waste of time.” Instead of arguing, she printed out a schedule from the local community college. She found a one-year certificate in cybersecurity that had an open house the following Thursday. She didn’t make him go. She just left the printout on the kitchen counter and mentioned that the program started at 9 a.m., not at some unnamed “college time.” He went because he was curious about hacking. He later enrolled, not because she convinced him that education matters, but because he saw a room full of people messing around with computers and thought, “This isn’t school.”
The practical lesson here is simple: stop talking about college and start talking about what’s next.
Ask a boy what problems he wants to solve, not what career he wants to have. Then find the training—certificate, apprenticeship, two-year degree, or four-year—that gets him closer to solving those problems. Show him actual people doing actual work. Walk into a campus before season, not during a stressful application cycle. Let him feel the space before he has to perform in it.
Parents and teachers can also change the language they use at home. Instead of “You need a degree to get a good job,” try “You need a credential that proves you can do something valuable.” Instead of “You’re throwing away your potential,” try “Let’s find a version of learning that doesn’t feel like a punishment.” Boys tend to hear “college” as a command to become more obedient. They hear “what’s next” as an invitation to plan.
None of this means every boy should be pushed into a four-year university. Some shouldn’t. But far more boys than we currently enroll would benefit from some kind of structured postsecondary training—if they could find one that didn’t feel like an extension of high school.
My son is a freshman now. He still says his general education classes are boring. He struggles with essay deadlines. But he’s in a program with an actual hangar, and for the first time, he asks questions about assignments before he ignores them. I don’t know if he’ll finish. The odds are a little against him, honestly. But he’s no longer treating the future as something that happens to him.
The counselor’s spreadsheet will be updated again this spring, and the gap will probably still be there. But I’ve stopped seeing it as a boys’ problem. It’s a problem for all of us—and the fix isn’t pushing boys into lecture halls. It’s meeting them where they already are, showing them something specific, and letting them decide if it’s worth the next step. That’s slow, unglamorous work. But it seems to be the only kind that works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Boys Are Falling Behind in College Enrollment—and What Parents Can Do