When Your Older Sibling Acts Out: Practical Tips for Parents Stretched Thin
I was halfway through scooping garlic mashed potatoes for dinner last month when 7-year-old Lila nudged 2-year-old Milo’s sippy cup right off the edge of the table. Whole milk pooled across the placemat, seeped into my open cookbook, and left a cold damp spot on my jeans. My husband dropped his fork and said, sharp, “Lila, what is wrong with you?” She didn’t say anything, just turned and ran to her room, slamming the door so hard the fridge magnets rattled.
That wasn’t the first time something like that happened. Since Milo was born, we’d gone through the whole familiar cycle: everyone told us Lila would be the best big sister, and for the first six months, she was. She loved holding him, reading him board books, and showing off her little brother at the park. Then the quiet snark started, then the “accidents” that felt far from accidental. We tried everything we read online: one-on-one dates every other Saturday, special “big sister” charm bracelets for when she was nice to him, time outs when she was mean, taking away her tablet when she hid his toys. Nothing stuck.
Two weeks before the sippy cup incident, I asked her to watch Milo for two minutes while I ran to grab a towel from the laundry room. I came back to find she’d drawn blue mustaches all over his face with a permanent marker. She just stood there, arms crossed, staring at me like she dared me to get mad. I did get mad, I sent her to her room and then I leaned against the hallway wall and cried, because I was so tired. We needed help with Milo—he’s all over the place, gets into everything, we can’t turn our backs for two seconds—and instead of having an extra pair of hands, we had this kid who seemed determined to make everything harder.
We got a referral to a family educator through our pediatrician, and she came over one Tuesday afternoon when Milo was napping. She just sat in our living room, asked us a few questions, then asked if she could stay a little while to watch us do snack time after he woke up. What she pointed out still feels obvious now, but I didn’t see it at all: we were so busy needing help with the baby that we’d turned Lila into a mini helper first, and our kid second. Every interaction we had with her these days involved Milo: “Can you get his diaper?” “Can you watch him while I cook?” “Be nice to your brother.” The only time we talked to her without Milo being part of it was when we were telling her she’d done something wrong.
She helped us make three small changes that have shifted more than I expected. First, we cut out all requests that put Lila in charge of Milo. No more “can you watch him for five minutes” that puts all the pressure on her, and if something goes wrong, she’s the one in trouble. Instead, we ask for tiny, specific one-step jobs that take 10 seconds tops: “Can you hand me his shoe?” “Can you sing that one song he likes while I strap him in the car seat?” If she doesn’t want to help, we don’t push it. We just say “no problem, I’ve got it.” That took away all the unspoken pressure of her having to be a little adult before she’s ready.
Second, we started building two-minute check-ins into our day, no agenda, no Milo talk. When I’m waiting for the kettle to boil for tea, I don’t fold laundry while I wait. I walk to Lila’s room, sit down on the floor next to whatever she’s building or coloring, and ask one quick question: “What’s the best part of your Lego castle right now?” or “Can you show me the new jump rope trick you learned?” I don’t correct anything, I don’t bring up chores or behavior, I just leave after a couple minutes. It’s way easier than trying to carve out an hour for a fancy date every other week, which we always ended up canceling anyway because Milo needed a nap or a last-minute doctor’s appointment.
Third, when she does mess up with Milo, we pause before we react. Instead of immediately jumping in with “what did you do?” we clean up the mess first, then I go talk to her one on one, and I let her speak first. The night of the sippy cup incident, after we wiped up the milk and got everyone else sorted for dinner, I went in and sat on the end of her bed and just waited. After a minute she said, “That’s my spot. He always sits in my spot now and you never notice.” I almost said it’s just a chair, but I didn’t. I said “That sounds really frustrating. It’s not fair that someone takes your spot all the time, is that right?” She cried for five minutes, and after that we put a little sticker on the floor to mark her spot, and we make sure Milo doesn’t sit there unless she says it’s okay. That one small change cut down three little arguments a week right there.
It’s only been three weeks since we started doing these things, and it hasn’t fixed everything. Last Saturday she hid Milo’s favorite stuffed duck under the couch because we spent the whole morning at his cousin’s birthday party. I still get frustrated when I’m exhausted and she does something that makes my job harder. I still need help with Milo most days, and I’m still stretched too thin more often than not. But the screaming matches are down from almost every day to once a week, or less. I’ve stopped expecting Lila to be the one who gives me that extra help I’m craving. She’s still seven, she still needs someone to take care of her, even when I think she should be old enough to take care of herself.
Some days it feels like we’re still figuring it out. But these small changes have stuck way better than any of the big fancy advice I read online when I was pregnant with Milo. I don’t think any of us are going to get this perfect, but it’s nice to not slam doors and yell at dinner every night anymore.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Older Sibling Acts Out: Practical Tips for Parents Stretched Thin