When Your Teen Asks “Can Someone Please Read My College Essay” (What To Actually Do)
It’s 8:17 on a rainy Sunday, I’m wiping spaghetti sauce off the kitchen counter, my younger daughter’s soaking soccer uniform is draped over the back of a chair, and my 17-year-old senior leans in the doorway holding his laptop so low I can barely see the top of his head. “Can someone please take the time to read my college essay?” he says. The emphasis on “take the time” isn’t accidental. A week earlier, I’d skimmed it while waiting for my daughter’s piano lesson, typed a quick “this looks great!” in the comments, and he’d stormed off, saying I didn’t even read the part about Mr. Henderson.
Mr. Henderson is the 78-year-old retired gardener who runs the community plot where my son works 10 hours a week in the summer. This essay is about the summer Henderson had a minor stroke mid-season, and my son had to step up to water all 42 plots, even though he’d only ever been responsible for his own. It’s not the essay he thought he’d write. He originally planned to write about his robotics team competition win, but he scrapped that after three weeks of staring at a blank screen.
My husband was on a work call that Sunday, his English teacher had already done one full round of edits, and his college counselor only had 15 minutes per meeting to look at drafts. So that left me. I could have said I’d do it later, when I was done cleaning up and folding laundry, but I remembered how mad he was after the piano lesson skim. I wiped my hands on my jeans, pulled out a chair at the table, and said “give me 20 minutes, no distractions.” I closed my work laptop, turned my phone to do not disturb, and pushed it across the table away from me. That’s the first thing I didn’t do the last time, and it made all the difference.
I read the whole thing straight through, no stopping to mark comma splices or cross out sentences that felt off. When I finished, I shut the laptop and looked at him, waiting for him to talk first, instead of jumping in with my opinions. He sighed and said he was scared it didn’t check all the boxes. The college counseling blog he’d read said every essay needed to clearly show personal growth by the end, and he left in the line about how he still forgets to water the seedlings when it’s supposed to rain, and how Henderson still teases him about it every time he stops by the garden. He thought admissions officers would think he was lazy, or didn’t learn anything.
I told him that line was my favorite part. The robotics essay he scrapped would have sounded just like every other kid’s robotics essay, I said. This one sounded like him. That’s what he actually wanted, right? When he begged someone to take the time to read it, he didn’t want me to fix his grammar or rewrite it to fit some rubric. He wanted someone to confirm that the thing he’d poured three weeks into actually said what he wanted it to say. It wasn’t an editing request, it was a request to be seen. That’s the thing most of us miss as parents, I think. We hear “read my essay” and immediately jump into fix-it mode, because we’re stressed about college too, and we want it to be perfect. But most of the time, perfection isn’t what they’re asking for.
Over the past two months of draft requests, I’ve picked up a few small things that work better than jumping in with red pen. The first is, if you can’t give them your full attention right then, don’t fake it. Say “I have 10 minutes of work left to finish, but I’ll set aside 20 minutes after dinner to read this properly, no phones” instead of skimming it while you unload the dishwasher. A delayed full read is way better than an immediate half-read that leaves them feeling like their work doesn’t matter. Second, read the whole draft all the way through before you write down any notes or say anything. Marking it up as you go puts them on the defensive immediately, even if your notes are nice. Third, after you read, ask them what they want help with before you offer any changes. Some days they just want to know if the story makes sense. Some days they do want grammar fixes or help tightening a paragraph. They’ll tell you, if you ask. Last, don’t insist on cutting the “unpolished” parts that sound like them. That messy line about forgetting to water the tomatoes isn’t a flaw—it’s what makes the essay stick.
We sent the first essay off for early action last week. I don’t know if it’ll get him in. College admissions is still a crapshoot, no matter how good the essay is. I’ve read all the stats about how essays only move the needle for a tiny fraction of applicants, and that doesn’t change how much this whole process matters to my kid. For him, this essay is the first time he’s ever had to write something that’s just him, not for a grade, not to check a box for a class, just to tell a school who he is. Of course he wants someone to actually read it.
Last night, he knocked on my office door with a new draft for his state school application, this one about learning to change tires with his grandpa after his grandma got sick. I was wrapping up a work project that was due tonight, so I told him I’d meet him at the kitchen table at 7:30 tomorrow morning, before he heads to school, I’ll make coffee, and I’ll read it properly. He nodded, closed the door, and went back to his room. No stress, no yelling, no feeling like he has to beg for 20 minutes of my time. That’s the win, for now, anyway. We’ll see what happens next.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Teen Asks “Can Someone Please Read My College Essay” (What To Actually Do)