When Your District Wants to Close Your Public School to Cover Admin Building Overspending: How to Talk to Kids and Take Action
Last Tuesday, I was wiping dried ketchup off my 8-year-old Lila’s dinosaur rain boots while she colored at the kitchen counter, when the district email alert pinged my phone. I wiped my hand on my jeans and clicked, half expecting another reminder about upcoming state testing. The subject line read: Proposed 2025-26 Budget Adjustments: Public Hearings for Elementary School Closures.
I scrolled through the 17-page document while Lila rambled about her class’s upcoming field trip to the nature center. Two neighborhood elementary schools were on the chopping block to fill a $3.2 million budget gap. Ours, Maplewood— the 62-year-old walking-distance school I attended as a kid, where Lila went to pre-K and still runs to chess club every Wednesday after class—was first on the list. Buried 10 pages in, I found the line no one had mentioned in the previous year’s bond campaign: the district’s new central administration building had come in $2.8 million over its $14 million budget, and cuts to school sites were the proposed way to make up the difference.
By drop-off the next morning, word had spread through the parent group. A handful of us huddled by the bike rack, breath fogging in the April cold, while kids darted past with backpacks bouncing. One dad held up a photo he’d taken on a tour of the new admin building the month before, showing quartz countertops in the staff break room and floor-to-ceiling windows in the superintendent’s suite. Another mom gestured to the school entrance behind us, where the front step has been cracked since last winter and the gym roof still leaks along the back wall when it rains hard. “My third grader’s desk has a split down the middle she has to keep a workbook over,” she said. “They can’t afford to fix that, but they can afford that?”
Lila didn’t say anything about the news that morning, but on the drive home from school, she picked at the hem of her faded hoodie and stared out the window for 10 minutes before she spoke. “Mia on the playground said we’re all going to have to go to Lincoln Elementary next year,” she said. “That’s the one across the highway, right? It doesn’t have a garden club.”
My first instinct was to brush it off, to tell her not to worry, that everything would be fine. I bit my tongue. I’d talked to enough other parents whose kids had lived through school closures to know that empty reassurance doesn’t land when kids hear whispers on the playground and see their parents scrolling tense budget documents after dinner. Instead, I pulled into the park on the way home, grabbed the cherry popsicles I stow in a cooler for post-soccer practice treats, and sat down next to her on a splintered picnic bench. I answered exactly what she’d asked, no extra adult drama or budget jargon.
“Right now, the school board is talking about maybe closing Maplewood, but nothing is decided,” I said. “A lot of parents and teachers are going to tell them why this school matters, and we get to share our thoughts too. The first thing I want to know is, what’s the part you’re most worried about right now?”
She didn’t mention friends or teachers first. She talked about the strawberry plant she’d put in the school garden in first grade, the one she checks every spring as soon as the snow melts. That’s the thing adults often miss when we talk about school closures as line items in a budget: kids don’t care about bond measures or construction cost overruns. They care about the small, specific things that make their school feel like theirs.
I stopped by the school counselor’s office after drop-off that Friday to ask what we should actually be saying to our kids, and what kind of impact this uncertainty could have on their learning. Ms. Lopez has worked at Maplewood for 18 years, and she’s lived through two previous closure scares, so she didn’t give me any vague lines about staying positive. She gave me three simple rules that have worked for the families she’s supported, and they’ve worked for us these past few weeks.
First, don’t lie and say it can’t happen, and don’t dump all your anger about the admin building overspend on your kid. Broken promises make kids distrust the adults around them, and constant rants about district leadership make school feel like an unsafe, unstable place even if the doors stay open. I’ve practiced a simple line I use when Lila asks for updates: “The people who run the district spent more money on their new office than they planned, and now they’re making choices I don’t think are fair to kids. I’m going to the public meeting next week to tell them how much Maplewood helps you and your friends.” It’s honest, it names the problem without framing every district employee as a villain, and it tells her I’m doing something about it.
Second, keep every normal routine you can. I kept Lila in chess club, I still make pancakes every Saturday morning, I still make her pack her backpack by the front door the same way every Sunday. When big, out-of-control choices hang over kids’ heads, the small, predictable daily stuff is what keeps them feeling grounded enough to focus in class. I learned that the hard way the first week after the news broke: I spent hours scrolling the angry parent Facebook group after bedtime, got wrapped up in frustration about the admin building’s catering kitchen and unused parking garage, and snapped at Lila for leaving her socks on the living room floor for no real reason. Now I set a 20-minute timer for all closure-related emails and planning, and I put my phone in the kitchen drawer after 8 p.m. It’s cut down on my unnecessary stress, and Lila hasn’t had to deal with my random short fuse.
