When Another Kid’s Parents Won’t Let Their Child Hang Out With Yours: What I Learned As A Mom And Teacher
Last Saturday, my 11-year-old daughter Lila was lacing up her scuffed neon high-tops by the front door, twisting the rainbow friendship bracelet she’d spent three nights braiding between her fingers. She’d been talking all week about Mia, the new friend she met in after-school art club who also draws Warrior Cats original characters and hates the same overly hard math worksheets. Mia was supposed to come over for a movie and pizza afternoon, and Lila had already cleared the coffee table for their sketchbooks. Then my phone buzzed.
The text was from Mia’s mom: “So sorry to spring this on you last minute. We’ve decided Mia can’t come over today. Hope you understand.” I stared at it for a minute, then typed back asking if everything was okay. Ten minutes later, she sent a longer reply: She and her husband looked over their household rules, and they don’t feel comfortable with Mia hanging out at our house right now. They’d seen my Instagram posts of Lila climbing oak trees at the park and letting her pick her own bedtime on weekends, and they’re worried Lila’s “laid-back boundaries” will influence Mia to push their rules too much.
I had to tell Lila. She took off her shoes, set the bracelet on the entry table, and walked up to her room without saying anything. I followed a minute later, and that’s where I drew on what I’ve learned after seven years working as a 4th grade paraprofessional. I see this exact situation play out every few months, between all kinds of families. What I didn’t do was the thing I’ve seen so many parents do: I didn’t badmouth Mia’s parents to Lila, I didn’t tell her we didn’t want to be friends with them anyway, and I didn’t brush off her hurt by saying she could just find another friend. Instead, I sat down next to her on her bed where she was hiding under her weighted blanket, and I said, “That sucks so bad. I know how excited you were. This isn’t your fault, okay?”
Most of the time, when another parent blocks a friendship, it feels like a personal attack. I’ll admit, I was stung for an hour after that text. I kept replaying it, thinking about what I must have done wrong, what Lila must have done wrong. But after years of working with kids and their families, I’ve learned most of the time it’s not about you, or your kid. It’s about the other parent’s own comfort level, their own fixed ideas of what good parenting looks like. Sometimes it’s even about stuff going on in their house that you’ll never know about. One time last year, I had a student whose parents wouldn’t let him hang out with a classmate because the classmate’s parents were divorced, and they thought that would “confuse” him. It had nothing to do with the kid, who was one of the kindest, most well-behaved kids in the whole class.
Lila nodded into her blanket when I asked if she still wanted to be friends with Mia, and that was that. I emailed the art club teacher, explained the situation politely, asked if the girls could sit together at club each week, and if she could keep a casual eye on them to make sure everything was okay. Mia’s parents were fine with that – they just didn’t want Mia at our house, not no contact at all. So that’s our new normal. Every Wednesday, Lila goes to art club, sits next to Mia, they draw and pass notes between projects, and she comes home with little trinkets Mia slipped her: a glitter sticker, a half-used pack of colored pencils, a crumpled drawing of their two warrior cats side by side.
A lot of other parents have asked me what to do when this happens to them, so I don’t give vague advice about “being supportive” or “communicating better.” I share the small, concrete things that worked for us. First, don’t dump your hurt or anger on your kid. It’s okay to feel mad or embarrassed – go vent to your best friend or your partner when your kid isn’t around. Your kid didn’t do anything wrong, and they don’t need to carry the weight of your frustration, or feel like they have to take sides. Second, look for a neutral middle ground if you can. You don’t have to force a sleepover at your house, and you don’t have to cut the friendship off entirely. School, after-school clubs, the public park during busy weekend hours, local library events – all of these are neutral spaces where kids can hang out without either set of parents having to host. Third, talk to your kid clearly about why rules work differently for different families. I said to Lila, “Mia’s parents have different ideas about what’s okay for her than we do for you. That doesn’t mean they’re bad people, and it doesn’t mean we’re bad people. It just means your friendship has to look a little different than other kids’ friendships right now.” That helped her stop assuming she’d done something to turn them off, which is what most kids think first when this happens.
It’s not a perfect situation. Last month, there was a small birthday gathering for another art club kid at my house, and Mia couldn’t come. Lila was disappointed for an hour, but she wrapped up two extra cupcakes in a napkin and brought them to art club for Mia the next day. We still wave at Mia’s mom in the school pickup line, and it’s awkward, but it’s fine. I don’t know if things will change in a year, if Mia’s parents will ever feel comfortable letting Mia come over, or if Lila will even want to be friends this time next year. Right now, though, it’s enough that two kids who like the same things get to see each other once a week. Lila’s learning that relationships don’t have to look perfect to matter, and I’ve been reminded that sometimes the best thing we can do as parents is step back and let the kids have their messy, in-between friendships, instead of trying to fix every awkward thing that comes up.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Another Kid’s Parents Won’t Let Their Child Hang Out With Yours: What I Learned As A Mom And Teacher