When Did Middle Schoolers Get So Tall? What Parents and Teachers Should Know
I was reaching for the box of extra composition notebooks on the top shelf of my 7th grade classroom closet yesterday, and a student brushed past me to grab it before I could even drag out the step stool. He wears size 11 basketball sneakers that leave faint scuffs on the linoleum, and when he stood up straight after grabbing the box, his shoulder hit me right at chin level. I’m 5’7”, average for an adult woman. I joked, “When did 12-year-olds turn into NBA power forwards?” He grinned and said his mom buys all his jeans two inches too long, just so he can grow into them before winter break. That checks out—he’s already outgrown two pairs this school year.
I’ve been teaching middle school for 12 years, so I don’t just notice this change—I measure it in small, daily ways. When I started, only two or three 8th graders were taller than me. Now, I have at least seven 7th graders that beat my height in any given class. Last month, when we lined up for the yearly class photo, I had to add an entire extra back row I didn’t need a decade ago. A parent mentioned the same thing at back-to-school night last fall: she takes her 11-year-old son to the pediatrician every six months, and the nurse keeps marking him off the growth chart at the 95th percentile, just shaking her head.
Last week, I sat with a mom during parent-teacher conferences who brought up a frustration I’d never really thought through before. Her 11-year-old daughter is 5’8”, already taller than her mom. When they go to the grocery store, cashiers and other shoppers treat her like she’s a 16-year-old. If she gets upset about a misplaced cookie in her cart, people side-eye her mom like she’s raising an unruly teen, not a kid who still sleeps with a stuffed unicorn. Last month, at the school playground, her daughter got into a tiff with a first grader over a swing, and another parent immediately stepped in, yelling at my student for picking on a little kid—before she even asked what happened. It turned out the first grader had pushed my student first.
I looked this up a few months ago, out of curiosity. It’s a well-documented shift over the last century: kids have been getting taller and hitting puberty earlier, mostly thanks to better overall nutrition and healthcare. CDC data puts the average 12-year-old girl about an inch and a half taller than she was 40 years ago, and the average 12-year-old boy is almost an inch taller. It’s a small shift on paper, but it adds up when you’re standing in a classroom full of kids that tower over your storage shelves.
The real issue isn’t the height itself, though. It’s that our expectations haven’t caught up. When a kid looks like an adult, we automatically expect them to act like one, even if their brain is still very much that of an 11, 12, or 13-year-old. That mismatch creates all kinds of small, unfair stress for kids and the adults that care for them.
I’ve had to adjust a lot of small habits in my classroom over the last five years, things I never thought I’d need to change. I used to automatically ask the tallest kid in class to move heavy lab tables or hang bulletin board borders, just because they could reach. Now I ask for volunteers, regardless of height. A 5’10” 7th grader might have asthma, or hate lifting heavy things, just like any shorter kid. I also caught myself raising my voice more when correcting misbehavior from taller kids, because I assumed “they should know better” based on their size. Now I make a point to use the same calm, matter-of-fact tone for every kid, no matter how big they are.
I saved up a little extra PTA money last year and bought three adjustable-height chairs for the back of my room. The old chairs I’ve had for a decade don’t fit taller kids—their knees hit the bottom of the desk, and they spend the whole class slouching just to fit. Any kid can swap their chair if they need more room, no questions asked. It’s a small change that’s cut down on fidgeting and discomfort more than I expected.
For parents, the mom I talked to at conferences shared a trick that’s worked for her: when they go to crowded places like amusement parks or community events, she has her daughter wear a woven wristband that says “6th grade” on it. It’s a quiet way to clue other adults in to her actual age, so they don’t expect teen-level maturity from a pre-teen. She also has a rule for relatives: if the first thing you say to my kid is “wow you’re so tall,” you have to follow it up with a question about her favorite video game or her art class. Tall kids get so used to being commented on for their size that it starts to feel like that’s the only thing people notice about them. I’ve started doing the same thing in my class—instead of leading with a comment about a growth spurt when I see a kid after break, I just ask about their trip.
Last week, that same 7th grader who grabbed the notebook for me stayed after class to help me move my heavy podium to the other side of the room. He joked that by next year, he’ll be able to change the light bulbs in the ceiling without the step stool. I laughed, but I also caught myself about to make a comment about how he’ll be driving before I know it. I stopped myself, and instead asked him how his tryouts for the basketball team went. He lit up talking about his first practice, and I remembered: for all his height, he’s still just a 12-year-old kid who gets nervous for tryouts and forgets his homework twice a week.
I still slip up sometimes. It’s hard to rewire a habit of matching expectations to size, after all. But it’s worth the small effort. Kids are growing faster than our chairs, our clothing budgets, and our old ideas of what a middle schooler should look like. All we have to do is adjust our expectations to fit them, not the other way around.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Did Middle Schoolers Get So Tall