When Your Child Says A Subject Is The Worst: What I Learned From My Own School Struggles
Last month, my 10-year-old son Milo trundled in from the bus, dropped his scuffed backpack by the front door, and said, “Social studies is the worst. I’m never going back to that class.” I was pulling leftover pepperoni pizza out of the fridge for after-school snack, so I just nodded at first. I’ve heard this same line about math, about PE, about the mandatory intro coding club he had to join last semester. But then he said it again, louder, kicking the leg of the kitchen table: “I hate it. It’s stupid. Why do I even have to go?” And that’s when I thought of my own worst subject: 11th grade chemistry.
I was a solid B student, mostly, got A’s in anything that let me read and write, scraped by in math without too much trouble. But chemistry? I’d sit in the back of Room 214, stare at the faded periodic table taped to the cinder block wall, and feel my brain go soft. All those random symbols, all those equations that didn’t add up to anything that made sense to me. I’d study for three straight days for a test, highlight half my textbook, do every practice problem twice, and get a 52 back. I’d tuck the test in the back of my notebook so my mom wouldn’t see, and walk out of class with my shoulders hunched, convinced I was just inherently bad at science, full stop. Once I faked a fever the morning of a midterm, and spent the whole day on the couch watching re-runs of The Price is Right, feeling equal parts guilty and relieved. No one ever asked what made it so hard. My teacher said I just wasn’t trying hard enough. My dad said if I would just stop listening to my Walkman while I studied, I’d get it. By the end of the semester, I believed them.
So when Milo said he hated social studies, I didn’t jump in with the “just try harder” or “it’ll be worth it later” speech I got growing up. I pushed the plate of pizza crusts across the table toward him and asked, “What’s the part that’s the worst, exactly? It’s not the map work, right? You like coloring maps.” It turned out, it wasn’t the dates or the capitals or anything to do with the actual subject content. His teacher requires every student to do a three-minute current events presentation in front of the whole class every Friday. Milo gets so nervous his palms sweat right through his note cards, they slip out of his hands when he walks to the front of the room, and the kids snicker when he stutters and forgets his next line. That’s why the whole subject is the worst: it’s not the work, it’s the feeling of being embarrassed and exposed every single week.
That’s the thing I’ve learned now, as a parent: the “worst subject” is almost never actually about the subject. It’s about the specific pain point tied to it that no one’s bothered to dig up. I didn’t struggle with chemistry because I was bad at science. I struggled because my teacher taught like everyone was already prepping for a college engineering degree, he never stopped to re-explain a concept if half the class still looked confused, and I was too shy to raise my hand and say I didn’t get it after he moved on. Every bad test made me more anxious, so I studied less instead of more, and the cycle just got worse. No one asked me what the hard part was, they just told me I wasn’t trying.
Instead of that, I tried a few small, concrete things with Milo. First, we practiced his presentation in the car on the way to school the next Friday, not at the kitchen table where it felt like another homework assignment. He was talking about the new skate park the city council was voting on, a topic he’d been bugging me about for months, so I let him hold his skateboard while he practiced, instead of forcing him to write out full note cards. Then I sent a short, polite email to his social studies teacher. I didn’t complain or demand special treatment. I just said, “Milo gets really anxious about front-of-the-room presentations, and it’s making him dread the whole class. Would it be okay if he does this week’s presentation for just you first, or records it to play for the class instead of standing up front?” He wrote back 20 minutes later saying that sounded totally fine.
That’s the practical trick I share with other parents now, when they ask what to do about a kid’s worst subject. First, skip the big speech and ask three specific questions: What part of this is the worst for you? When do you start feeling bad about it? Is there one small thing that would make it better? You don’t have to fix the whole thing right away, you just have to find the actual problem. Second, try one tiny adjustment before you jump into big changes like tutors or teacher switches. Small changes take almost no effort, and they take the sharp edge off the bad feeling. Third, it’s okay if they still don’t love the subject at the end. No one is good at everything, and no one has to love every required class.
Last week, Milo came home from school and said social studies is still kind of the worst, but he didn’t mind it this week. He did his presentation in front of three of his friends instead of the whole 30-person class, and he didn’t drop his note cards once. I didn’t tell him that one day he’ll grow to love social studies, or that public speaking is a skill he’ll need for life. I just high-fived him and gave him an extra chocolate chip cookie after dinner.
I still think chemistry is the worst. I’m a freelance writer now, I don’t need to balance chemical equations or identify unknown compounds for my job. That’s fine. Some things just don’t click, and that’s okay. The point isn’t to make every subject your kid’s favorite. It’s just to keep the bad feeling from one bad subject from bleeding into how they feel about learning, or about themselves. Right now, that’s enough for us. We’ll see what next semester brings.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Child Says A Subject Is The Worst: What I Learned From My Own School Struggles