When Your Kid Says School Is Killing Their Passion For History: What You Can Do
The crinkle of fluorescent quiz paper cut through the hum of my dishwasher as Leo dropped his backpack on the kitchen counter last month. A half-eaten peanut butter granola bar tumbled out, and he tossed the red-marked test next to my cutting board, the score big and angry at the top. “Told you,” he said. “History’s garbage now.”
I wasn’t entirely surprised. When Leo was 10, he was obsessed with all things history. He spent all his birthday money on a replica Viking shield, could rattle off every king of Norway between 800 AD and 1050, and made me rewatch every Viking saga documentary on Netflix three times in one summer. He’d drag me to the local cemetery to read old headstones, and ask endless questions about what life was like for kids 100 years ago. That passion was just there, bright and unforced.
Now he’s a freshman in high school, and that same passion has turned into irritation. He flipped open his textbook to the chapter on women’s suffrage to show me what I was seeing. The whole three page section was packed with bullet points: 19th Amendment ratified 1920. Susan B. Anthony born 1820. National Woman Suffrage Association founded 1869. “That’s all it is,” he said. “No one talks about how most Black suffragists got cut out of the official story, or how some women thought getting the vote wouldn’t change anything for people like them. I just have to memorize the dates for the test, and then I forget them a week later. What’s the point?”
I talked to his history teacher at parent-teacher conferences a week later, waiting in the gym line that smelled like floor wax and leftover pepperoni from the student dance. She sighed and leaned against the folding table when I brought it up, and I didn’t get the defensive pushback I expected. She told me she gets it. Ten years ago, she taught at a small charter school where she could spend a whole week on the Harlem Renaissance, play Louis Armstrong records for the class, and pass around copies of Langston Hughes poetry. Now she has 120 students a semester, a state curriculum that requires her to cover 25 units before testing season, and her evaluation is tied 40% to how her kids score on the standardized end-of-year exam. She doesn’t have time for the side stories that make history feel alive. She’s just trying to get through the list.
That conversation changed how I approached this. I didn’t want to march to the principal’s office and demand an overhaul of the entire history department, that’s not a realistic win for most of us. Instead, I started looking for small, low-effort ways to keep Leo’s passion alive outside of class, while still helping him get through the requirements he has to meet.
The first thing we tried was a 20-minute “history snack” after dinner every Wednesday. No homework, no tests, no grades. He picks whatever he wants to talk about or watch. Some weeks it’s a 15-minute YouTube video from a historian who breaks down what medieval peasants actually ate for lunch, instead of just focusing on kings and battles. Last month he picked a podcast episode about a 17-year-old factory worker who helped organize the Flint sit-down strike in 1936. After we finished listening, he spent an extra hour scrolling through the library’s digital archive of old local newspapers looking for more mentions of her. It takes almost no planning, it doesn’t cost any money, and it keeps history tied to curiosity, not grades.
For the school work he has to do, we changed how he studies to slip a little story back into the rote memorization. Instead of drilling flashcards of plain dates, we pair every required fact with a weird, human side detail. When he needed to remember 1929 was the year of the stock market crash, we added that it was also the year Mae West was sent to prison for obscenity over her Broadway play. He remembers that weird, random connection, so he remembers the date. It doesn’t add much extra study time, and it keeps him from seeing all history as just a list of boring facts to forget later.
I also emailed his teacher after conferences and asked if Leo could do alternate extra credit projects when the option was available, instead of the standard 5-page research paper. She agreed right away, and last semester Leo made a 10-minute TikTok breaking down how Hollywood changed the real story of Boudica, comparing what the original Roman texts say to the version the 2003 movie put on screen. He got full credit, had fun editing it, and even got a few comments from other kids in his school saying they learned more from his video than they did from the textbook chapter.
Leo still complains about history class every Monday. He still mixes up the date of the Louisiana Purchase on every quiz. He still says the class sucks more often than not. But last weekend, he dragged me out to an overgrown empty lot on the edge of town, where the old segregated train station used to stand. He’d found a short mention of a 1952 sit-in there by Black travelers, 10 years before the Montgomery bus boycott, and he wanted to take photos for another TikTok post.
The passion isn’t dead. It’s just hiding out somewhere the standardized curriculum can’t reach it. We don’t have a fix for the system, and I don’t know if it’ll ever get better for him in high school. But for now, 20 minutes a week and a few small changes to how we approach study are enough to keep it going. We’ll see where it takes him after that.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Kid Says School Is Killing Their Passion For History: What You Can Do