When LA Finally Gave Us Real School Choice Info, This Is What Actually Went Down
I’m sitting on a splintered park bench right now waiting for my son to get out of first grade, and I can still remember how stressed I was three years ago, doing kindergarten applications. Back before the district rolled out that new transparent school choice dashboard, everything was just guesswork. Wait, I should back up. Before this new system, school choice in LA was basically a game of telephone played by stressed out people all convinced one wrong move would ruin their kid’s third grade experience. Or at least that’s what it felt like for me.
I remember I cornered a mom at that little coffee shop by the 101 Silver Lake offramp once, back in 2020, right when applications opened. I’d heard her kid went to that elementary everyone whispered about, the one with the sky-high test scores. I bought her a latte, asked her what it was really like, how the teachers were with wiggly, disaster-prone kindergartners. She just got all tight around the eyes, stirred her drink super hard, said “It’s fine” and then bailed for a meeting. I found out later she thought if more people applied, her kid’s chance of getting in went down. That’s how the old system worked—everyone hoarded info, because no one wanted to lose their spot. It was gross, honestly.
When the district finally launched that new dashboard, I stayed up till 1 a.m. drinking flat lemon seltzer and scrolling it, half convinced it was too good to be true. It wasn’t just the generic test scores everyone posted before, the numbers that don’t tell you anything about what it’s actually like to drop your kid off there every day. It had actual stuff parents ask each other in playground huddles: how many full-time nurses on staff, what aftercare cost and how long the waitlist was, what percentage of teachers had been at the school more than two years, even how many bike racks there were for the after-school bike club. I’d been leaning hard towards that popular charter 20 minutes from my house, but I clicked through and saw it had no full-time nurse. My son has asthma, that’s not a small thing for me. Before the dashboard, I’d left three messages for the district office and never heard back about nurse hours. That one detail changed everything for me. I ended up ranking our local zoned school second, got in, and that’s where he is now. It’s more than fine.
My nanny, Lupe, lives in South LA, has a 6 year old. Before the dashboard came out, she just assumed she had to send her kid to the zoned school that everyone online said was falling apart. She doesn’t have a big network of other professional parents to swap gossip with, works two jobs, doesn’t have time to drive across town for all the fancy parent mix-ins on the westside. The new dashboard was fully translated into Spanish, all the info was there in plain language, no jargon, and she saw that there’s a dual-language immersion school 10 minutes from her apartment, with free busing, and 80% of the teachers have been there more than five years. She applied, got in, and her kid’s now in first grade reading in both English and Spanish. She told me last week she never would have found that if the info hadn’t been right there, easy to access. That’s the big win no one talks about much, right? Wealthy parents already had all this info, through consultants and their neighbors and whatever. It was the rest of us that were flying blind.
But it’s not all good. Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t some “transparency fixed everything” story. That popular elementary in Los Feliz everyone already loved? Applications jumped 40% the first year the dashboard went up, because all the info about their low class sizes and full-time art teacher was out in the open. They had to put three portable classrooms where the kids’ community garden used to be. Now the garden’s crammed along the side of the parking lot, half the plants get run over by parent SUVs dropping kids off. That sucks. And I know a mom, Mia, who picked that super high-test-score magnet in Silver Lake because the dashboard said it had a 12:1 student teacher ratio. She didn’t read the fine print that it’s a gifted magnet, and the whole program is built for kids who can sit still for three hours of independent work. Her son has ADHD, he hated it, they switched after one semester. Better info doesn’t mean you know what questions to ask, I guess. Not when you’re stressed and sleep-deprived and just trying to check all the boxes.
Some people act like better school choice info will fix all of LA’s public school problems. That’s bullshit. It didn’t fix the fact that schools in wealthier neighborhoods still get hundreds of thousands of extra dollars every year from parent associations, while schools in poor neighborhoods can’t afford new textbooks. It didn’t fix the fact that if you work two jobs, you can’t take three hours off on a Wednesday to go to an open house, even if you know the school exists. It didn’t undo 100 years of segregation that’s baked into every neighborhood and every school zone in this city.
Last month I saw that mom I cornered at the coffee shop back in 2020, here at the park pickup. We got to talking, and she laughed about that day, said she was just so stressed back then, convinced if her kid didn’t get that spot she’d messed him up for life. Now she tells everyone she meets all the details about the school, good and bad. That’s a small change, but it’s something. I don’t have a big neat conclusion here. It’s just better than it was. Not perfect. Just better.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When LA Finally Gave Us Real School Choice Info, This Is What Actually Went Down