Why Art and Emotional Expression Matters for Kids: A Teacher’s Perspective
Last Tuesday, I was wiping dried glue off my 3rd grade classroom tables after art time when Leo wandered over. He’s the kid who never raises his hand, who eats lunch at the corner table by himself, who got sent to the office three weeks earlier for pushing a boy who teased him about his dad missing the parent-child soccer game. He didn’t say anything, just shoved a crumpled sheet of construction paper into my hand.
I unfolded it slow, so I didn’t tear it. Most of the page was covered in thick, scribbled black, so dark the crayon had torn through the paper a little. Off to the side, a tiny blue stick figure huddled in the corner, and a big red one with X’s for eyes took up most of the middle. I didn’t jump in with “that’s beautiful” or “can you tell me how you feel” — I learned a long time ago that spooks quiet kids. I just said, “That black takes up so much space. It feels heavy just looking at it.” Leo nodded, so hard his shaggy hair fell in his face. He said, “That’s what it’s like when Mom yells on the phone to Dad. It feels like all the air gets black.”
I started teaching eight years ago, and for the first half of that, I thought art was just a bonus. A nice break between math worksheets and reading quizzes. I’d cut it short all the time to squeeze in extra test practice, or send extra drawing home as a “time filler” for early finishers. Parents would ask me all the time at conferences, “When are they going to do more actual work instead of all this coloring?” I used to agree, sort of. I got the question, I think — everybody’s worried about test scores, about getting into good middle schools, about kids falling behind. I used to wonder myself if all that drawing time was taking away from stuff that really mattered.
Leo was the first kid who made me stop and rethink that. His parents had just split a month before that day with the drawing. He hadn’t said a single word about it to the school counselor, to me, to any of his classmates. All that feeling was just sitting there, coming out in pushing kids on the playground and not turning in homework. But he could put it on paper. He didn’t need to have the right words. He just needed to scribble that black until his hand hurt. After that day, he didn’t push anyone again that semester. He still didn’t talk about his parents much, but that weight that’d been sitting on him had a place to go now.
I rearranged my classroom after that. I got a big plastic bin from the dollar store, put it by the door, and filled it with extra paper, broken crayons, old magazine clippings, a few packs of playdough, and some cheap markers. I told the kids any time they feel like their chest is too full, they can step over to the bin and make something, no permission needed. I changed what I say when kids show me their art, too. I used to always ask “what is it?” Now I just point out what I see: “You used all green here,” or “That’s such a wiggly line.” That doesn’t put pressure on them to explain it if they don’t want to, and it lets them know I see what they made, no judgment.
A few months back, one of my parents told me she tried this at home. Her 7-year-old son was having daily meltdowns after school, between homework and his mandatory soccer practice. She’d been trying to get him to talk about what was wrong for weeks, and he’d just clam up or scream. She got a big bin, put it next to the kitchen table, filled it with old cereal boxes, sidewalk chalk, stickers, and crayons. Now when he walks in the door grumpy, she doesn’t ask any questions. She just says, “Want to scribble on the driveway while I make dinner?” She told me half the time he just draws big squiggles for 10 minutes, then puts the chalk down and comes in fine. No meltdown, no big talk. It works.
A lot of people think expressing emotions means you have to talk about them, that you have to work through them out loud to get better. But for kids, especially little kids, their words haven’t caught up to the size of what they feel. You can’t expect an 8-year-old to untangle all the messy hurt that comes with parents splitting, or a grandma moving across the country, or being scared of a big test. But they can draw that black all over a piece of paper, or knead playdough until their arms ache, or cut up a hundred magazine pictures of dogs to stick on a page when they miss their old puppy that died. That counts as expressing it.
It doesn’t fix the hard thing. It doesn’t make the bad feeling go away forever. But it gets it out of their body, out of their chest, so it doesn’t come out as pushing a kid on the playground or a meltdown over a missing homework sheet.
I still have days where I cut art time short. Last week, we had to skip it to do a state practice test, and I felt guilty about it all afternoon. Leo still doesn’t talk much. Last week, he left a drawing on my desk of two separate houses, each with a dog in the yard. He didn’t stay to talk about it, just walked back to his seat. I taped it up next to the feeling bin by the door. It’s not a solution. It won’t fix that his parents don’t live together anymore. But it’s his. He got to put it out there, on his own terms, in a way that felt safe. That’s more important than any extra 20 minutes of math practice I could ever squeeze in.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Art and Emotional Expression Matters for Kids: A Teacher’s Perspective