Why Asking Nicely Doesn’t Always Work With Kids (And What To Try Instead)
Last Tuesday morning, I was leaning against our front door, coffee gone cold in my hand, 8 minutes late for first grade drop off, and my 7-year-old Leo was cross-legged on the entryway rug, completely absorbed in rolling a T-Rex toy back and forth over the baseboard. I’d already asked twice, nicely. “Honey, can you please put your shoes on?” “Leo, we need to head out now, okay?” Neither had registered. I took a breath, softened my voice like all the parenting reels say to, and asked a third time: “Buddy, can you please hurry up? We’re already late.” Leo didn’t look up. “Just one more minute,” he mumbled. That’s when my voice snapped, sharp and tight: “Leo. Shoes. Now.” He jumped up, stuffed his feet into his sneakers, and was out the door before I finished grabbing my bag. On the drive, I felt that familiar twist of guilt. I’d messed up, right? I was supposed to keep asking nicely, stay calm, not lose my cool. But as I pulled into the school parking lot, I thought: Apparently asking nicely has limits here.
I’ve spent Leo’s whole life being told that asking nicely is the gold standard. Model polite communication, give warnings, frame requests nicely, and kids will comply. That’s what I learned in parenting classes, what I see all over my feed, what I was taught as a kid. But for Leo, who gets sucked into play so deep he doesn’t hear me calling him for dinner, nice requests have always felt like suggestions. I talked about this at his latest occupational therapy checkup—he’s got mild sensory processing differences that make it hard to shift attention away from things he’s focused on—and that’s where the lightbulb went off. She said most kids under 8, even those without any differences, process polite, question-form requests literally. When you say “Can you please put your shoes on?” that’s a yes or no question. If your kid is 100% focused on their dinosaur, the answer is going to be no, or not right now. Asking five times nicely just tells them that it’s okay to ignore you the first four times. Why would they stop what they’re doing if you haven’t made it clear this isn’t optional?
A few days later, I tried the small shift she suggested. We were heading to my mom’s birthday brunch, and Leo was hunched over the coffee table building a Lego spaceship that he’d been working on for three days. Instead of hovering by the door asking nicely three times, I walked over to the table, stood next to him, and rested my hand lightly on his shoulder to get his attention. I waited until he looked up at me, then said clearly, no question: “It’s time to clean up the Legos now. We need to leave for Grandma’s.” No extra softness, no yelling, just clear. He frowned, like I expected. “Aww, I just got the wings on. Can’t I stay five more minutes?” I didn’t argue about whether I’d already given him a 10 minute warning. I just said, “I know this is really fun. We’ll put the whole build on the top shelf where no one will touch it, and you can finish it as soon as we get home.” I held out the storage bin, and he picked up the biggest pieces and put them in. It took two minutes, we left on time, and no one yelled. I was shocked it worked that well.
I’ve been testing these small changes for a month now, and the biggest difference is I don’t walk around all morning feeling like a nag. The changes are so small, anyone can do them. First, you don’t make a request from another room when they’re playing. Go to them, get their attention first—even just a light touch on the arm or calling their name until they look at you is enough. When they’re deep in an activity, their brain doesn’t have space to process a distant, quiet request, even if you say it nicely. Second, when the request is non-negotiable (it’s time for school, it’s time to leave the park, stop throwing mulch at smaller kids), you say it as a statement, not a question. You don’t have to be rude. “It’s time to put your shoes on” is still polite, it’s just clear that this isn’t a choice. Asking nicely is great for when it actually is optional: “Would you like to wear the blue shirt or the red shirt?” “Can you please pass me the cereal?” That’s what it’s for. Third, if they still don’t move after you’ve made the request clear, you follow through with a small physical cue instead of repeating yourself. Hold out their coat, hold out your hand to lead them to the door, step between them and whatever they’re doing that’s unsafe. That’s way more effective than repeating the same nice request 10 times.
My sister, who teaches second grade, tried this in her classroom after I told her about it. She used to start circle time by saying, “Can everyone please sit down quietly?” and half the class would keep chatting or coloring. Now she rings the bell to get their attention, then says, “It’s time to sit for circle time.” She says she has way fewer transitions that drag on for 10 minutes now, and she doesn’t have to raise her voice as much.
It’s not perfect. I still default to asking nicely from the other room when I’m busy stirring pasta or answering a work email, and I still end up repeating myself three times before I walk over. Some days, Leo still pushes back even when I’m clear, and I still lose my patience sometimes. But I’ve let go of the idea that asking nicely should work every single time, no matter the situation. Kids’ brains are still developing. They can’t split their attention between what they’re deeply focused on and a soft request from across the house, and it’s not rude or bad that they can’t. It’s just how they are.
Right now, this small shift is working for us. We’re less stressed, I nag less, and we still have plenty of time to practice saying please and thank you over dinner. I don’t have all the answers, but I know this: asking nicely isn’t a magic fix. Sometimes, clear is kinder than nice.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Asking Nicely Doesn’t Always Work With Kids (And What To Try Instead)