Why Asking Kids to Be Polite All the Time Doesn’t Work (And What To Do Instead)
Last Saturday, I was halfway through unloading groceries onto the checkout belt when my 7-year-old Lila spotted the neon green bag of sour watermelon candies tucked by the card reader. I’d already said no twice—we’d picked up a box of cookies for her school bake sale that morning, and that was enough sugar for one trip. She leaned into my side, touched my arm soft, and said, “Mom, please? I helped you unload the car this morning, and I’ve been asking so nicely. Can I please just get one bag?”
I said no again, reminded her of the cookies, and turned back to the cashier. Ten seconds later, Lila crumpled onto the sticky, soda-stained linoleum and started loud, heaving sobbing. Half the line turned to look. I left my half-unloaded cart right there, grabbed her wrist, and walked out to the car, my face hot. As I sat there waiting for my heart to stop racing, I thought about the three years I spent drilling “ask nicely” into her. When she was 4, she’d scream for juice before I even finished a sentence, and I worked so hard to get her to use her words, to say please, to wait her turn. Strangers regularly complimented how polite she is. I’d told her a hundred times, “If you ask nicely, I’ll always listen.” But I never told her what happens when I listen and still say no.
Last month, I saw the exact same dynamic play out when I was subbing in a local second grade class. Javi, a quiet kid who never breaks rules, raised his hand four times in 10 minutes, each time calling “excuse me” politely, waiting to be called on. He needed a drink of water—he’d left his bottle on the playground earlier. The class was supposed to finish math quizzes before recess, so the lead teacher said no each time. The third time, she even said, “I appreciate you asking nicely, but we’re almost done, just hold on.” The fourth time, Javi slammed his pencil down so hard it bounced, knocked over his entire desk caddy of pencils and erasers, and walked straight out of the room without a word. After class, the teacher was confused. “He’s never acted out,” she said. “He always asks so nicely. That’s what we’re supposed to teach him, right?”
It hit me then that we all do this: we treat asking nicely like a magic button. If you press it right, you get what you want. I did it too. For years, I’d give in to Lila’s requests just because she asked politely, because I wanted to reinforce the good behavior. If she screamed, I said no. If she asked nicely, I usually said yes, even when I didn’t really want to—even when I was exhausted, even when we already had too many snacks. I was accidentally teaching her that politeness equals getting your way, not that politeness is just a respectful way to state your needs, regardless of the outcome. So when the answer is no, even after you followed every rule we gave you, it feels like a betrayal. Of course you lose it. Apparently asking nicely has limits, and no one bothered to tell you that upfront.
After the grocery store meltdown, I changed a few small, concrete things that have made a bigger difference than I expected. First, I stopped tying “asking nicely” to getting a yes. Now when Lila asks me for something, I acknowledge the good behavior first, before I give my answer. Instead of just a quick yes or no, I say, “Thank you for asking so nicely—that’s exactly how you tell me what you want. Right now, the answer is no, because dinner will be ready in 15 minutes.” This separates the behavior from the outcome. She doesn’t get rewarded with a yes just for being polite; she gets recognized for doing the right thing, even when the answer doesn’t go her way.
Second, I stopped caving on small things just to avoid a scene. I used to give her an extra cookie or 10 more minutes of screen time if she asked nicely, just because I didn’t want to deal with disappointment. Now I let her sit with small no’s when the stakes are low. If she asks for an extra story when I’m already 10 minutes late for a work call, I say no, and let her be frustrated in the living room while I take my call. No big argument, no caving to keep the peace. She’s gotten used to the feeling of disappointment now, so it doesn’t hit her like a tidal wave when we’re out in public.
Third, I name the disappointment out loud instead of dismissing it. Before, if she asked nicely and got a no, I’d say, “You knew we weren’t getting candy today, why are you upset?” Now I say, “It sucks to ask so nicely and still not get what you want, doesn’t it? I’d be disappointed too.” This lets her be upset without feeling like she did something wrong. She followed all the rules, she asked nicely, and it’s still okay to be mad about the outcome.
It’s not perfect. Last week, she asked nicely for a new art set at Target, I said no, and she still stomped off to the sock aisle and crossed her arms the whole checkout. But she didn’t collapse on the floor. She even told me, when I checked on her, “I’m still really mad, but I’m okay.” That’s progress. I still catch myself slipping sometimes—when I’m tired and I just want 10 minutes of quiet, I’ll say yes even when I should say no. But we’re getting there. Asking nicely is a good skill, don’t get me wrong. It just doesn’t solve everything. And that’s a lesson we all need to learn, kids and grownups alike.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Asking Kids to Be Polite All the Time Doesn’t Work (And What To Do Instead)