Third, give kids a small, optional way to weigh in if they want, and don’t force it if they don’t. Lila decided she wanted to draw a picture of her strawberry plant to bring to the public hearing. Her friend Javi, who gets speech therapy at Maplewood, dictated one sentence to his mom: “Ms. Rita helps me say my r’s, and I don’t want a new teacher.” No kid has to testify at a hearing or hold a sign to be part of this, and pushing them to do that just turns their school into a source of stress instead of the place they get to see their friends and learn.
At the first PTA meeting about the closure, Mr. Torres, a fourth grade teacher who’s been at Maplewood for 11 years, talked about the learning impact that rarely gets mentioned in district budget presentations. People talk about closure as a social hassle, like kids will just make new friends and move on, but he pulled data from his own students over the years to show how much instability sets learning back. For kids who move schools once in elementary school, he said, most spend three to six months just learning new routines, new curriculum rules, and which adults they can trust for help before they’re able to fully focus on new material. One of his students moved three times in one school year due to housing instability, and her reading fluency dropped an average of 18 words per minute after each move, even though she was reading at grade level when she started the year.
That gap is even bigger for kids with IEPs, English learners, and kids who live in low-income households, who are already more likely to have inconsistent routines outside school. Maplewood’s special ed team has worked with the same group of families for years; they know which kids need extra movement breaks, which kids need paperwork sent home in Spanish and English, which kids get anxious before fire drills. Transferring all those cases to an already overcrowded school across the highway would mean months of delayed evaluations and missed support, per the district’s own special ed wait time data. That’s not a “feeling” about neighborhood schools—that’s a measurable hit to kids’ learning, all to cover a construction overrun on an office most kids will never step foot in.
A lot of the conversation at that first meeting centered on big, high-lift actions: recalling school board members, organizing a district-wide strike, filing lawsuits. Those things have their place, but most of us are working parents who don’t have extra time for that between homework help and bedtimes. The group organizing our response put together low-effort, high-impact steps any parent or teacher can do in 10 minutes after dinner, and they’ve already made a difference. Instead of sending generic angry emails that get filtered into a generic inbox, send one specific, personal story that ties to the priorities the district already says it has. If the district says it wants to cut absenteeism, mention that 42% of Maplewood kids walk to school, and the proposed receiving school has no sidewalks along the main route, so kids will miss more days in bad weather. If your kid gets free after-school tutoring that helped them go up two reading levels this year, say that, and note that Lincoln Elementary already cut its tutoring program last year due to overcrowding. I wrote my comment in 12 minutes while Lila did her math worksheet, and I got a personal reply from two school board members the next day.
Last week, 120 of us showed up to the first public hearing. Kids carried drawings of the playground and the garden, teachers brought stacks of student work, and more than 30 people spoke for two minutes each about the specific supports and small moments that make Maplewood work. By the end of the night, the board voted to delay the closure vote for 30 days to review more public feedback and look at alternative cuts, like trimming admin salaries and pausing planned renovations to the new admin building’s conference wing.
Last Saturday, Lila and I stopped by the school garden after her soccer game to weed around her strawberry plant. She pushed back a cluster of leaves and found one tiny green berry tucked against the stem, no bigger than her thumbnail. “I’m going to leave it there,” she said. “If we have to leave, the new kids can find it when it turns red.”
I knelt down next to her and pulled a dandelion out of the dirt next to the bed. We don’t know what the board will vote next month. We don’t know if they’ll choose to cut admin costs instead of closing schools, or if they’ll still vote to lock the doors at the end of the semester. Some nights I still lie awake and think about the leaking roof and the quartz countertops, about how easy it is for district leaders to treat neighborhood schools like disposable line items.
But right now, Lila still has art class on Tuesday mornings. She still sits next to her best friend at lunch, and she still gets to check her strawberry plant every recess. That’s enough for this week.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your District Wants to Close Your Public School to Cover Admin Building Overspending: How to Talk to Kids and Take Action