When You Question Your Child’s Special Ed Teacher: What I Learned From Speaking Up
The first time I saw the sticker chart, I almost laughed. It was taped to the wall near the door, with my son’s name at the top and a row of little green stars that stopped abruptly at Tuesday. Underneath, in bright red marker, was a note: “Ethan needs to earn 5 stars to go to the treasure box.” Ethan is seven and has autism. He communicates mostly through picture cards and a few spoken words. The treasure box was a cardboard bin filled with broken crayons and plastic dinosaurs.
I hadn’t planned to volunteer in his classroom that day. I had dropped off a raincoat and decided to peek through the window in the door. His teacher, Mrs. Parsons, was kneeling next to him. Ethan was rocking slightly, humming his comfort tune, and she was holding up a single gold star sticker, saying, “If you stop rocking, you can have the star. Be still now.” He didn’t stop. He hummed louder. She put the sticker on his hand anyway, but her face had that tight, polite smile that I’d learned to recognize from parent-teacher conferences. The smile that says I’m being patient with you, but you’re making my job hard.
I stood there for another minute. The classroom was bright and orderly, with labeled bins and a visual schedule that ran along the whiteboard. It looked like a well-run place. But something about that sticker chart kept pulling at me. It wasn’t cruel. It wasn’t even unusual. It was just wrong in a way I couldn’t quickly name.
Later that week, I brought it up at our monthly check-in meeting. The team included Mrs. Parsons, the speech therapist, and the district’s inclusion specialist, who joined over video call. I tried to keep my voice even. “I noticed Ethan has a sticker chart for staying quiet,” I said. “But he was humming because he was happy, not because he was off task. Is there a way to reward communication instead of stillness?”
Mrs. Parsons folded her hands. “Well, the hum is disruptive to the other students,” she explained. “We’re working on self-regulation. If he can show us he’s ready to learn, then he earns a reward. The chart gives him a concrete goal.”
I didn’t know the right terms. I didn’t know what an FBA or a BIP were at the time, though I would learn them soon. All I knew was that asking a child with sensory differences to stop a self-soothing behavior in order to “earn” a broken dinosaur felt less like teaching and more like making him small. I said something like, “But what is he learning? That his body is wrong?”
The inclusion specialist spoke up then. She asked Mrs. Parsons if she’d considered a sensory break schedule instead of a contingent reward. The speech therapist suggested giving Ethan a picture card that meant “pause” rather than demanding silence. I saw the conversation shift, and I felt both relieved and terrified, because I realized I had to be the one to start it.
That was two years ago. Since then, I’ve done a lot of reading, a lot of listening, and a lot of awkward meetings where I’m the only parent in a room full of professionals. I’ve also learned that “questionable” in special education can mean a lot of things. Sometimes it’s a teacher who means well but uses outdated methods. Sometimes it’s a system that prioritizes order over dignity. And sometimes—rarely, but sometimes—it’s something that needs to be addressed directly, through the school’s official channels.
What helped me most, honestly, was keeping a simple log. At first it felt obsessive. I wrote down every concerning interaction: the date, the time, what Ethan said or did before and after. Not just bad things—I also noted when he came home happy, when a lesson went well, when he used a new word. That log became my grounding place. When I walked into an IEP meeting and felt my chest tighten, I could open my notebook and point to patterns, not vague feelings. “On October 4th, he came home crying and wouldn’t take his coat off. On October 7th, he had the same schedule, and he was fine. What changed?” That shifted the conversation from my anxiety to observable data.
I also learned to ask questions without apologizing. Instead of saying, “I’m sorry, but…,” I started saying, “Can you walk me through the reasoning behind that?” It’s a small change, but it changed everything. Mrs. Parsons, for her part, wasn’t a villain. She was a tired, underpaid teacher with thirty years of experience and a district mandate to show progress. Once I stopped framing our meetings as a confrontation and started framing them as a problem-solving session, she relaxed. She even admitted, once, that she hadn’t been trained on sensory processing in college. “We learned behavior modification,” she said, shrugging. “That’s the old way.”
The old way is still everywhere. Reward charts, red light–green light systems, time-out corners that have been renamed “cool-off spots.” Some of it works for some kids. But for a child with a communication delay, a system that subtracts stars for “bad” behavior can feel like a punishment for not being able to explain themselves. When a child can’t say, “I’m overwhelmed,” they might flap, rock, or hum. If the teacher’s response is to withhold a sticker, the child learns that their body’s honest response is wrong.
There are better tools, but they require trust. If you’re in a similar spot, here’s what I wish someone had told me early on.
First, request an observation—but make it specific. Don’t say, “I want to see what’s happening.” Say, “I’d like to observe during a transition period and a seated activity, and I’ll sit quietly in the back.” That way, you’re not there to judge; you’re there to see what the child sees. I did this three times. The first time, I watched Ethan’s teacher prompt him through every step of a worksheet, barely giving him space to think. The second time, I saw her give him extra time and a quiet hand signal. The difference wasn’t malice. It was awareness.
Second, ask for data on specific behaviors. Special ed teachers deal with mountains of paperwork, but they track things like on-task time, occurrence of hums, or minutes to completion. Say, “Could you chart how often the humming happens during the morning circle and also in the afternoon?” Then you can look at the numbers together and ask whether the intervention is actually changing them. If it isn’t, you have a reason to try something else.
Third, remember that you can bring an outside opinion without turning it into a battle. I hired an independent educational advocate for one meeting. She didn’t yell or threaten. She simply asked better questions than I did. “What’s the replacement behavior for humming?” she asked. Mrs. Parsons looked confused. “If you’re going to stop the hum, what do you want him to do instead? Raise his hand? Shake a bell? How does he ask for a break?” That one question opened up a whole conversation that eventually led to Ethan getting a small sand timer on his desk. When he feels wiggly, he flips the timer and takes three minutes to squeeze a stress ball. The humming has mostly stopped, but not because he’s suppressing it. Because he has an alternative that works.
I still question things. I question the way the school groups kids, the way homework is assigned, the way progress is measured. Some battles I’ve let go because they weren’t worth the energy. Others I’ve pushed, and I’ve learned that a calm, persistent parent is more respected than an angry one. You don’t have to be a trained behaviorist to know when something doesn’t sit right in your gut. But you have to be willing to sit with that feeling long enough to turn it into a clear sentence.
Last week, Mrs. Parsons retired. Her replacement is young, fresh out of grad school, and she asked me for tips. I laughed and said, “Ask my son, not me.” Because that’s the part I didn’t understand early on. At the end of the day, Ethan isn’t a problem to be solved. He’s a kid who hums when he’s happy, rocks when he’s overloaded, and spends his afternoons chasing our old dog around the yard. The school is just a place he goes during the day. It’s our job to make sure that place respects who he already is, not just who they want him to be. I’m still learning how to do that. I suspect I always will be.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When You Question Your Child’s Special Ed Teacher: What I Learned From Speaking Up