Why Asking Nicely Doesn’t Always Work With Kids (And What To Try Instead)
7:14 a.m. The toaster just popped, the bus is 12 minutes away, and my 7-year-old Leo is hunched over the kitchen table, glue stick in one hand, a handful of blue Lego in the other, putting the finishing touches on a rocket ship for his space project. I’m wiping grape jam off my sleeve, and I say, just as nicely as I can, “Leo, can you please put your shoes on? We need to get going.” He doesn’t look up. The glue stick keeps moving along the cardboard fin. I say it again, a little softer, like that will help it cut through the noise in his head: “Honey, please, shoes on. We can’t miss the bus.” Still nothing. I lean against the counter and count to three, like the parenting reels say to do. By the third time, my nice tone is wearing thin: “Leo, I’ve asked you nicely twice. Can you please stop what you’re doing?” He mumbles something about the booster rocket not fitting, and I feel that familiar knot in my stomach. I’m doing this wrong, I think. If I was a better parent, I’d ask nicely enough that he listens.
I’ve been told since Leo was a toddler that the key to good behavior is modeling good manners. Ask nicely, and they’ll learn to ask nicely back. Ask nicely, and they’ll be more likely to comply than if you yell. I bought into it completely. I spent years practicing my calm, polite request, and I’d feel terrible every time it failed, every time I ended up snapping through gritted teeth and dragging a crying kid to the car. After a particularly bad morning two weeks ago where we missed the bus and I had to reschedule a work meeting, I brought it up at Leo’s quarterly check-in with his occupational therapist. Leo has always had a hard time shifting focus when he’s deep into something he loves, so I figured she’d have some trick for getting him to listen.
She leaned back and laughed a little, not at me, just at the whole unspoken expectation. “Of course asking nicely has limits,” she said. That caught me off guard. I’d never heard anyone say that out loud. Every parenting article I’d ever read framed “asking nicely” as the gold standard for requests. She explained that when a kid is fully hyperfocused on something they care about—whether that’s Lego, or a game of tag, or drawing—their brain is pretty much all in on that one thing. A quiet, polite request from across the room is just background noise. Even if they do hear it, interrupting that focus themselves takes way more effort than most young kids (or most adults, honestly) can pull off on command. “Asking nicely works great when you’re asking them to pass the crackers at dinner,” she said. “It’s not designed to get them to stop doing the thing they care about most right that second to go put on shoes.”
She gave me three small, low-effort things to try, no big parenting overhauls required. First, before you make the request, get their attention gently. Don’t yell from the other side of the house. Walk over, touch their arm or shoulder softly, and wait until they look at you. That gives their brain a heads up that a shift is coming, instead of springing it on them mid-focus. Second, give a time warning if you can, instead of asking them to stop immediately. Two minutes, five minutes, whatever fits your timeline. Third, say the request as a clear statement, not a question. “It’s time to put shoes on now” instead of “Can you please put your shoes on?” Because “can you” feels optional, even when you don’t mean it to.
I tried it the next morning. Leo was back at his rocket, I was packing lunches. Instead of calling from the counter, I wiped my hands on my jeans, walked over, and rested my hand lightly on his shoulder. I waited until he lifted his head and looked at me. “Five more minutes of building, then it’s time to put shoes on, okay?” I said. No extra sugary nice tone, just regular. He nodded and went right back to his rocket. When the timer on my phone went off five minutes later, I walked back over, touched his shoulder again. “It’s time for shoes now. I’ll leave your rocket right here on the table, no one will touch it while you’re at school.” He sighed, set down the last brick, and walked to the front hall to get his shoes. No yelling, no ignoring, no hurt feelings. I stood there for a second after he left, shocked it worked that well.
I’ve been testing this routine for two weeks now, and it’s not a magic fix. Some mornings he still complains about stopping play, some weekend afternoons at the playground I still have to carry him to the car kicking a little because he doesn’t want to leave. But what’s changed is that I don’t feel like a failure anymore when asking nicely doesn’t work. I used to think it was my fault for not being calm enough, or his fault for being rude and defiant. Now I know it’s just that asking nicely was never supposed to handle every single request we make of our kids. It’s a tool for casual, low-stakes interactions, not for transitions that require a kid to completely shift their brain gears on demand.
A lot of people worry that being direct means we’re teaching kids to be rude, right? I did. I thought if I stopped asking “can you please” for every little thing, Leo would grow up thinking it’s okay to order people around. But so far, that hasn’t happened. He still says please when he asks for an extra cookie after dinner, he still holds the door open for his classmates and says excuse me when he burps. Politeness didn’t disappear. We just stopped asking it to do a job it can’t do.
Last week, we made it to the bus on time four days out of five. That’s the best streak we’ve had all school year. I still forget sometimes. I’ll be in a hurry, I’ll call from the living room “can you please come here now” and get annoyed when he doesn’t answer. But now I just walk over, do the little routine, and it works. Asking nicely has limits, turns out. That’s not a failure of good manners. That’s just how kids’ brains work. We’re still working on it, some days are messier than others, but it’s a start.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Asking Nicely Doesn’t Always Work With Kids (And What To Try Instead)