When My 8-Year-Old Said “How Do I Do It, Guys?” At Homework Time: Small Changes That Helped
It was 6:47 on a Tuesday, and the kitchen smelled like leftover spaghetti sauce and the strawberry juice box Milo had squeezed so hard the sides were bent. I was folding socks on the counter, half listening for the work email ping I knew was coming, when his pencil rolled across the table and stopped against my stack of dish towels. “How do I do it guys,” he said. Not yelling, not sniffling, just flat, blank, like he was asking the wall and the cat curled on his extra worksheet and me all at once. It took me a second to realize he’d forgotten I was the only person in the room. That line was the one he used with his third-grade table group, the first thing out of half the kids’ mouths the second they hit a problem they couldn’t solve in two seconds flat.
This had been going on for three weeks straight, ever since his math unit moved from straight multiplication drills to word problems about pizza parties and field trip buses and packing goodie bags. We’d already had one meltdown over eraser crumbs, two rounds of “can I just take a break to pet the dog,” and I’d already explained what a dozen was twice. My first instinct, the one I’d given in to a dozen times already, was to wipe my hands on my jeans, slide into the chair next to him, point at the first line, and walk him through every step until the worksheet was done. It was faster. It meant he got to bed by 8:30. It meant I didn’t have to spend the rest of the evening negotiating homework when I still had to pack his lunch and answer that work email and take the trash out. But the week before, his teacher Ms. Henderson had sent a short note home after an exit ticket: Milo had turned in half a blank page, and written “I didn’t know how” across the top. He’d put his pencil down 10 seconds after reading the first problem, she said, and asked his table for help before he’d even finished reading the whole thing.
I’d talked to her after pickup a few days later, leaning against the bike rack while kids ran past with melting rainbow popsicles. She laughed when I repeated the “how do I do it guys” line. “I hear that 20 times an hour,” she said. “They’re not being lazy. They’re so used to someone stepping in right when things feel hard, they don’t know what to do with that stuck feeling for even 10 seconds.” She showed me the beat-up popsicle sticks she keeps at every table group, each one scrawled with three prompts in chipped black marker. No fancy curriculum, no 10-step problem-solving method. Just three small things to do before you ask anyone for help.
That Tuesday night, I grabbed the laundry basket and carried it over to the chair across the table from him, not the one right next to his elbow. I’d learned the week before that if I sat next to him, my hand automatically reached for the pencil before I even thought about it. “I hear you,” I said, instead of “it’s easy” or “just try” or “we went over this last week,” all lines that had backfired and ended in tears before. “Before I help, can you do three quick things for me? First, read the whole problem out loud slow. Second, circle the actual question it’s asking you, not all the extra stuff about pepperoni. Third, write down every number it gives you, even if you don’t know what to do with it yet.”
He huffed so hard his bangs fluttered, but he did it. He read the problem out loud: “The third grade is having a pizza party. There are 28 students and 2 teachers. Each pizza has 8 slices. How many pizzas do they need to order?” He circled “how many pizzas do they need to order” in wiggly pencil, then wrote 28, 2, 8 off to the side. He stared at it for 12 seconds, I counted, because I was folding socks and watching over the top of the pile. “Wait,” he said. “First add the people. 30. Then divide by 8? But that’s 3.75. Do we round up?” Just like that, he wasn’t blank anymore. He’d found the actual stuck part, instead of drowning in the whole worksheet all at once.
I volunteered in his math class the next week, and I saw how it works with the whole group. A girl at the next table over dropped her pencil and said the exact same line, “how do I do it guys,” and her table partner just slid her the popsicle stick instead of leaning over to tell her the answer. She read the prompts out loud under her breath, worked through all three, and yelped “oh!” so loud the whole table looked over. It struck me that I’d spent so much time thinking I had to choose between giving him the answer or leaving him to flounder alone, and there was this whole tiny middle step I’d missed. I didn’t have to re-teach him multiplication every night. I just had to give him one small, concrete thing to do when his brain went blank, instead of rescuing him immediately.
When I got home that day, I wrote the three prompts on a crumpled index card and taped it to the edge of our kitchen table, right where he spreads out his homework every night. I stopped pulling up a chair next to him unless he’d run through the three checks and still couldn’t name what was tripping him up. Most nights, I don’t even look up from what I’m doing when he says that line now. I just say “run the three checks first,” and half the time he mutters through them and figures it out before I finish folding the next towel. I also started pausing before I step in for tiny, non-homework things, too, which sounds silly but it adds up. If he’s grunting trying to twist open his water bottle, I count to 10 in my head before I offer to help. Half the time he gets it open himself. If he’s struggling to force a Lego piece into the spaceship he’s building, I don’t lean over and snap it in for him. I just say “try turning it the other way” and go back to washing dishes.
It doesn’t work every night. Last week he had soccer practice until 5:30, he was tired and hungry and his socks were itchy, and he crumpled up his math worksheet after two problems and said the whole thing was stupid. I didn’t make him finish. I flattened it out, wrote a note to Ms. Henderson that said he put in 15 minutes of independent work and hit a wall, and we sent it back the next day. She wrote back that half the class crumpled that same problem, it was a hard one, and she went over it with them at morning meeting. We don’t do sticker charts or big celebrations when he gets a problem right, either. The other morning I was buttering toast and I heard him mutter the three checks to himself while he worked on morning work before school, and I didn’t say a word. If I’d cheered and made a big deal out of it, he would have gotten self-conscious and stopped doing it.
Last night he looked up from his worksheet halfway through, grinned, and said “you guys, I just did three whole problems all by myself.” He still says “guys” even when it’s just the cat and me in the room. Some nights, if I’m tired too and we just need to get through bedtime, I still sit next to him and walk him through a hard problem, or let him skip the last one if he’s put the work in. It’s not a perfect system. I still catch myself grabbing his water bottle before I count to 10 some days. But most of the time, when that blank “how do I do it” look crosses his face now, I don’t panic. I just nod at the scuffed index card on the table, and he leans back over his paper.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When My 8-Year-Old Said “How Do I Do It, Guys